Morgan E.
Skala
,
Sarah M.
Zeitler
and
Matthew R.
Golder
*
Department of Chemistry, Molecular Engineering & Science Institute, University of Washington, 36 Bagley Hall, Seattle, WA 98195, USA. E-mail: goldermr@uw.edu
First published on 10th June 2024
The plastic waste crisis has grave consequences for our environment, as most single-use commodity polymers remain in landfills and oceans long after their commercial lifetimes. Utilizing modern synthetic techniques to chemically modify the structure of these post-consumer plastics (e.g., upcycling) can impart new properties and added value for commercial applications. To expand beyond the abilities of current solution-state chemical processes, we demonstrate post-polymerization modification of polystyrene via solid-state mechanochemistry enabled by liquid-assisted grinding (LAG). Importantly, this emblematic trifluoromethylation study modifies discarded plastic, including dyed materials, using minimal exogenous solvent and plasticizers for improved sustainability. Ultimately, this work serves as a proof-of-concept for the direct mechanochemical post-polymerization modification of commodity polymers, and we expect future remediation of plastic waste via similar mechanochemical reactions.
In the context of polymer science, mechanochemistry is intuitively perceived to promote destructive processes.24–28 Following the early work of Staudinger,29–31 mechanochemical chain scission has been redirected to mechanoresponsive functions (e.g., color change, catalyst activation, cargo release) via activation of engineered mechanophores using ultrasonic irradiation.27,32–38 On the other hand, BMG in polymer mechanochemistry has largely focused on constructive chemistry for polymer synthesis.36,37,39,40 Less studied in polymer mechanochemistry is PPM. Reactive extrusion is an example of an industrially relevant, mechanochemical method for PPM that relies on shear forces for mixing, but typically requires elevated temperatures for melt phase thermally mediated processes.13,41–43 Force-induced polymer modifications via BMG, however, have rarely been applied to industrially relevant polymers. Instead, accounts are limited to low molar mass or low Tg materials that will not degrade under BMG conditions (i.e., oligomeric polystyrene44 and poly(ethylene glycol)45) and polymers with pre-installed functional handles that facilitate efficient modification in the solid-state (i.e., polystyrene-based copolymers containing aldehyde46 or benzyl chloride47 moieties, functionalized polyethers,48 and poly(vinyl alcohol) and poly(vinyl chloride)49) (Fig. 1A). Most commercial polymers, however, are high molar mass species and do not have such pre-installed moieties and therefore require longer reaction times for direct functionalization. The kinetics of prolonged functionalization reactions under BMG conditions are likely to be competitive with those of chain scission, resulting in excessive backbone degradation and loss of desired bulk properties.50 This degradation via BMG can be leveraged for polymer depolymerization,26,51,52 chain-end functionalization,53,54 or radical functionalization.55 For PS, while chain scission under BMG is well documented above a limiting molar mass, Mlim (ca. 7.0–13.0 kDa),50 a recent report demonstrates a more specific relationship between Tg and the rate of degradation under BMG conditions.50 In this work, Peterson, Hwang, and Choi also demonstrate that the addition of exogenous plasticizer could decrease the rate of degradation. Inspired by this finding, we hypothesized that liquid-assisted grinding (LAG) could plasticize post-consumer plastic under BMG conditions such that the rate of PPM significantly outcompeted the rate of mechanochemical chain scission. LAG, commonly used in synthetic organic mechanochemistry, is customarily defined as the ratio of a liquid additive to the mass of the reaction components within the range of 0.1–1 μL mg−1.56,57 With plasticization of the polymer substrate, the Tg and the magnitude of shear forces experienced by polymer chains would decrease and result in slower degradation rates.50,58
To demonstrate the power of PPM using LAG, we identified trifluoromethylation as an emblematic arene functionalization reaction. Electrophilic CF3 sources should be reactive enough to add directly to aromatic monomer units in PS; importantly, for this study subsequent fluorinated products could be quantified easily via19F NMR spectroscopy.19,20 Previous reports have shown TFM-PS possesses increased hydrophobicity and improved interfacial and bulk polarization compared to unfunctionalized PS, making TFM-PS useful for applications in coatings and as a potential replacement for PS as a gate dielectric in organic electronics.19,59 Recent work by Kubota and Ito on the mechanoredox fluoroalkylation of activated arenes60 inspired us to extend trifluoromethylation to PPM via BMG. Although these conditions proved to be ineffective (Table S1†), we later identified a direct arene trifluoromethylation reported by Sanford61 (Fig. 1B) as a method adaptable to mechanochemical functionalization of unactivated aromatics, such as PS model substrate bibenzyl (BB) (Fig. 1C). Inspired by these previous reports, we now demonstrate the first example of direct mechanochemical PS functionalization using BMG and investigate the impact of varying LAG conditions on competitive polymer functionalization versus degradation (Fig. 1C). Overall, we obtain PS trifluoromethyl incorporation up to 1.4 mol%, including 0.60 mol% for post-consumer dyed PS. This work serves as a proof-of-concept for sustainable aromatic polymer upcycling via LAG enabled mechanochemistry.
Entry | Jar size (mL) | Ball size (mm) | Initial Mnf (kDa) | m (mol%) | TFM-PS M n (kDa) | Final Đf |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: PS repeat unit = 0.81 mmol, AgOTf = 0.32 mmol, KF = 0.32 mmol, TMSCF3 = 0.08 mmol, DCE (for LAG) = 37.4 μL (0.2 μL mg−1), jar temperature = 20 °C–36 °C. b 3× SS balls were used. c 4 SS balls were used. d Reaction conditions: PS repeat unit = 1.62 mmol, AgOTf = 0.65 mmol, KF = 0.65 mmol, TMSCF3 = 0.16 mmol, DCE (for LAG) = 79.3 μL (0.2 μL mg−1). e Functionalization density (m) was determined by 19F NMR spectroscopy using 4,4′-difluorobenzophenone as an internal standard. Based on TMSCF3 as the limiting reagent, a maximum m is 10 mol%. f M n and Đ were determined by GPC-MALS-RI. | ||||||
1 | 5 | 8 | 8.9 | 1.1 | 9.0 | 1.05 |
2 | 5 | 8 | 9.3 | 1.2 | 9.6 | 1.17 |
3 | 5 | 5b | 9.3 | 0.76 | 9.5 | 1.07 |
4 | 5 | 10 | 9.3 | 1.6 | 9.1 | 1.07 |
5 | 25 | 8c | 9.3 | 0.97 | 10.2 | 1.09 |
6d | 25 | 8c | 8.9 | 0.86 | 10.2 | 1.10 |
Fig. 2 GPC-RI traces comparing unmilled parent PS, 1.3 mol% TFM-PS containing a high molar mass shoulder, and PS milled without additives for 4 h. |
With mechanochemical parameters optimized, we next focused on LAG conditions for well-defined higher molar mass PS. PS (Mn,MALS = 26.0 kDa), also synthesized via ATRP, is well above the Mlim of PS and therefore allows better visualization of how Mn and Đ are impacted by DCE LAG and chain scission kinetics (see Tables S6 and S7† for evaluation of different LAG solvents). LAG volumes were then varied from 0.2 μL mg−1 to 1.2 μL mg−1 (Fig. 3A). At 0.2 μL mg−1 LAG, while Mn decreases and dispersity increases as evidenced by low molar mass tailing in the GPC trace, the highest CF3 density (1.3 mol%) is also observed. As LAG volume increases above 0.2 μL mg−1, only a slight shift to lower molar masses and minimal changes in dispersity compared to the initial polymer are observed. We hypothesize this lack of chain scission is due to increased plasticization above 0.2 μL mg−1 of LAG solvent. Additionally, increasing LAG volume results in decreased interchain coupling as evidenced by the decreasing Mn and shoulder peak area; these results are likely due to increasingly more dilute concentrations of triflic acid. The highest functionalization density with minimal degradation of TFM-PS was achieved at 0.4 μL mg−1 LAG volume. At this LAG loading, plasticization appears to hinder the degradation kinetics while maintaining productive impact forces needed for efficient functionalization. At LAG loadings above 0.4 μL mg−1, we attribute decreases in trifluoromethylation to dissipation of force in the reaction mixture. To assess the impact of plasticization and stress dissipation to the solid reagents on mechanochemical chain scission, we milled 26.0 kDa PS with either just the solid reagents (AgOTf and KF) or just 0.4 μL mg−1 LAG solvent (DCE) and liquid reagent (TMSCF3) for 4 h, the length of the standard reaction time (Fig. 3B). When milled with only solid reactants, PS saw slightly less chain scission occur (Mn,final = 8.3 kDa) than the initial PS milled alone (Mn = 7.0 kDa), likely due to powder cushioning effects.65 When PS was milled with only the LAG solvent and liquid additive, virtually no degradation or deleterious side reactions occur as assessed by GPC. To further confirm this result was due to plasticization, we used differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) to determine the Tg of the 26.0 kDa PS after milling with only 0.4 μL mg−1 of the LAG solvent and the liquid additive (Fig. 3C). The DSC curves of this liquid-milled PS compared to the initial 26.0 kDa PS reveal a decrease in Tg by ca. 30 °C, indicative of plasticization. Based on these results, we determined that plasticization suppresses Tg and diminishes the force experienced by polymer chains, thus decreasing the rate of chain scission.
With BMG functionalization now demonstrated on well-defined PS, we turned our attention to modifying commercial and post-consumer plastic waste, particularly expanded polystyrene (EPS) foam waste (EPS Foam) and dyed PS coffee cup lids (PS Lid). To optimize grafting density while minimizing degradation, LAG amounts were first evaluated on Precipitated EPS Foam waste, which was precipitated as an attempt to control for the impact of inherent plasticizers and additives present in the “native” post-consumer plastics (Table 2). LAG amounts between 0.2 and 0.6 μL mg−1 resulted in 0.68–0.89 mol% CF3 incorporation, retaining a similar efficiency to the PPM of well-defined PS, although significant degradation was now observed, likely due to higher molar mass starting material (Table 2, entries 1–3). Milling with 0.8 μL mg−1 of DCE resulted in the highest amount of functionalization, 1.1 mol%, with significantly less chain scission than with lower LAG volumes (Table 2, entry 4). At 1.0 and 1.2 μL mg−1 LAG, trifluoromethylation incorporation begins to decrease alongside minimal changes in Mn, likely due to less effective applied force (Table 2, entries 5 and 6).
Entry | LAG (μL mg−1) | m (mol%) | M n (kDa) | Đ |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: PS repeat unit = 0.81 mmol, AgOTf = 0.32 mmol, KF = 0.32 mmol, TMSCF3 = 0.08 mmol, DCE (for LAG) = 0.2–1.2 μL mg−1, internal jar temperature = 20 °C−36 °C. b Functionalization density (m) was determined by 19F NMR spectroscopy using 4,4′-difluorobenzophenone as an internal standard. Based on TMSCF3 as the limiting reagent, a maximum m is 10 mol%. c M n and Đ were determined by GPC-MALS-RI. | ||||
SM | — | — | 101 | 1.87 |
1 | 0.2 | 0.89 | 16.0 | 2.25 |
2 | 0.4 | 0.86 | 55.6 | 2.64 |
3 | 0.6 | 0.68 | 32.3 | 4.96 |
4 | 0.8 | 1.1 | 71.0 | 1.45 |
5 | 1.0 | 0.89 | 79.9 | 1.66 |
6 | 1.2 | 0.61 | 66.6 | 1.69 |
With optimized LAG conditions in hand (0.8–1.0 μL mg−1 DCE), we subjected high molar mass (Mn = 132 kDa) Commercial PS and post-consumer PS waste to mechanochemical trifluoromethylation conditions (Table 3). We refer to the crude post-consumer waste (i.e., containing all additives and plasticizers) as Native EPS Foam and Native PS Lid and the purified PS as Precipitated EPS Foam and Precipitated PS lLid. Utilizing LAG, we achieved trifluoromethylation loadings of 0.65 mol%, 0.29 mol%, and 0.60 mol% of Commercial PS, Native EPS Foam, and Native PS Lid, respectively (Table 3, entries 1–3). As assessed by GPC-MALS, less degradation was seen during mechanochemical trifluoromethylation for Commercial PS and both post-consumer “native” PS substrates relative to “precipitated” PS substrates (Table 3). These results are supported by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) experiments that reveal glass transitions of 93 °C–94 °C for the Native EPS Foam and Native PS Lid (Fig. S72 and S74†); these values are lower than the Tg's of their respective precipitated forms66 (Fig. S73 and S75†) and indicate the presence of plasticizers and/or additives in the crude polymers. When combined with LAG conditions, the result is limited backbone degradation compared to precipitated high molar mass PS. To further explore the advantages of mechanochemistry, we subjected Commercial PS, Native EPS Foam, and Native PS Lid to force-free trifluoromethylation conditions in solution (Table S8,† entries 5–9). In all cases, we noted, at best, trace functionalization while also obtaining insoluble cross-linked materials (Fig. S8†) from Native EPS Foam and Commercial PS. Overall, these efforts highlight the efficacy of our mechanochemical methodology over solution-state methods (see Table S8† for solution-state reactions of additional substrates).
Entry | Substrate | LAG (μL mg−1) | Initial Mnc (kDa) | Initial Đc | m (mol%) | TFM-PS M n (kDa) | Final Đc |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: PS repeat unit = 0.81 mmol, AgOTf = 0.32 mmol, KF = 0.32 mmol, TMSCF3 = 0.08 mmol, DCE (for LAG) = 0.8–1.0 μL mg−1, jar temperature = 20 °C–36 °C. b Functionalization density (m) was determined by 19F NMR spectroscopy using 4,4′-difluorobenzophenone as an internal standard. Based on TMSCF3 as the limiting reagent, a maximum m is 10 mol%. c M n and Đ were determined by GPC-MALS-RI. | |||||||
1 | Native EPS Foam | 0.8 | 119 | 1.82 | 0.29 | 83.6 | 2.57 |
2 | Native PS Lid | 1.0 | 113 | 1.78 | 0.60 | 114 | 2.62 |
3 | Commercial PS | 1.0 | 132 | 2.19 | 0.65 | 93.2 | 1.65 |
4 | Precipitated EPS Foam | 0.8 | 101 | 1.87 | 1.1 | 71.0 | 1.45 |
5 | Precipitated PS Lid | 1.0 | 131 | 1.72 | 0.46 | 13.3 | 3.78 |
Despite the benefits of LAG for reducing mechanochemical chain scission during PS trifluoromethylation, for commercially relevant high molar mass samples, we generally still observe a decrease in Mn during trifluoromethylation (Table 3); such changes can drastically impact downstream bulk properties. At the outset, we hypothesized that the intrinsic plasticizers67 in “native” PS waste could reduce the rate of mechanochemical chain scission through Tg depression, but such phenomena may vary across different post-consumer substrates. Indeed, in the case of Native PS Lid (Table 3, entry 2) no change in Mn was observed, while Native EPS Foam (Table 3, entry 1) showed a decrease in Mn by ca. 35 kDa. However, any potential benefits of these plasticizers still require synergistic LAG solvent; mechanochemical trifluoromethylation experiments with Native EPS Foam and Native PS Lid run in the absence of LAG solvent (Fig. S9 and S10†) leads to low molar mass PS approaching Mlim (ca. 9.0 kDa) for both substrates. We also performed identical experiments on Precipitated EPS Foam without LAG, but with the addition of 2 or 4 wt% of exogenous plasticizers dioctyl terephthalate (DOTP) and tributyl citrate (TBC) (Fig. S11 and S12†). Interestingly, we still achieved ca. 0.5–1 mol% functionalization across these representative examples, suggesting that “plasticizers” support our mechanochemical trifluoromethylation chemistry.
Given that LAG is clearly necessary for maintaining high molar mass polymers during mechanochemical PPM, we then subjected Precipitated EPS Foam to trifluoromethylation conditions with exogenous plasticizer (2 or 4 wt% of DOTP or TBC) and 0.8 μL mg−1 DCE LAG (Fig. 4). We investigated two different plasticizers because LAG additive polarity can alter reaction kinetics and/or reactivity.68,69 At just 2 wt% DOTP we maintain functionalization density (1.4 mol%) but now observe less chain scission, with a loss of ca. 15 kDa in Mn (Fig. 4A). Use of 2 wt% TBC increases Mnca. 50 kDa with similar functionalization (1.2 mol%). At 4 wt% DOTP and TBC, functionalization density decreases slightly with similar plasticizer dependent outcomes in the final product molar mass (Fig. 4B).
At 8 wt% TBC loading we recovered mostly insoluble cross-linked material, while at 8 wt% DOTP we maintain similar degradation kinetics as at 2 and 4 wt% DOTP (Table S9†). Because added TBC often led to insoluble material, we opted to study the impact of 2 wt% DOTP + LAG on the mechanochemical functionalization of native post-consumer waste and Commercial PS.
With the ability to effectively maintain high Mn polymers through addition of LAG solvent and plasticizer, we set out to optimize the mechanochemical trifluoromethylation of commercial and post-consumer “native” substrates (Fig. 5). Although Native EPS Foam contains plasticizer, we still observed a decrease in Mn by ca. 35 kDa (Table 3, entry 1). However, the addition of just 2 wt% DOTP with LAG (1.0 μL mg−1 DCE) provided efficient functionalization (1.0 mol%) with a slight increase in Mn and dispersity relative to the initial substrate. Without exogenous plasticizer but with 1.0 μL mg−1 LAG, Native PS Lid still maintains similar trifluoromethylation densities (0.60 mol%) with a slight increase in dispersity. Because Native PS Lid performs so well without exogenous plasticizer, we investigated the supernatant content after precipitation. While NMR spectroscopy and GC reveal a complex mixture of additives, we estimate they only account for ca. 1–2 wt% (Fig. S78 and S79†). Commercial PS results in small amounts of chain scission (loss of ca. 30 kDa) with 2 wt% DOTP and 0.8 μL mg−1 LAG. We attribute this increased chain scission to the higher dispersity of Commercial PS (Đ = 2.19).50 To increase Mnvia chain coupling/branching (132 kDa to 373 kDa), 2 wt% TBC can be used instead (Fig. S13†). These results are promising for future mechanochemical functionalizations of post-consumer plastic waste that already contains additives and/or high degrees of plasticizers. Additives that might otherwise hinder solution-state PPM reactions can potentially tune reactivity under mechanochemical conditions.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc03362k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |