Xuebin Houabc,
Wei Chena,
Meihong Fanabc and
Chen Shi*a
aCollege of Textile Science and Engineering, Zhejiang Sci-Tech University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province 310018, PR China. E-mail: chenshi2021@zstu.edu.cn
bZhejiang Sci-Tech University Shengzhou Innovation Research Institute, Shaoxing, Zhejiang Province 310018, PR China
cZhejiang Sci-Tech University Tongxiang Innovation Research Institute, Jiaxing, Zhejiang Province 310018, PR China
First published on 11th November 2024
Chitosan (CS) is regarded as a promising sorbent due to its biodegradability, wide availability, easy processing, and multiple active groups. In this work, CS-based porous fibers (ZIF-n@CS) consisting of CS and zeolitic imidazolate frameworks (ZIFs) were fabricated through wet spinning and self-assembly methods. This combination effectively utilizes the dual advantages of CS and ZIFs, which effectively remove dyes from water and exhibit excellent recyclability. In addition, the adsorption mechanism of the adsorbent was explored through the analysis of adsorption kinetics, thermodynamics, isotherms, and chemical characterization after adsorption. This work provides an operable and universal strategy for the efficient adsorption of dyes, promoting the further promotion and application of MOFs and CS materials.
The use of adsorption methods for removing dyes and heavy metal ions in wastewater offers technical advantages, including high efficiency, simple operation, and low cost.5–7 Compared to other treatment methods such as membrane filtration and flocculation, adsorption poses a lower risk of secondary pollution; therefore, numerous sorbents have been developed for various desired environments.8 Among these sorbents, naturally degradable polysaccharide polymers (such as chitosan, cellulose, and lignin) have been explored as effective adsorbents for organic synthetic dyes. Chitosan (CS) is regarded as a practical sorbent due to its wide availability, easy processing, multiple active groups, and high adsorption capacity.9 Current research primarily focuses on modifying substrates or combining them with other nanomaterials of high porosity to achieve efficient adsorption of individual pollutants.10–12 However, due to economic considerations and the wide range of pollutants present, single-function adsorbents are no longer sufficient to meet the current demands of wastewater treatment. Therefore, combining CS with other materials is a potential strategy to fabricate a multi-functional adsorbent.13,14
Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) are porous materials created by linking metal ions and organic ligands through coordination bonds. They offer benefits such as high porosity, specific surface area, adjustable structure, and easy functionalization.15–17 In recent years, the application of metal–organic framework (MOFs) materials in air and water filtration has garnered significant attention from researchers. The adsorbent materials derived from MOFs exhibit a high specific surface area,18 excellent chemical stability, and a distinctive porous structure, all of which contribute to their exceptional adsorption properties. As a typical series of MOFs, zeolitic imidazolate frameworks (ZIFs) have been reported to exhibit a good adsorption property in some published works.19 However, due to their granular form, ZIFs pose challenges in terms of recycling and reusability, thereby hindering their further development and application. Fibers have emerged as prominent substrates for carrying particulate matter in research due to their elongated shape, high specific surface area, and flexibility.
In view of the above consideration, we have successfully combined chitosan with zeolitic imidazolate framework-8 (ZIF-8) nanomaterials using the self-assembly method in this study, to effectively remove dyes from water. The adsorption property of ZIF-8@CS was evaluated, and results indicated that it has great removal performance for dyes and good recyclability. In addition, the natural factors influencing the adsorption capacity and recycling performance of this composite material were investigated. Through the analysis of adsorption kinetics, thermodynamics, isotherms, and other theoretical models, we aim to gain a comprehensive understanding of its adsorption behavior. Additionally, we conducted a thorough characterization of the fibers before and after adsorption using techniques such as XPS and FT-IR. This work provides an applied strategy for the efficient adsorption of dyes and it will promote the further promotion and application of MOFs and CS materials.
(3-1) |
(3-2) |
C0 (mg L−1) and represents the initial concentration of the dye solution, Ce (mg L−1) and Ct(mg L−1) represent the concentration at the adsorption equilibrium and at a certain moment, respectively.
For cyclic adsorption-regeneration experiments, following the dye adsorption experiment, the adsorbent was successfully regenerated through multiple washings with DMF. The ratio of the adsorbent to DMF washing solution was maintained at 0.3 mg mL−1. The washing procedure took place on a constant temperature shaking bed for a duration of 5 h, and the washing was repeated three times until the washing liquid became colorless. Subsequently, the adsorption experiment was resumed.
For selectivity adsorption experiments, the binary mixed dye solution was pre-configured, the concentration of a single component in the mixed dye solution was controlled to be 30 mg L−1, and the adsorption experiment was carried out on the shaking table at 25 °C after adding an appropriate amount of the adsorbent. After the adsorption equilibrium, the dye concentration tests were performed using UV-vis.
SEM images of ZIF-8@CS, ZIF-67@CS, and Zn–Co-ZIF@CS composite fibers correspond to (a), (b), and (c) in Fig. 2, respectively. The images reveal the distinctive 12-hedral structures characteristic of zinc-based and cobalt-based ZIF materials, indicating the successful synthesis of these materials.21 Furthermore, the SEM images show that ZIF particles were self-assembled onto the chitosan fibers. Fig. 2d presents the mapping image of bimetallic Zn–Co-ZIF nanoparticles on the Zn–Co-ZIF@CS, demonstrating accurate detection of the major metal ions, Zn and Co, and their elemental distribution. This confirms the successful synthesis of the bimetallic ZIF material ZIF-678 (Zn:Co = 1:1).
Fig. 2 SEM images of ZIF-8@CS (a), ZIF-67@CS (b) and Zn–Co-ZIF@CS (c), and SEM mapping images of Zn–Co-ZIF@CS (d). |
Fig. 3 displays the XRD patterns and adsorption properties of ZIF-8, CS, and ZIF-8@CS fibers towards different dyes. The diffraction peaks observed in ZIF-8@CS composite fiber samples were located at 7.3°, 10.3°, 12.7°, 14.6°, 16.4°, and 17.9°, corresponding to the (011), (002), (112), (022), (013), and (222) crystal planes, respectively, as documented in previous studies.22–24 This observation confirms the successful synthesis of ZIF-8 on the CS fiber matrix, with the crystal structure of ZIF-8 remaining unchanged throughout the self-assembly growth process. Comparative experiments were conducted on the adsorption of ZIF-8@CS, ZIF-67@CS, and Zn–Co-ZIF@CS fibers with various dyes, as illustrated in Fig. 3b. Overall, the adsorption efficiency of the three fibers for MG and CR dyes surpassed that of other dyes, with ZIF-8@CS exhibiting the most effective dye removal between the three composite fibers. Compared with pure CS fibers (Fig. S6†), the adsorption efficiency of MOFs-n@CS composite fibers was obviously improved. It illustrates that MOFs plays a key role in the adsorption of dyes. In consideration of the better stability of the ZIF-8 in an aqueous environment,25 further investigations were focused on the adsorption behavior of ZIF-8@CS towards MG and CR dyes.
Fig. 3 (a) XRD patterns of ZIF-8, CS and ZIF-8@CS and (b) comparison of adsorption properties of ZIF-67@CS, ZIF-8@CS and Zn–Co-ZIF@CS composite fibers adsorbents for different dyes. |
The adsorption efficiency of an adsorbent is influenced by the concentration of the adsorbate.25 Generally, the adsorption capacity of the adsorbent is fixed, but under too high or low-concentration conditions, this capacity may not be fully utilized. At low concentrations, the likelihood of contact between the adsorbent and adsorbate decreases, making it challenging for the adsorbate to be completely removed from the solution even if there are sufficient adsorption sites. Conversely, the adsorbate molecules tend to aggregate in high-concentration environments, leading to rapid occupation of the adsorbent surface and blockage of adsorption channels, thus diminishing the adsorption capacity of the adsorbent.
Therefore, the removal efficiency of ZIF-8@CS for dye solutions with varying concentrations was evaluated (Fig. 4). The results illustrated a gradual decrease in removal efficiency as the concentration of the dye solution increased. This phenomenon can be attributed to the distribution of dye molecules as monomers in low-concentration environments, allowing for effective contact with adsorption sites and leading to higher removal efficiency. Conversely, in high-concentration environments, adsorption sites become saturated with dye molecules, resulting in diminished post-equilibrium removal efficiency. The optimal performance of ZIF-8@CS composite fiber was observed when the dye concentration did not exceed 100 mg L−1. Furthermore, distinct differences were noted in the adsorption behavior of ZIF-8@CS composite fiber towards the two dyes. Specifically, at low concentrations, the removal rate of MG surpassed that of CR, possibly due to the smaller molecular size of MG. While at high concentrations, the removal rate of CR exceeded that of MG, potentially due to stronger stacking interactions among the MG molecules. Experimental results indicated adsorption capacities of 568.47 mg g−1 for CR and 412.75 mg L−1 for MG.
Fig. 4 The removal rate curves of ZIF-8@CS for different initial concentrations of MG and CR dye solutions. |
For a specific concentration of the dye liquor, there exists an optimal amount of adsorbent that matches it. This ideal ratio of the adsorbent to dye liquor maximizes the efficiency of the adsorbent.26 Excessive use of the adsorbent in an environment with a certain dye liquor concentration can lead to economic waste and suboptimal utilization of the adsorbent. Consequently, exploratory experiments were carried out. Fig. 5 illustrates that the ZIF-8@CS composite fiber's adsorption of the two dyes (CR and MG) follows a similar process, where the removal efficiency Re gradually increases with the amount of the adsorbent, while the unit adsorption capacity Qe subsequently decreases due to the provision of adequate adsorption sites by the optimal amount of the adsorbent. The experiment concluded that for dye liquor concentrations <100 ppm, an adsorbent dosage of 0.6 g L−1 can guarantee a removal rate exceeding 96% and achieve the highest level of adsorbent utilization efficiency.
Fig. 5 Removal efficiency curves of CR (a) and MG (b) dyes with different adsorbent ZIF-8@CS dosages (Re: removal efficiency; Qe: adsorption capacity). |
Fig. 6a and b illustrates the removal performance of ZIF-8@CS for CR and MG dyes at varying pH levels. The figure demonstrates that the composite fiber's adsorption behavior towards the two dyes exhibits contrasting characteristics in response to changes in pH. Specifically, the adsorption of CR dye shows a decrease in the removal rate with increasing alkalinity, whereas the adsorption of MG displays a decrease in the removal rate with stronger acidity. This trend could be attributed to the potential of the dyes and the protonation of the functional groups on ZIF-8@CS. Specifically, CR and MG dyes exhibit opposite behaviors when dissolved in water due to their different electronegativity. The ZETA potential performance of ZIF-8@CS at various pH levels suggests that the electronegativity of ZIF-8@CS is enhanced in an alkaline environment, leading to electrostatic force repulsion due to the negatively charged CR dye molecules. Conversely, in an acidic environment, the positive charge of ZIF-8@CS increased, resulting in electrostatic attraction toward negatively charged CR. Therefore, the removal rate of CR decreases with higher alkalinity, while the opposite effect is observed for MG.
In environments where dyes are used daily, sodium salts are commonly added to dye solutions as fixing or coloring agents. These sodium salts are often discharged into dye wastewater, becoming a significant factor in dye adsorption. To investigate this, we conducted a single variable comparison experiment. The result shows (illustrated in Fig. 6d) that in an environment with a specific amount of adsorbent and dye solution concentration, the overall dye removal rate decreases as the sodium concentration increases. The impact on MG is more pronounced than on CR, attributed to the ion shielding effect. The presence of sodium salt shields the electrical properties of both the dye and adsorbent, diminishing the electrostatic interaction between them. The disparity in the removal rates between CR and MG could be attributed to the varying strength of this shielding effect. At pH 7, the ZIF-8@CS composite fiber should exhibit electrostatic repulsion towards CR molecules and electrostatic attraction towards MG molecules. However, the presence of sodium salt weakens both the repulsion and attraction. Consequently, CR dye molecules can penetrate deeper into the adsorption site, while MG molecules find it more challenging to enter, resulting in the discrepancy in removal rates between the two.
In the context of printing and dyeing wastewater treatment, adsorbents are exposed to a wide range of pollutants. An important consideration for the practicality and efficiency of adsorbents is whether they can selectively adsorb specific substances from a diverse mixture of pollutants. This is crucial because if adsorbents lack selective adsorption capabilities, they would need to possess high adsorption capacity to effectively treat mixed dye solutions. Additionally, the process of dye desorption typically requires a significant amount of elution solvent, making it challenging to reuse the mixed dye solution afterwards. Hence, this study delves into the selective adsorption properties of ZIF-8@CS composite fibers in binary mixed dye scenarios. As depicted in Fig. 7, the ZIF-8@CS composite fiber demonstrates favorable adsorption selectivity in the binary mixed systems of MG + MB, MG + SY, and MG + CV. The selectivity observed in the MG + MB and MG + CV systems may be attributed to factors such as the shape and size of the dye molecules, hydrogen bond energy, and intermolecular interactions. Conversely, in the MG + SY system, the selectivity of the adsorbent is likely influenced by electrostatic forces. The negatively charged ZIF-8@CS composite fibers attract positively charged MG molecules while repelling the negatively charged anionic dye SY. During the adsorption process, these influencing factors may act simultaneously. Furthermore, the result illustrates that the ZIF-8@CS composite fiber does not exhibit selectivity for CR.
The results from Fig. 8 suggest that the experimental data of CR is better fitted with the pseudo-second-order kinetic model. While the pseudo-first-order kinetic model is more suitable for MG adsorption with a fitting degree of 0.99. Besides, the Weber–Morris model was applied for kinetic analysis (shown in Fig. 8c and d), through the analysis of the fitting data, it can be proved that the adsorption process of ZIF-8@CS is controlled by not only a single factor, which indicates that there are other factors affecting the adsorption rates besides the diffusion rate of dye molecules. CR is an anionic dye and in a neutral environment, the adsorption of CR by ZIF-8@CS is mainly due to the formation of chemical bonds with functional groups such as hydroxyl and amino groups on the surface of the adsorbent, which may also include hydrogen bonds, π–π accumulation and van der Waals forces. Electrostatic force does not play a dominant role in this system.27,28 The adsorption of MG, a cationic dye, and the adsorption rate of ZIF-8@CS on MG is predominantly influenced by the diffusion rate of the dye molecules, and it is consistent with the ZETA potential results. The electrostatic attraction between ZIF-8@CS and MG molecules emerges as the primary factor affecting dye diffusion.
From Fig. 9, it can be concluded that the Langmuir model is more suitable for explaining the CR adsorption process of the ZIF-8@CS composite fiber compared to the MG, suggesting that the adsorption process of ZIF-8@CS for CR follows a point-to-point single-layer uniform adsorption process, while the adsorption process for MG is better explained by the Freundlich model.
Fig. 9 (a and b) Fitting of the Langmuir model for adsorption isothermal plots of ZIF-8@CS toward MG and CR; (c and d) Freundlich model for adsorption isothermal plots of ZIF-8@CS toward MG and CR. |
The recyclability of the adsorbent is a critical factor in determining its practical applicability. Fig. 10 illustrates that while the removal efficiency gradually decreases with each cycle, it remains above 90% for a 50 mg L−1 dye solution even after 6 cycles. The adsorption of ZIF-8@CS on CR and MG shows a slight decrease of 7.8% and 8.7% respectively, suggesting that ZIF-8@CS can be regenerated and reused. The decline in the removal efficiency may be attributed to the type of eluent used and the stability of ZIF-8. When using the organic solvent DMF as an eluent, it may not completely displace all dye molecules, leading to some adsorption sites on the ZIF-8@CS surface remaining occupied during subsequent cycles, thereby causing a reduction in the removal efficiency.
FT-IR analysis of ZIF-8@CS was conducted pre- and post-dye adsorption to investigate the adsorption mechanism (Fig. S5†). The results revealed a shift towards blue in the hydroxyl peaks at 3382 cm−1 after CR and MG adsorption, suggesting the formation of new hydrogen bonds during the process. Additionally, the absorption peak at 420 cm−1 attributed to Zn–N stretching vibration exhibited a blue shift post-adsorption, suggesting new coordination was formed. This coordination potentially involves Zn with –NH2 and –SO3 in CR dye molecules or C–N bonds with MG dye molecules.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ra06883a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |