Hongyang
Zhu
a,
Rongrong
Du
a,
Hongyao
Zhao
a,
Mengting
Liu
a,
Yanyun
Wang
a,
Chao
Yu
a,
Zengjing
Guo
b,
Sheng
Tang
a,
Edison Huixiang
Ang
*c and
Fu
Yang
*a
aSchool of Environmental and Chemical Engineering, Jiangsu University of Science and Technology, Zhenjiang 212003, China. E-mail: fuyang@just.edu.cn
bSchool of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Liaocheng University, Liaocheng 252000, Shandong, China
cNatural Sciences and Science Education, National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore 637616, Singapore. E-mail: edison.ang@nie.edu.sg
First published on 26th February 2024
In the pursuit of synchronous contaminant purification and freshwater reclamation using multifunctional nanomaterials, a broad prospect emerges. Through a tactic process involving the successive modification of ZIF67 by mesoporous silica and cobalt-incorporating polydopamine coating, followed by graphitization, the confinement of multivalent cobalt nanocrystal species within the interconnected carbon-silica hybridized porous shell has been achieved, establishing it as a multifunctional nanoreactor with abundant and well-dispersed catalytic sites. Additionally, the hybridization of the silica framework with the carbon network, facilitated by the binding of N species, has generated polar sites enhancing the capture of pollutant molecules, thereby extending the lifespan of reactive oxidative species by reducing their migration. This catalyst presents an array of metallic redox pairs, significantly enhancing electron transfer capacity and bolstering peroxymonosulfate activation. The optimized Co-SiCNO-6 catalyst exhibits the capability to degrade norfloxacin within 5 min, showcasing a reaction rate constant of about 0.917 min−1, a remarkable 5.3-fold enhancement compared to that of its ZIF67 graphitization-derived counterpart. Further studies encompassing reaction conditions, anion interference, and the catalyst's flexibility in degrading contaminants were conducted to assess its practical potential. Concurrently, exploration into the direct recovery of clean water through solar-driven interfacial water evaporation utilizing the optimized catalyst yielded an evaporation rate of 1.50 kg m−2 h−1 and an impressive 93.1% evaporation efficiency. Notably, distinctive outcomes emerged when dealing with polluted water containing norfloxacin and carbamazepine. The norfloxacin solution achieved a near 1.88 kg m−2 h−1 evaporation rate with 95% efficiency, outperforming the treatment of carbamazepine solution. The obtained Co-SiCNO-6 was further anchored onto a tailored melamine sponge by the Ca ion-triggered sodium alginate crosslinking tactic as an integrated monolith evaporator, which exhibits excellent evaporation performance (2.0 kg m−2 h−1) and rational norfloxacin degradation efficiency (30 min). This innovative hybrid hollow nanoreactor exhibits potent dual functionality in degrading contaminants and facilitating solar-driven water regeneration from polluted wastewater.
To address this, the advanced oxidation process (AOP) has emerged, leveraging PMS activation to target organic molecules within a multiphase catalyst, establishing itself as a potent approach for treating organic wastewater.4,5 In the course of AOP treatment, a substantial quantity of reactive oxygen species (ROS) like sulphate radicals (SO4˙−), hydroxyl radicals (˙OH), superoxide ions (O2˙−), and singlet oxygen (1O2) is generated, effectively eliminating recalcitrant pollutants.6,7 The focal point of the AOP lies in the development of functional materials to drive this process. Cobalt-based catalysts have gained widespread recognition for their efficacy as heterogeneous catalysts in activating PMS within AOP investigations.8–10 While cobalt oxide (CoO) demonstrates the ability to activate permonosulfate (PMS) for contaminant removal, its catalytic performance is hampered by a limited number of active sites and the potential risk of cobalt ion leaching, limiting its efficiency.11 Carbon-based materials, owing to their abundance, non-toxicity, biocompatibility, and excellent thermal and chemical stability, have garnered significant interest.12 Recent carbonaceous materials like graphene, carbon nanotubes, and activated carbon fibers have become preferred catalyst carriers due to their substantial specific surface area, abundant surface functional groups, and impressive mechanical properties.13 Ordinarily, pristine carbon exhibits low to moderate catalytic activity. Enhancing it often involves modifying it with transition metals to introduce more favorable active sites. In homogeneous reactions, transition metal ions such as Co2+, Fe2+, Mn2+, and Ni2+ activate PMS, with the best performance seen in Co2+/PMS combinations.14 Incorporating cobalt into carbon carriers effectively mitigates cobalt ion leaching.15 In turn, cobalt nanoparticles further amplify the catalytic prowess of carbon materials in PMS activation. Thus, combining carbon-based materials with cobalt-based nanoparticles can synergistically harness the strengths of both materials, significantly boosting the oxidation effect produced by activating PMS.16 Investigating the synergies generated through ultrafine metal oxides within carbon frameworks by precisely regulating the size of carbon is a critical pursuit.17 Mesoporous silicon dioxide emerges as a promising catalyst carrier owing to its exceptional chemical stability. For instance, incorporating cobalt-iron spinel nanoparticles into porous silica carriers results in superior dispersion of metal particles, amplification of the specific surface area, and optimization of catalyst utilization.18 The surface properties of silica offer easy modification by diverse groups, and specific nanostructured silica materials demonstrate remarkable effectiveness in modulating the active state of metal species.19 However, the combination of nanocarbon mesoporous silica remains infrequent when addressing the activity optimization of metal species. In particular, the incorporation of carbon materials into mesoporous silica can cause additional photothermal properties, which are capable of extending the functionality of materials in the photothermal conversion application.
In addition to breaking down pollutants, a fascinating avenue involves regenerating freshwater directly from sewage. Typical desalination technologies, such as reverse osmosis, distillation, capacitive deionization, and battery desalination, consume large amounts of electrical or thermal energy.20–22 As an emerging desalination technology, solar-driven photoelectrochemical desalination using sustainable solar energy to remove salt ions without any external bias has gained much attention.23 Emerging interfacial photo-thermal water evaporation technologies possess the capability to confine photothermal heat at the evaporating surface, prompting evaporation of water molecules from the photothermal material to generate fresh water.24 Solar-powered desalination technologies, including solar steam generation and solar-powered membrane distillation, provide a sustainable pathway for generating clean water from wastewater.25,26 Nevertheless, the efficiency of converting natural light into water vapor remains insufficient to create a practical freshwater supply due to water's poor optical absorption and significant heat losses.27 Thus, developing a photothermal material capable of absorbing a broad spectrum of sunlight and exhibiting high photothermal conversion efficiency becomes imperative. In addition, when addressing the contaminant elimination and regeneration of freshwater by multifunctional materials, the coupled technique for synchronous pollutant mineralization and solar-driven interfacial water regeneration is rarely mentioned. During interfacial solar evaporation, sufficient light, high air–water interface temperature, and carbon-based and transition-metal photothermal materials provide the necessary conditions for the activation of PMS. Therefore, the introduction and activation of PMS in an interfacial solar evaporation system should be able to achieve both efficient solar evaporation and catalytic degradation of volatile organic compounds.28 This makes the project attractive for practical wastewater treatment when using complicated wastewater systems containing organic pollutants.
Inspired by these concepts, we modified the surface of dodecahedral ZIF67 with silica.29 Under alkaline conditions, ZIF67 dissolves and merges with SiO2, resulting in a spherical shell. Applying a dopamine coating and employing heat treatment help confine cobalt species within silica nanolayers, forming hollow photothermal nanospheres. Metal nanospecies tend to aggregate, prompting the addition of a carbon layer to ensure the uniform dispersion of metal species. However, as carbon inherently repels water, a more polar SiO2 shell acts as a support within the material.30 This, combined with the carbon layer, enhances affinity across the entire surface of the catalyst, facilitating the creation of active sites for contaminants and fostering porousness for contaminants to react within the pores. Moreover, the SiO2 shell preserves the stability of the carbon coating and ultrafine metal oxide, resulting in localized photothermal effects at the interface through interaction between the carbon coating and metal. Simultaneously, the unique structure and channel confinement effect stabilize the formed metal or metal oxide particles, rendering the material highly active. Functional metal-constrained carbon layers serve as exceptional photothermal materials for interfacial solar-thermal water evaporation, showcasing excellent photothermal conversion efficiency. This structural design ensures both efficient degradation performance and commendable photothermal properties for the catalysts. Various characterization tests were conducted to determine the physicochemical properties of the catalysts. Their degradation performance on NFX and other pollutants underwent systematic investigation. Additionally, the impact of different conditions on degradation performance was studied. The choice of a melamine sponge as a support to immobilize the catalyst is justified by its open and abundant network structure, which can effectively accommodate a greater quantity of catalysts. Additionally, the surface hydrophilicity of the melamine sponge facilitates the easy coating of alginate acid onto the skeleton, ensuring proper incorporation of the catalyst. Therefore, simulated solar water evaporation experiments for treating contaminant containing wastewater by using the obtained functional materials and integrated monolith evaporator by anchoring the nanoreactor onto the melamine sponge were conducted to gain deeper insights into the photothermal conversion performance of the catalysts, water purification, and recycling abilities.
In addition to these experiments, several controlled comparative samples were prepared. In one instance, ZIF67 was directly carbonized at 600 °C in a tube furnace at a rate of 5 °C min−1 and then calcined for 2 h under a N2 atmosphere, labeled as Co-NO-6. ZIF67 coated with mesoporous silica for further treatment by the above procedure was labeled as Co-SiCNO-6. Another sample involved coating ZIF67 with cobalt-incorporating polydopamine as per a similar procedure, followed by carbonization at 600 °C in a tube furnace at a rate of 5 °C min−1 and calcination for 2 h under a N2 atmosphere, named Co-CNO-6.
Fig. S1† shows the N2 adsorption/desorption isotherms and the corresponding pore size distributions of different catalysts. The adsorption/desorption isotherms of Co-SiCNO-6, Co-SiNO-6, Co-CNO-6, and Co-NO-6 catalysts conform to type I and type IV hysteresis curves (Fig. S1a†), indicating the presence of combined micropores and mesopores in the catalysts. Table S1† summarizes microstructural properties such as specific surface area calculated by the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) method and pore size distribution. As shown in Fig. S1b, c and Table S1,† the BET specific surface areas of Co-SiCNO-6, Co-SiNO-6, Co-CNO-6 and Co-NO-6 were 392.4 m2 g−1, 546.0 m2 g−1, 218.3 m2 g−1 and 201.4 m2 g−1, respectively. The specific surface area of Co-SiCNO-6 was obviously higher than that of Co-CNO-6 and Co-NO-6, indicating that the introduction of mesoporous silica increases the nanochannels of the material and improves the exposure and accessibility of active species for contaminants. However, the specific surface of Co-SiCNO-6 is lower than that of Co-SiNO-6 possibly because of the introduction of cobalt-containing dopamine on mesoporous silica affecting the structural properties of the material.
Fig. 2a depicts the wide-angle XRD patterns for the optimal sample Co-SiCNO-6, alongside comparison samples Co-CNO-6, Co-SiNO-6, and Co-NO-6. All samples exhibit robust diffraction peaks at 36.6° and 42.6°, corresponding to the (111) and (200) crystal planes of cubic CoO, aligning with the standard card (JCPDS: 01-1227). Additional peaks at 44.2° and 51.5° indicate metallic Co species (JCPDS: 15-0806), possibly resulting from the reduction of CoO to metallic Co at higher temperatures in an N2 atmosphere. Notably, Co-NO-6, derived directly from ZIF67, primarily comprises metallic Co(0). In contrast, Co-CNO-6, derived from PDA-modified ZIF67, exhibits multiple cobalt species diffractions, implying that more carbon deposition on ZIF67 reduces oxidative metal species to a metallic state. Increasing cobalt incorporation onto the PDA layer yields various cobalt species in the final nanoreactor. Fig. S2† shows XRD spectral results of comparative catalysts at 500 and 700 °C calcination temperatures. At 500 °C, Co-SiCNO-5 displays insignificant diffraction peaks due to low crystallinity and high dispersity of the introduced metal species on the carbon-SiO2 hybrid shell. Conversely, Co-SiCNO-7 exhibits diffraction peaks related to Co3O4 and Co2SiO4 at 700 °C, indicating that high temperatures lead to cobalt species reacting with silica, forming Co2SiO4. Fig. 2b illustrates the Raman spectral outcomes of comparison samples (Co-SiCNO-6, Co-CNO-6, Co-SiNO-6, and Co-NO-6). Raman peaks at around 1360 cm−1 and 1600 cm−1 correspond to the D and G bands of the carbon network, respectively. Generally, D peaks signify lattice defects in carbon atoms, while G peaks represent in-plane stretching vibrations of sp2 hybridized C atoms. The relative intensity ratios of the D and G bands (ID/IG) elucidate atomic crystal defects or the degree of graphitization in carbon materials.34 The lower ID/IG in Co-SiCNO-6 and Co-SiNO-6 compared to the other catalysts likely stem from increased graphitized carbon layers due to SiO2 introduction, enhancing carbon graphitization. To gain deeper insights into the surface elemental composition and states, Fig. S3† presents comprehensive XPS survey results for comparison samples: Co-SiCNO-6, Co-CNO-6, Co-SiNO-6, and Co-NO-6, outlining the predominant elemental compositions of C, O, N, and Co. In Fig. 3a, the C 1s core level spectra across different samples reveal distinct peaks corresponding to three types of carbon assignments: CC (287.8 eV), C–O/N (285.4 eV), and C–C (284.6 eV), indicating the presence of heteroatoms in the carbon framework. Fig. 3b shows N 1s core level peaks at 398.4 eV and 400.3 eV, representing pyridine N and pyrrole N, respectively, confirming the successful nitrogen species doping within the carbon network. Interestingly, the SiO2-doped catalyst predominantly exhibits pyrrole N species, while the direct calcination of ZIF67 results in an increased presence of pyridine N, suggesting that PDA modification facilitates the formation of pyrrole N species, potentially contributing to more adsorptive sites for polar contaminant molecules. Moving to Fig. 3c, the O 1s spectra exhibit three peaks corresponding to lattice oxygen OL (529.5 eV), oxygen vacancy OV (531.1 eV), and adsorbed oxygen OA (532.8 eV). Specifically, Co-SiCNO-6 and Co-SiNO-6 show Si–O and adsorbed oxygen, while Co-CNO-6 and Co-NO-6 exhibit CoOx-related lattice oxygen and oxygen vacancy species, indicating the increased presence of Co species within the mesoporous silica shell due to silica introduction. Fig. 3d displays Co 2p core level XPS spectra for different catalysts, revealing Co(II) and Co(III) in the Co 2p1/2 and Co 2p3/2 core energy levels, consistent with typical crystalline species. Notably, characteristic peaks of zero-valent cobalt appear, alongside two satellite peaks of Co 2p, indicating the presence of multivalent cobalt oxide species. Co-SiCNO-6 notably shows a significantly higher Co(II) content (77.09%) compared to Co-CNO-6 (32.75%), Co-SiNO-6 (49.33%), and Co-NO-6 (27.92%). This higher Co(II) content makes Co-SiCNO-6 advantageous for PMS activation, as Co(II) often serves as the primary active center, potentially initiating more ROS for efficient NFX degradation.35 In Fig. 3c, three distinct peaks in the O 1s spectra correspond to lattice oxygen OL (529.5 eV), oxygen vacancy OV (531.1 eV), and adsorbed oxygen OA (532.8 eV).36 Notably, the O 1s spectra of Co-SiCNO-6 and Co-SiNO-6 reveal adsorbed oxygen and Si–O assignments at 533.0 eV and 532.4 eV, respectively. Conversely, Co-CNO-6 and Co-NO-6 showcase lattice oxygen and oxygen vacancy species related to CoOx, suggesting that the introduction of silica leads to an increased presence of Co species within the internal structure of the mesoporous silica shell. Moving to Fig. 3d, the XPS spectra of the Co 2p core level for different catalysts indicate the presence of Co(II) and Co(III) in the Co 2p1/2 and Co 2p3/2 core energy levels, consistent with the elemental composition of typical crystalline species. Specifically, the deconvoluted binding energy at 780.4 eV and 795.5 eV corresponds to the Co 2p3/2 and Co 2p1/2 of Co(II), respectively, while the energy level peaks at 782.1 eV and 798.2 eV align with the Co 2p3/2 and Co 2p1/2 of Co(III). Notably, two distinct peaks of zero-valent cobalt emerge at 778.8 eV and 793.8 eV, along with two satellite peaks of Co 2p, indicating the presence of multivalent cobalt oxide species. Significantly, the calculated relative Co(II) content of Co-SiCNO-6 (77.09%) surpasses that of other catalysts-Co-CNO-6 (32.75%), Co-SiNO-6 (49.33%), and Co-NO-6 (27.92%). This higher Co(II) content makes Co-SiCNO-6 uniquely advantageous for PMS activation, as Co(II) often serves as the primary active center, potentially initiating more ROS for efficient degradation of NFX. In addition, the cobalt contents of Co-SiCNO-6, Co-SiNO-6, Co-CNO-6 and Co-NO-6 were determined by inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES) to be 5.69%, 9.73%, 67.45% and 21.74%, respectively (Table S2†). Table S2† also reveals that the cobalt leaching of Co-SiCNO-6, Co-SiNO-6, Co-CNO-6 and Co-NO-6 reaches 5.5%, 5.64%, 17.97% and 14.65%, respectively. This result indicates that the introduction of a silica framework in the carbon network could efficiently reduce the leaching of Co during the reaction, which further highlights the advantage of silica for stabilizing the metal species confined in carbon.
Fig. 2 (a) Wide-angle XRD patterns and (b) Raman spectra of Co-SiCNO-6, Co-CNO-6, Co-SiNO-6 and Co-NO-6; (c) crystal cell structure of multiple Co species in the catalyst. |
Fig. 3 XPS spectra of (a) C 1s, (b) N 1s, (c) O 1s and (d) Co 2p core levels of Co-SiCNO-6, Co-CNO-6, Co-SiNO-6, and Co-NO-6. |
The efficiency of various samples in catalyzing PMS to degrade NFX was assessed. In Fig. S4,† the degradation curves of NFX over time for catalysts derived at different calcination temperatures are displayed. Notably, Co-SiCNO-6 exhibits superior catalytic degradation performance, showing the highest first-order kinetic constant (Kabs = 0.426 min−1), establishing it as the most effective catalyst for NFX degradation. Fig. 4a highlights the disparity in NFX degradation among comparison samples obtained at the optimal calcination temperature. Even when compared to the samples lacking modification with metal-incorporating PDA, Co-SiCNO-6 demonstrates significantly enhanced reaction activity. Furthermore, based on the first-order kinetic fitting analysis (Fig. 4b), the sequence of reaction kinetic constants for the four catalysts stands as follows: Co-SiCNO-6 (0.917 min−1) > Co-CNO-6 (0.314 min−1), Co-NO-6 (0.205 min−1) > Co-SiNO-6 (0.172 min−1). This underscores that the metal-incorporating carbon layer on the SiO2 shell over ZIF67 effectively confines and stabilizes active metal species, thereby enhancing the efficiency of PMS activation. To elucidate the activity origin of the optimized catalyst, Fig. 4c illustrates the correlation between different cobalt valences and reaction rate constants. Remarkably, the optimal catalyst Co-SiCNO-6, possessing the highest Co(II) fraction, exhibits the highest reaction rate, emphasizing the pivotal role of Co(II) in catalytic PMS activation. The correlation is clear: a higher valence metal fraction, especially higher Co(II) content, leads to a faster reaction rate. Interestingly, while the primary reaction kinetics of Co-SiNO-6 are slower than those of Co-CNO-6 and Co-NO-6, the degradation efficiency and degree of degradation of Co-SiNO-6 surpass those of Co-CNO-6 and Co-NO-6 at seventeen minutes. This discrepancy might stem from the absence of cobalt-incorporating polydopamine coating in Co-SiNO-6, where the introduced SiO2 reduces the exposure and reactivity of active cobalt species to some extent. Fig. 4d further illustrates the relationship between nitrogen species types and content versus the reaction rate. Notably, the primary kinetics of the four catalysts increase as the pyrrolic N content increases. The optimal catalyst containing solely pyrrolic N species exhibits the fastest reaction rate, indicating a positive correlation between pyrrolic N and primary reaction kinetics. More surface pyrrolic N species are recognized as polar sites that enrich polar contaminants around the reaction sites, shortening the migration distance of generated ROS towards contaminants and thereby enhancing their activity lifespan. A sequence of experiments was conducted to establish the optimal parameters for the catalytic elimination of NFX utilizing Co-SiCNO-6. These experiments were methodically designed to optimize catalyst dosage, PMS dosage, and NFX concentration. The outcomes, as depicted in Fig. 5a and d, elucidate the influence of varying catalyst dosages exclusively on the catalytic degradation of NFX while maintaining controlled variables.37 Notably, an increase in catalyst dosage from 0.2 g L−1 to 0.3 g L−1 resulted in an 88% degradation of NFX within a nine-minute timeframe. However, a further increase to 0.4 g L−1 did not enhance the reaction rate, indicating that excessive catalyst amounts render reactive sites unavailable for efficient NFX elimination. Furthermore, optimal PMS quantities were determined by solely varying PMS additions while keeping other variables constant, as illustrated in Fig. 5b and e.38 The catalyst without PMS exhibited the slowest NFX removal, attributed predominantly to adsorption effects rather than inherent catalytic function. Conversely, both 0.1 g L−1 and 0.2 g L−1 PMS contributed effectively to NFX degradation, to similar extents, although the initial-stage reaction kinetic constant for 0.1 g L−1 PMS was higher. This suggests that insufficient PMS underutilizes active sites, while excessive amounts might inhibit the reaction due to competitive processes. Interestingly, even in the absence of PMS, the catalyst eliminated 80% of NFX within 9 min, potentially due to the presence of abundant pyrrole nitrogen species enhancing ROS generation. This augmentation facilitated the attack on pollutants around the catalyst surface, thereby improving catalytic efficiency by reducing ROS diffusion distances. Fig. 5c and f indicate a gradual reduction in the catalytic activity of Co-SiCNO-6 as NFX concentration increased from 10 mg L−1 to 30 mg L−1. Maintaining a lower NFX concentration appeared more favorable for the catalyst, with a pronounced reduction in the reaction rate observed at 30 mg L−1. Moreover, qualitative analysis conducted as shown in Fig. S5†via 3D fluorescence assay confirmed the decreased NFX content during the degradation reaction, corroborating results from UV-absorption spectroscopy assays. Subsequent experiments at various temperatures established the low reaction activation energy (Ea) of Co-SiCNO-6 to be 1.420 kJ mol−1 (Fig. S6†), showing its distinctive advantage in NFX degradation. Table S3† shows the total organic carbon (TOC) content before and after the degradation of NFX by different catalysts, reflecting the degree of mineralization of organic pollutants. Specifically, Co-SiCNO-6 shows the highest TOC removal of 50.96%, which was higher than that of Co-SiNO-6 (33.36%), Co-CNO-6 (37.48%) and Co-NO-6 (31.84%). This basically agrees with the degradation activity trend of the above several comparative catalysts. In Fig. 6 and Table S4,† a comparative assessment of Co-SiCNO-6 and previously reported catalysts underscores its exceptional performance, demonstrating superiority in NFX degradation with respect to concentration, reaction rate, time, PMS, and catalyst dosage. Co-SiCNO-6 emerges as a catalyst showcasing superior comprehensive degradation performance for NFX across all evaluated parameters.39–44
Fig. 6 Comprehensive performance comparison of NFX degradation based on optimal Co-SiCNO-6 and several reported comparative catalysts. |
To explore the impact of anions on the degradation of NFX catalyzed by the catalyst, control experiments were conducted by introducing various inorganic salts like NaOH and Na2CO3 under optimized conditions (Fig. S7†). Observations reveal that Cl− exerts a noticeable inhibitory effect on the NFX degradation process. This inhibition could be attributed to the oxidation of Cl− by SO4−˙ and ˙OH, generating less reactive Cl˙ and HOCl−˙ (eqn (1)–(3)).45 Conversely, SO42− shows minimal influence on the degradation of NFX by Co-SiCNO-6, while OH− significantly diminishes the efficiency of the catalyst in degrading NFX, indicating that an excessively alkaline environment severely impedes PMS activation. Phosphates are known for their role as complex ions, engaging in chelation reactions by binding to –OH and Me–O groups on the surface. Additionally, they function as quenchers for ˙OH (eqn (4)).46 The introduction of H2PO4− somewhat curtails the activity of the reacting species, resulting in decreased catalytic performance. Moreover, the presence of HCO3− and CO32− inhibits NFX degradation due to their competition with reactive SO4−˙ or ˙OH, ultimately diminishing the population of reactive radicals (eqn (5)–(8)).47
Cl− + ˙OH → HOCl−˙ | (1) |
HOCl−˙ + H+ → Cl˙ + H2O | (2) |
Cl− + SO4−˙ → SO42− + Cl˙ | (3) |
˙OH + H2PO4− → OH− + H2PO4−˙ | (4) |
˙OH + HCO3− → CO3−˙ + OH− | (5) |
˙OH + CO32− → CO3−˙ + OH− | (6) |
SO4−˙ + HCO3− → CO3−˙ + HSO4− | (7) |
SO4−˙ + CO32− → CO3−˙ + SO42− | (8) |
To gain deeper insights into the roles and reaction mechanisms of the primary active substances in NFX degradation through catalyst-activated PMS, free radical quenching experiments were performed. Methanol (MeOH), tert-butanol (TBA), L-histidine (L-his), and p-benzoquinone (p-BQ) were employed to quench specific free radicals. Broadly, MeOH effectively reacts with ˙OH (hydroxyl radical) and ˙SO4− (sulfate radical), while TBA exclusively interacts with ˙OH but not with ˙SO4−. Conversely, p-BQ and L-his exhibit evident scavenging effects on ˙O2− (superoxide radical) and 1O2 (singlet oxygen), respectively. The results presented in Fig. 7a and b indicate a reduction in the reaction rate constants of the optimal catalyst to 0.344 min−1, 0.783 min−1, 0.324 min−1, and 0.466 min−1 upon the addition of MeOH, TBA, L-his, and p-BQ to NFX, respectively. Remarkably, TBA displays the weakest effect after consuming ˙OH, while MeOH and L-his exhibit the most prominent impact, suggesting that ˙SO4− and 1O2 predominantly drive NFX removal. In a bid to assess the electron transfer capabilities of various catalyst composites, linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) (Fig. 7c) and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) (Fig. 7d) data were collected. Fig. 7c illustrates heightened electron transport in Co-SiCNO-6, resulting in an accelerated oxidation reaction and exceptional electron transport capacity. Additionally, Fig. 7d portrays a steeper slope for Co-SiCNO-6 in the low-frequency region, indicating lower charge transfer resistance and swifter interfacial charge transfer, potentially contributing to the activity advantage of Co-SiCNO-6 from this perspective. Furthermore, to investigate the role of Co-SiCNO-6 in authentic water sources, NFX degradation experiments were conducted in tap water and Lake Haiyun water from Zhenjiang. These were compared with degradation experiments in deionized water (Fig. S8a†). Degradation rates in tap water and lake water were slightly lower than those in deionized water. This decline can be attributed to Cl− in tap water, which diminishes active radicals, consequently reducing the reaction rate. In lake water, various anions impact the catalyst, while other substances compete for active sites, further diminishing the reaction rate. However, Co-SiCNO-6 exhibited high catalytic performance for different water qualities, stably degrading over 80% of NFX within 19 min. The recyclability of Co-SiCNO-6 was assessed (Fig. S8b†), demonstrating the catalyst's capability to degrade almost 80% of NFX even after three cycles, affirming its stability and reproducibility. Moreover, to explore the versatility of Co-SiCNO-6 in degrading other pollutants, control degradation experiments (Fig. S8c†) were conducted with this catalyst for p-nitrophenol (PNP), bisphenol A (BPA), carbamazepine (CBZ), tetracycline (TC), and oxytetracycline (OTC). These experiments, conducted using optimal reaction parameters for NFX, displayed compelling results: PNP was completely degraded in eleven minutes, and CBZ, TC, and NFX were degraded to nearly 90% within the same timeframe, while BPA and OTC were degraded by 70%. This underscores the versatility of Co-SiCNO-6 in the degradation of various common organic pollutants.
Besides effectively mineralizing contaminants, the potential for reclaiming clean water from wastewater is alluring. The presence of carbon and plasmonic metallic Co amplifies the photothermal attributes, a facet of particular interest. Specifically, the photothermal conversion of specialized materials is gaining traction in solar-driven interfacial water evaporation, harnessing sunlight to generate heat on photothermal materials. The amalgamation of carbon layers and metal species within the nanoreactor notably aids in surface heating. Additionally, the nanoreactor's mesoporous channels and hollow configuration expedite water vapor diffusion towards air, enhancing water evaporation.48Fig. 8a shows digital photos of the photothermal membrane prepared for water evaporation. Evaluating the Co-SiCNO-6 nanoreactor's photothermal properties involved measuring the integrated catalyst membrane's surface temperature using an infrared thermal imager. Infrared photothermal images depicted in Fig. S9a† reveal an increase in the nanoreactor's surface temperature from 26.6 °C to 71.2 °C within 30 min of irradiation. Fig. S9b† illustrates photothermal images of the wet sample, where Co-SiCNO-6 reaches 39.6 °C after 10 min, remaining at around 40 °C for the next 50 min. Moreover, the photothermal membrane's surface temperature significantly increases under sunlight exposure when soaked in NFX and CBZ solutions, ultimately reaching 42.3 °C and 39.5 °C, respectively. These results underscore Co-SiCNO-6's commendable photothermal conversion performance, likely stemming from Co metal's incorporation into the carbon layer, fostering exceptional photothermal conversion efficiency. In addition, the UV-vis absorption spectrum of Co-SiCNO-6 further validates the excellent sunlight absorption of the constructed materials compared to the natural light spectrum (Fig. S10†). Fig. 8b shows the temperature variation during the water evaporation process for different pollutants and deionized water. Its inset highlights Co-SiCNO-6's temperature variation in deionized water under light irradiation within 10 minutes, swiftly increasing from room temperature to 39.6 °C and stabilizing under the catalyst's influence. As depicted in Fig. 8c, the blank group data indicate water evaporation occurring directly under natural conditions, registering an evaporation rate of 0.17 kg m−2 h−1. In the absence of light, Co-SiCNO-6 exhibits a lower water evaporation rate of 0.15 kg m−2 h−1 compared to the blank group due to the nanoreactor's membrane aggregation impeding water molecule diffusion to some extent.49 However, under light conditions, the Co-SiCNO-6 membranes achieve a water evaporation rate of 1.50 kg m−2 h−1, boasting a photothermal evaporation efficiency of 93.14%. In a comparison of evaporation rates or efficiency with those in prior studies (Fig. 8d and Table S5†), Co-SiCNO-6 emerges as the top performer in photothermal capabilities during the evaporation process.50–57Fig. 8e and f show the infrared-thermal images of the membrane initially and after irradiation for 60 min under one sun irradiation. In addition, the water evaporation rate of Co-SiCNO-6 reached 1.88 kg m−2 h−1 for NFX and 1.47 kg m−2 h−1 for CBZ when NFX and CBZ solutions were used as the evaporating substances, respectively. This variance may be attributed to the influence of contaminant-bearing interfacial water's thermal conductivity on the photothermal materials due to the addition of macromolecular contaminants. The cyclic evaporation experiments further demonstrate the excellent efficiency of the Co-SiCNO-6 photothermal material (Fig. S11†).
Due to the limitation of a separated 2D membrane for treating complex wastewater containing contaminants, in particular, the residual organic pollutants cannot be removed during the evaporation process. For practical applications utilizing photothermal materials, 30 mg of Co-SiCNO-6 catalyst was anchored onto a circular melamine sponge of 3 cm diameter to evaluate its performance in degrading pollutants and regenerating water. The combination of plasmonic metals and carbon materials enables efficient photothermal conversion in the composite. We anchored the photothermal catalyst onto the sponge evaporator through Ca ion-triggered crosslinking of SA. This integrated sponge evaporator offers a well-developed network, facilitating easy water diffusion and evaporation. Interfacial solar-assisted evaporation, achieved by constructing the evaporator from photothermal materials, is considered a feasible and promising method. The preparation is depicted in Fig. 9A; specifically, the obtained samples were dispersed in the SA solution, and the tailored sponge was soaked in the above mixture to adsorb them and further crosslink by Ca ion interaction. As a result, the integrated monolith evaporator composed of the functional materials and sponge can be placed in polluted wastewater as a floatable device, which can achieve solar-driven water evaporation and synchronous contaminant degradation on adding PMS as an oxidant. Impressively, this integrated device not only degrades pollutants but also achieves water evaporation at a high rate exceeding 2.0 kg m−2 h−1. Fig. 9a illustrates the photothermal performance of the integrated photothermal evaporator. The surface temperature increases from 20.2 °C to 30.2 °C within 3 min under one-sun irradiation, reaching 37 °C within 10 min, with a gradual increase and eventual stabilization. Additionally, under these conditions, Fig. 9b shows that the device exhibits water evaporation rates of 2.00 kg m−2 h−1, 2.04 kg m−2 h−1 and 1.96 kg m−2 h−1 in one hour during the three cycles, indicating the good stability and reusability of the integrated evaporator. The energy loss of the integrated sponge evaporator and separated 2D membrane involved in water evaporation was assessed (Table S6†). The calculated result reveals that the integrated sponge evaporator affords a high radiation loss and convection loss compared to the separated 2D membrane; in contrast, the integrated sponge evaporator contributes to an obviously lower conduction loss than that of the separated 2D membrane. Taken together, the total energy loss of the integrated sponge evaporator is higher than that of the separated 2D membrane. The catalytic degradation measurement, shown in Fig. 9c, confirms that the integrated monolith evaporator can degrade NFX by about 95% in one hour under sunlight and still degrades NFX by nearly 90% after three cycles, validating the reusability of the integrated evaporator in multiple contaminant degradation. The control group reveals that the NFX removal by virtue of the device without the addition of Co-SiCNO-6 and crosslinked with sodium alginate only reaches nearly 30%, indicating that Co-SiCNO-6 plays a crucial role in this real NFX degradation. Given the catalyst's integration with the sponge and its excellent recyclability, it aligns with practical requirements for water evaporation and contaminant removal.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3ta07853a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |