Chaoui Khaoulaa,
Halima Zaaria,
Abdelilah Benyoussefab,
Abdellah El Kenza,
Mohammed Loulidia,
Hajar Moatassim*a,
Mourad Boujnahc,
Francisco Javier Espinosa-Fallerd and
Felipe Caballero-Briones*e
aLaboratory of Condensed Matter and Interdisciplinary Sciences (LaMCScI), “Unité de Recherche Labellisée CNRST URL-CNRST-17” Physics Department, Faculty of Sciences, Mohammed V University, B.P. 1014, Rabat, Morocco. E-mail: hajarmoatassim1@gmail.com
bHassan II Academy of Science and Technology, Rabat, Morocco
cCINVESTAV-Querétaro, Libramiento Norponiente 2000, 76226 Juriquilla, Mexico
dEscuela de Ingeniería, Universidad Marista de Mérida, Periférico Norte Tablaje Catastral 13941, Temozón Nte, 97300 Merida, Mexico
eInstituto Politécnico Nacional, Materiales y Tecnologías para Energía, Salud y Medio Ambiente (GESMAT), CICATA Altamira. Km 14.5 Carretera Tampico-Puerto Industrial, 89600 Altamira, Mexico. E-mail: fcaballero@ipn.mx
First published on 11th December 2024
CdS(Se)/graphene oxide (GO) heterostructures have received significant attention due to their potential application in optoelectronic devices with tunable bandgap, efficient charge transfer, and enhanced photocatalytic and photovoltaic activity. In this work, Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations of the photocatalytic properties of CdS(Se)/GO heterostructures were performed. The results of work function, band gap, optical absorption, and band edges of CdS and CdSe in the (001) and (110) directions on graphene oxide are presented. Various approaches to simulate graphene oxide with a different concentration of oxygen, and their subsequent integration into CdS (Se)-GO heterostructures are discussed. DFT calculations were employed to determine the equilibrium value and adhesion energy for various compositions of layers at the interface, as well as different stacking arrangements between graphene oxide and CdS slabs. The results revealed that some oxygen atoms migrate to the CdS matrix and form bonds with Cd atoms. It was observed that the semiconductor band gap can be controlled by the oxidation degree in graphene oxide, and the electronic properties of CdS(Se) depend on the semiconductor orientation and slab number. Notably, surface states are found to be responsible for the negative part of the dielectric function at low frequencies, significantly influencing the electronic properties and charge transfer dynamics. The results show that both structures form type II heterostructures, which is promising for photocatalytic hydrogen generation.
By utilizing semiconductor materials and light energy, photocatalysis is a promising green process for water treatment. Recent research has shown that graphene oxide and reduced graphene oxide (rGO) composite materials have potential for use in photocatalysis, supercapacitors, batteries, and solar cells.2 This is primarily due to rGO's properties such as exceptional carrier mobility and high electrical conductivity, as well as its large surface area and additional high reactivity in the case of GO.3 In particular, rGO decorated with copper and silver nanoparticles has shown remarkable effectiveness in degrading water pollutant in a short time. Studies have reported a removal efficiency of 100% of methylene blue (MB) dyes within just after 40 minutes of exposure to the rGO–copper–silver photocatalyst.4 Furthermore, rGO has proven to be a highly effective enhancer of the photoactivity of cadmium sulfide (CdS) in nanocomposites. Studies have shown that the incorporation of graphene oxide into CdS-based nanocomposites results in an increased number of active sites, reduced electron–hole recombination rates, and improved light absorption in the visible and infrared regions of the electromagnetic spectrum, compared to pure CdS.5 CdS exhibits three different structures at ambient conditions, the wurtzite (WZ)-type structure, the cubic hawleyite zinc blende structure and the cubic rocksalt structure.6 Properties of CdS can also been manipulated when doping with different elements of the periodic table. It has been shown that doping with nonmagnetic elements can enhance the magnetic properties of materials for use as diluted magnetic semiconductors (DMS).7 Early experimental works have studied the effect of doping CdS by an amount of N-graphene.8 Their studies demonstrate that the radiative recombination in the N-graphene/CdS nanocomposites has been impeded due to the natural transfer of the excited electrons into the N-doped graphene, resulting in a considerable enhancement of its photocatalytic activity. The latter can be further improved by controlling the systems nanoarchitectures and increasing the interface coupling in this nanoarchitectures. The study of CdS(0001)/graphene and CdS/graphene bilayer in ref. 9 suggests that boron doping strengthens adhesion in the interface of CdS(0001)/graphene in contrast to the CdS/graphene bilayer where no effect on the interface was noted. An experimental study of a rGO/CdS heterojunction using X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy revealed a strong chemical-interaction at the rGO–CdS interface which facilitates the photoelectron transfer from CdS to rGO, which in turn increases the flow of electrons to the solid–liquid interface, leading to a superior enhancement of the photocatalytic activity of the rGO/CdS, also used for hydrogen production,10 which lead to a photocatalytic hydrogen production as high as 1701 μmol h−1 g−1.11
Other studies aiming to produce high-efficient photocatalytic hydrogen generation have synthesized the CoP/CdS/rGO in the presence of an internal electric field, the electrons, in the CoP/CdS/rGO photocatalysts, are transferred via “charge transfer channel” of graphene from CdS to CoP resulting in a photocatalytic activity of 104 mmol h−1.12
The formation of an active heterojunction in supported-photocatalysts is crucial for efficient photocatalysis in hydrogen production and pollutant degradation. However, detailed information at the atomic level on these heterojunctions studies is required to achieve fine tuning of the optoelectronic properties and device performance. Recently, X-ray absorption studies revealed that the decoration of graphene oxide (GO) with CdS1−xSex generates bonds between the carbon matrix and Cd, or between S/Se and the oxygen groups in GO.13,14 In that work, a semi-empirical electronic diagram has been proposed to explain some experimental properties, including photocurrent generation. Experimental evidence shows changes in the density of unoccupied states in CdS1−xSex–GO compared to pristine CdS1−xSex, indicating the injection of conduction band carriers from the semiconductor into graphene oxide. Moreover, the photocurrent in GO/CdSSe/GO/FTO multilayers has been found to be stable, almost independent of the applied electrochemical potential, while the magnitude of the photocurrent is observed to depend on the number of GO/CdSSe/GO multilayers.3
By examining the available data and previous studies on CdS(Se)/GO(rGO), the primary objective of the present work is to conduct a theoretical investigation of the interface effect on the electronic and photocatalytic properties. First, the number of CdS and CdSe slabs necessary to reproduce the bulk properties for both orientation (110) and (001) is varied systematically to identify the configuration that best aligns with the bulk behavior observed in experimental data. Thereafter, the band structure, electronic properties and electronic diagrams of the CdS/GO heterostructures are built to assess the potential photocatalytic behavior. Work functions and band edges are computed in order to explain the type of heterostructure formed and the mechanisms of charge transfer between GO and CdS(Se).
All structural models were fully optimized until forces were less than 10−3 eV Å−1 with an energy convergence of 10−8 eV between consecutive self-consistent steps. To reduce the effect of periodic images, a vacuum space of 10 Å was applied perpendicularly to the slab.
CdS(Se)/GO heterostructures studied in this work were made using two orientation, (110) and (001) for both CdS and CdSe. Fig. 1 represents the CdS/GO heterostructure before and after relaxation.
Fig. 1 Crystal structure of CdS/GO (a) top view (b) side view for CdS in 110 direction and (c) CdS/GO in 001 direction. |
CdS has wurtzite structure, and graphene oxide has hexagonal 2D structure, to avoid the mismatch problem between both structures, we use a 4 × 2 supercell of graphene oxide combined with a 3 × 2 supercell of CdS and CdSe to introduce a minimal mean absolute strain of 2.4% during the optimization of the CdS/GO heterostructure, a notable phenomenon was observed where certain oxygen atoms migrated into the CdS matrix, establishing bonds with Cd atoms. This finding aligns with the experimental results reported by Colina et al.3 Furthermore, it was observed that carbon atoms exhibit a slight displacement within the first plane at the interface with CdS, while the other planes remain unchanged.
To assess the photocatalytic behavior, the valence and conduction band edge were computed using the following empirical equations:22
(1) |
E0VB = E0CB + Eg | (2) |
In Fig. 4, the band structure of CdS along the (110) direction is depicted, by employing the hybrid function (HSE) to rectify the band gap. This adjustment yields a direct band gap of 2.78 eV. The limited number of bands displayed is a consequence of the small number of atoms incorporated into the crystal cell structure. For CdSe the same the behavior was observed, with a band gap of 0.92 eV regarding graphene oxide, it was found that the crucial parameters influencing the band gap and electronic properties are the oxygen contents and the number of graphene layers. Furthermore, the differences are observed between graphene oxide in hexagonal (oxygen at sheet top) and zigzag (oxygen at both sides of carbon sheet) forms, Fig. 5 presents the band structure of GO in hexagonal form with a C/O ratio of 50%.
Fig. 5 Projected band structure of hexagonal graphene oxide with a C/O ratio of 50%; red and green colors represent the p states of O and C respectively. |
The band structure exhibits characteristics such as bandgap opening, which is absent in perfect graphene, and a localized state within the bandgap due to the presence of oxygen groups, affecting the conductivity and optical properties of the material.
(3) |
CdS(001)/GO | CdS(110)/GO | CdSe(110)/GO | CdS/G | CdSe/G | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Eb (eV per atom) | −30.88 | −0.86 | −3.00 | −0.03 | −0.02 |
CdS/GO in 001 direction shows metallic behavior, as shown in Fig. 6a, Additionally, the results indicate the formation of surface states near the Fermi level from the p states of C and O, however for 110 direction (Fig. 6b and c) CdS and CdSe keep their semiconductor behavior, and the self-consistent calculations yield band gap values of 0.16 and 0.11 eV, respectively.
CdS along the [001] direction appears to exhibit a surface layer with possible asymmetrical termination, as indicated by the arrangement of Cd and S atoms. This configuration could suggest a polar surface, depending on the stacking sequence and charge distribution within the bulk structure.
In contrast, CdS along the [110] orientation may exhibit a non-polar nature due to balanced terminations. In this case, Cd and S atoms are arranged within the same plane, ensuring that positive and negative charges are evenly distributed and neutralized.
Surface states play a critical role in shaping the electronic properties of thin films, significantly influencing charge carrier transport at the interface between the layer and other materials. Polar surfaces, in particular, often exhibit unique properties, such as strong adsorption, band bending, and surface reconstruction. The charge distribution shows that negative charges are localized on oxygen atoms, creating surface states. These states appear in the band structure as flat bands (Fig. 6b and c), which can enhance electronic mobility and improve electrical conductivity.
ε(ω) = ε1 + iε2 | (4) |
Fig. 7 illustrates the calculation of the real and imaginary parts of the dielectric function for CdS(001)/GO when light is incident from the x, y, and z directions. At high-frequency values, the real part of the dielectric function exhibits a negative value for the polarized electric field along both the x and y axis. Similarly, the imaginary part along the z direction starts at 0.7 eV, indicating significant absorption. Additionally, for both x and y components, there is notable absorption at very low frequencies, which can be attributed to surface states at the CdS–GO interface described above. These observations highlight the intricate interplay of polarization and absorption phenomena at the material and the influence of the CdS/GO interface.
Furthermore, the orientation of the system can control the behavior of the dielectric function, as depicted in Fig. 8, where for CdS(110)/GO, only one component shows a negative value in the real part, while the other components exhibit positive values at lower energies. In addition to anisotropic of the system, this orientation-dependent behavior adds an additional layer of complexity and versatility to the optical properties of the material.
Fig. 8 Real (a) and (b) imaginary part of dielectric function of 110 orientations, for CdS and (c) dielectric function of CdSe/GO, (d) imaginary part along x, y and z axis for CdSe/GO. |
In contrast of CdSe(110)/GO from the band structure and self-consistent calculation, there is small band gap for CdSe/GO, and this behavior is confirmed in the imaginary part of dielectric function as displayed in (Fig. 8c and d), where the imaginary and real parts of the dielectric function for CdSe/GO are presented for three different directions. Notably, the dielectric constants differ at zero energy along these directions. The absorption characteristics, as illustrated in the imaginary part exhibit similarities for both the x and y directions, a significant difference between CdSe/GO and CdS/GO, particularly in the real part at low energy. The most noteworthy change is the appearance of a negative sign in the real part of CdS/GO, indicating a phenomenon known as “negative permittivity”. This means that the electric field and the induced polarization in the material are in opposite directions, leading to unconventional electromagnetic properties, similarly to the interaction between magnetic field and diamagnetic systems. Such behavior leads to unique optical effects and has a profound influence on the interaction of light with the material.
According to the Debye model, the concept of permittivity connects the displacement vector (D) and the electric field vector (E). The ratio of these amplitudes is described by the permittivity tensor (D/E).
• When ε1 (real part of permittivity) is positive, D and E point in the same direction.
• When ε1 is negative, D and E become perpendicular, leading to unique electromagnetic behaviors.25
In summary, manipulating the CdS orientation offers the potential to mitigate or eliminate the abnormal behavior of the dielectric function observed at low frequencies. This orientation manipulation emerges as a promising strategy for addressing and improving the observed behavior.
Δρ = ρ(CdS/GO) − ρ(CdS) − ρ(GO) | (5) |
In eqn (5), ρ(CdS/GO) is the electronic charge density for the combined system, ρ(CdS) and ρ(GO) the electronic charge density for CdS and graphene oxide respectively. On the other hand, the work function (Φ) was also computed, expressed as the difference between the energy of the Fermi level (EF) and the energy of the vacuum level (EV).26
Φ = EV − EF | (6) |
Materials with a high work function are more likely to attract photo-generated electrons to their surface, while materials with a low work function attract holes.27
As shown in Fig. 9, the electronegativity difference between the O and C atoms induces a charge transfer region (indicated by yellow and blue regions) and the development of a dipole moment, oriented from the O atom to the C atom. This establishes a built-in electric field.
To investigate charge transfer across the CdS(001)/GO interface, the work functions of CdS, CdSe and GO are comptued. Due to the higher work function of GO (ϕ = 5.37 eV) compared to CdS (ϕ = 4.73 eV), electrons transfer from CdS to GO, resulting in a dipole moment pointing from GO to CdS, which is antiparallel to the intrinsic dipole moment of GO. In contrast, for CdSe/GO, electron transfer occurs from GO to CdSe.
This charge transfer results in an electron-rich region on the CdS layer's surface, leading to the formation of a two-dimensional electron gas (2DEG).28 The interface shows a significant decrease in potential at 15 Å, accompanied by clear charge redistribution due to the charge depletion on the GO surface. Notably, the most substantial electron depletion occurs at the position of C–O bonds, suggesting that this system may exhibit higher electron mobility.
Fig. 10 Calculated band edge positions of CdSe, CdS, GO and CdS(Se)/GO with respect to vacuum potential and NHE (Normal Hydrogen Electrode). The green dashed lines are water redox potentials. |
The determination of p-type or n-type characteristics in CdS and graphene oxide (GO) relies on factors such as the work function, intrinsic Fermi level, and it's depended on the layer numbers of graphene oxide as well as the O atom ratio. For instance, when a single oxygen atom interacts with CdS, the work function is measured at 5.1 eV. However, upon introducing two oxygen atoms to the CdS matrix, the work function experiences an increase to 5.91 eV. In the case of graphene oxide, with an oxygen ratio of 14%, the band gap and work function stand at 3.17 eV and 4.13 eV, respectively. Upon reducing graphene oxide by 50%, these values undergo a transformation, resulting in a band gap of 0.83 eV and a work function of 3.14 eV. However, the most compelling insights are illustrated in Fig. 10, demonstrating the potential to form either type I or type II heterostructures, dependent to the layer numbers of graphene oxide or CdS orientation. Within the GO layer, surface charge depletion induces observable charge redistribution.
The transferred charge to the Cd–S substrate amplifies the potential on the Cd atoms' side, prompting additional charge transfer from C–O bonds to Cd atoms to maintain equilibrium. Theoretical expectations, depicted in Fig. 11, suggest that the electric field should be oriented from Cd to GO. However, variations in charge density reveal that the electric field orientation depends on the number of oxygen atoms connected to CdS compared to graphene. These findings imply that the controlling the O-to-graphene ratio can enable the manipulation of electric field orientation or charge transfer.
1. Both CdS/GO and CdSe/GO form type II heterostructures, indicating that there is a staggered energy alignment at the interface between the materials. This alignment promotes charge separation and enhances the possibility of hydrogen production.
2. The surface states present in the heterostructures play a crucial role in determining the negative part of the dielectric function at low frequencies. These surface states may influence the overall electronic properties and charge transfer processes.
3. The orientation of CdS combined with graphene oxide can affect the results, potentially altering the electronic structure and charge transport characteristics of the heterostructure. Different configurations may lead to varied energy band alignments and charge separation efficiencies.
Manipulating the oxygen content in the combined system allows control over the band gap of the heterostructure. This can be a valuable approach to fine-tune the electronic properties and optimize the material for specific applications, such as hydrogen production.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |