Amin
Zhou
a,
Xiao-Song
Li
*a,
Jing-Lin
Liu
a,
Lan-Bo
Di
*b and
Ai-Min
Zhu
a
aLaboratory of Plasma Physical Chemistry, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian 116024, China. E-mail: lixsong@dlut.edu.cn
bCollege of Physical Science and Technology, Dalian University, Dalian 116622, China. E-mail: dilanbo@163.com
First published on 3rd October 2024
Air plasma catalytic oxidation of toluene (C7H8) with the cycled storage-discharge (CSD) mode is a promising technology for toluene (C7H8) removal. However, the problem of low CO2 selectivity must be solved. In this work, a novel HZSM-5 (HZ) supported Au catalyst (Au/HZ) with ca. 5.7 nm Au nanoparticles was prepared by combining impregnation-ammonia washing and plasma treatment, and adopted for C7H8 removal. Au/HZ displays a large breakthrough capacity and an excellent oxidation ability of C7H8 in dry and wet air plasma. To investigate the mechanism of CO2 selectivity improvement with the Au/HZ catalyst, air plasma catalytic oxidation of gaseous C7H8 and CO, as well as the adsorption of C7H8 and CO on the catalysts were conducted. For plasma-catalytic oxidation of gaseous C7H8 over Au/HZ, the CO2 selectivity is 97.5%, significantly higher than those of HZ (55%) and Ag/HZ (62%). In situ TPD tests indicate that Au/HZ possesses a moderate adsorption strength for CO and C7H8 compared with HZ and Ag/HZ. Meanwhile, plasma oxidation of CO over Au/HZ reaches 100%, which is much higher than those of HZ (15%) and Ag/HZ (24%). Nearly 100% C7H8 conversion and CO2 selectivity of plasma-catalytic oxidation of C7H8 on Au/HZ can be attributed to the moderate adsorption strength of Au/HZ for C7H8 and CO, and very high plasma catalytic activity for CO oxidation.
Broader contextThe CO2 selectivity and carbon balance have to be improved to ensure the long-term durability of the cycled storage-discharge (CSD) mode for removal of low-concentration volatile organic compounds, especially when using air plasma. Therefore, it is very necessary to combine a Au catalyst with a zeolite support as a two-in-one catalyst. However, it is difficult to obtain small-sized Au nanoparticles on non-reducible zeolites. Herein, a novel HZSM-5 (HZ) supported Au catalyst (Au/HZ) with ca. 5.7 nm Au nanoparticles was prepared by plasma treatment. The Au/HZ exhibits large breakthrough capacity and excellent oxidation ability for C7H8. In situ TPD tests indicate that Au/HZ possesses moderate adsorption strength for CO and C7H8 compared with HZ and Ag/HZ. Moreover, plasma oxidation of CO over Au/HZ reaches 100%. Therefore, both C7H8 conversion and CO2 selectivity reach nearly 100% in air plasma for the Au/HZ catalysts. These findings underscore the outstanding toluene removal performance of the developed Au/HZ catalyst and its potential for air plasma catalytic oxidation of low-concentration VOC applications. |
Due to the unique pore structure and large VOC storage capacity, molecular sieves are widely adopted for removal of VOCs using the CSD mode.8–10 Among the molecular sieves, HZSM-5 (HZ) with high silica to alumina ratios is more attractive due to its large storage capacity, good hydrophobicity and stability.11 Confined to the low CO2 selectivity and carbon balance of HZ, HZ supported Ag, Cu, Mn, or Ce catalysts have been prepared and employed for plasma catalytic oxidation of benzene,7,12 toluene (C7H8)13,14 and formaldehyde (HCHO).5 These catalysts exhibited large storage capacity and high plasma catalytic oxidation activity for removal of VOCs. However, oxygen plasma is generally adopted, which is not economically affordable and inconvenient. Meanwhile, the CO2 selectivity and carbon balance need to be further improved to ensure the long-term durability of the CSD mode, especially when using air plasma.
Since Au catalysts are active for CO oxidation at low temperature,15 our previous work employed the tandem effect of in-plasma zeolite and a post-plasma Au/TiO2 catalyst for complete oxidation of C7H8 to CO2, and nearly 100% CO2 selectivity at 100% C7H8 conversion was obtained.16 To make it more convenient and beneficial for practical applications, it is very necessary to combine Au with the HZ support to prepare a Au/HZ catalyst. However, the activity of Au catalysts is sensitive to Au particle size, and larger particle sizes are generally less active.17 In order to obtain small Au nanoparticles, reducible oxides18 (such as TiO2, CeO2, etc.) are generally used as supports by using a deposition–precipitation method. Differently, zeolites such as HZ are non-reducible supports, and Au nanoparticles generally possess large size.15,19 Therefore, so far Au/HZ has not been reported in plasma catalytic removal of VOCs.
Plasma has been proved to be an efficient method for synthesizing supported metal catalysts.20,21 Herein, a Au/HZ catalyst was prepared by combining impregnation-ammonia washing and plasma treatment, and applied for air plasma catalytic removal of C7H8. Au/HZ displays large breakthrough capacity, excellent oxidation activity, and stability for C7H8 removal. To obtain insight into the underlying mechanism of the excellent performance of Au/HZ, plasma oxidation of gaseous C7H8 and CO was performed, and in situ TPD tests were adopted to further investigate C7H8 and CO adsorption on the catalysts. The results indicate that the nearly 100% CO2 selectivity of the plasma-catalytic oxidation of C7H8 on Au/HZ can be attributed to the moderate adsorption strength of Au/HZ for C7H8 and CO, and very high plasma catalytic activity for CO oxidation.
Since Ag/HZ is generally adopted for removal of VOCs by thermal catalysis and plasma catalysis, a Ag/HZ catalyst was also prepared by an incipient-wetness impregnation method using AgNO3 and HZ as the Ag precursor and support, respectively, according to previous work.23 1 g of HZ powder was immersed in a certain concentration of AgNO3 solution and left at room temperature in the dark for 12 h. It was then dried at 110 °C for 3 h and calcined in a muffle furnace at 450 °C for 3 h. Finally, the prepared Ag/HZ powder was prepared into tablets, crushed, and sieved to a size of 40–60 mesh for use.
Simulated air plasma was adopted for C7H8 removal using the cycled storage-discharge (CSD) mode. First, simulated air containing C7H8 was introduced into the same DBD reactor as that used for the preparation of catalysts. After adsorption for a certain period, simulated air was used to purge the catalyst bed to remove weakly adsorbed C7H8. Subsequently, the CTP-2000 K plasma power supply was turned on to treat the adsorbed C7H8 using simulated air as the working gas with an input power (Pin) of 7.0 W and a discharge power (Pdis) of 1.5 W. Pin was determined using a wattmeter, and Pdis was obtained by the Lissajous figure method using a 0.47 μF capacitance. The discharge time in this work was 20 min. Gaseous products were monitored online by using a nondispersive infrared gas analyzer (S710, Sick-Maihak, Germany) and a mass spectrometer (HPR-20 QIC, Hiden Analytical, UK).
Plasma catalytic oxidation of adsorbed C7H8 was conducted over the Au/HZ catalysts prepared by thermal treatment and air plasma treatment, respectively. It was found that the plasma-activated Au/HZ catalyst can show higher CO2 selectivity (Fig. S1, ESI†). Therefore, unless otherwise specified, the Au/HZ catalysts are prepared by air plasma treatment.
To understand the underlying mechanism of the catalysts for oxidation of adsorbed C7H8, plasma-catalytic oxidation of gaseous C7H8 and CO was also performed. Simulated air containing certain concentrations of C7H8 or CO was introduced into the DBD reactor with a 7.0 W input power.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 TEM images of Au/HZ with different Au loadings: (a) 0.3 wt%, (b) 0.6 wt%, and (c) 1.1 wt%, and (d)–(f) the corresponding size distribution histograms of Au nanoparticles. |
To investigate the valence state of Au, the Au/HZ catalyst (0.6 wt% Au) was analyzed using XPS and H2-TPR. As shown in Fig. 2(a), the XPS results indicate that Au species primarily exist as Au0 and Auδ+ in Au/HZ, with the proportion of Au0 (∼55 at%) slightly exceeding that of Auδ+. The UV-vis diffuse reflectance spectroscopy (DRS) characterization of Au/HZ (Fig. S2, ESI†) displays a distinct absorption peak at 560 nm, which can be attributed to the plasmonic resonance absorption of Au0. This confirms the presence of Au0 in Au/HZ, which is consistent with the XPS results. The H2-TPR analysis of the Au/HZ catalyst (Fig. 2(b)) reveals a hydrogen consumption peak at 98 °C associated with the reduction of Auδ+. Furthermore, a CO-TPR experiment was conducted on the Au/HZ catalyst, under a 1400 ppm CO/He atmosphere, resulting in concentration change curves of CO and CO2 during the CO-TPR process, along with the corresponding mass spectrometry signals, as shown in Fig. 2(c) and (d). The CO reduction peak, observed at around 100 °C and shown in Fig. 2(c) for the Au/HZ catalyst, is attributed to the reduction of Auδ+ species, consistent with the H2-TPR results. At 630 °C, the concentration of CO (m/z = 28) decreases, accompanied by a peak in CO2 generation. The gaseous products detected include CO2 (m/z = 44) and H2 (m/z = 2) (Fig. 2(d)).
This indicates the occurrence of the water–gas shift reaction (CO +H2O → CO2 + H2) as the temperature rises, involving the reaction of CO with adsorbed H2O molecules on the catalyst surface.
The C7H8 breakthrough capacity of Au/HZ is significantly improved in comparison with HZ. TPD technology was applied to analyze C7H8 adsorption sites on HZ and Au/HZ for exploring the mechanism of increased C7H8 breakthrough capacity. With the same adsorption amount of C7H8, Au/HZ catalysts with different Au loadings were subjected to TPD experiments under an Ar atmosphere, and the corresponding C7H8 TPD curves were obtained, as shown in Fig. 3(b)–(d). Two C7H8 desorption peaks appear on Au/HZ with different Au loadings. Combined with the C7H8 TPD curve on HZ, the C7H8 desorption peak at around 200 °C is attributed to C7H8 adsorbed on the HZ adsorption site, while the peak at around 300 °C is ascribed to C7H8 adsorbed on Au adsorption sites. With increasing Au loading, the C7H8 concentration desorbed from HZ adsorption sites gradually decreased, while the C7H8 concentration desorbed from Au adsorption sites increased, indicating an enhanced adsorption strength of Au/HZ catalysts for C7H8 with increasing Au loading. Meanwhile, the amounts of CO and CO2 generated from oxidation of adsorbed C7H8 on Au adsorption sites also increased with increasing Au loading.
According to the COx selectivity results (the sum of CO and CO2 sensitivities) from Fig. 4(c), COx selectivity during the discharge process reaches about 90%, indicating that small amounts of intermediates are adsorbed on the catalysts or desorbed into the gas phase during the discharge process. To verify the carbon balance results of the Au/HZ catalysts, an in situ TPO test was conducted on the Au/HZ catalysts under a 10% O2/Ar atmosphere after three cycles of storage and discharge (Fig. S4, ESI†). Intermediates adsorbed on the catalysts are fully oxidized to CO2, and the amount of intermediates can be determined through the CO2 production, thus obtaining carbon balance results. The CO2 concentrations during the TPO process are shown in Fig. S4(a) (ESI†). Compared to one desorption peak of CO2 on HZ, two CO2 desorption peaks appear on the Au/HZ catalysts, with significantly increased peak values and areas. This indicates that there are two types of surface intermediates absorbed on the Au/HZ catalysts after discharge, which are gradually oxidized to CO2 during the TPO process. With the further increase of Au loading to more than 0.6 wt%, the peak surface values of CO2 concentration basically no longer increase.
CO2 produced from surface intermediates on the Au/HZ catalysts with different Au loadings can be obtained by integrating the CO2 concentration-time curve, hence obtaining the carbon balance (average of three cycles), as shown in Fig. S4(b) (ESI†). The carbon balance of 0.6 wt% Au/HZ reaches 97.5%. It is higher than that of HZ (carbon balance of 93%) due to the stronger adsorption strength of Au/HZ for C7H8, which may reduce desorption during the discharge process. This is consistent with the infrared spectroscopy result that no desorbed C7H8 or intermediates are detected during the discharge process.
To evaluate the oxidation performance and stability of Au/HZ in the CSD experiments, five cycles of C7H8 storage-discharge oxidation were conducted. The corresponding COx production and selectivity results are shown in Fig. 5. Compared to the CO2 production, CO production is negligible. CO2 selectivity reached approximately 95% in 5 cycles. This indicates that the Au/HZ catalyst exhibits stable and excellent plasma-catalytic oxidation performance for C7H8.
To obtain insight into the underlying mechanism of the excellent performance of the Au/HZ catalysts for complete oxidation of C7H8, at first, plasma-catalytic oxidation of gaseous C7H8 and CO was conducted in comparison to HZ and the widely adopted Ag/HZ catalyst. CO and CO2 concentrations as a function of discharge time over the catalysts for gaseous C7H8 oxidation are shown in Fig. 6(a)–(c). 100% C7H8 conversion is obtained on the catalysts. No CO is detected on Au/HZ, and the CO2 concentration on Au/HZ is significantly higher than those on Ag/HZ and HZ. In contrast, both HZ and Ag/HZ produce a significant amount of CO during plasma-catalytic oxidation of C7H8, with CO2 concentration on Ag/HZ being slightly higher than that on HZ. Accordingly, CO and CO2 selectivity for plasma-catalytic oxidation of C7H8 over different catalysts are shown in Fig. 6(d). The CO2 selectivity over HZ and Ag/HZ is 55% and 62%, respectively, while it reaches as high as 97.5% over Au/HZ.
Plasma-catalytic oxidation of CO was also conducted in comparison with the HZ and Ag/HZ catalysts, as shown in Fig. 7. It can be noted that the Au/HZ catalyst has no activity for thermal catalytic oxidation of CO at room temperature. Even at 100 °C, the Au/HZ catalyst only exhibits a CO conversion of approximately 5%, being slightly higher than that of Ag/HZ (∼3%), while HZ shows no thermal catalytic activity (Fig. S5, ESI†). In contrast, the Au/HZ catalyst is distinguished from HZ and Ag/HZ catalysts for plasma-catalytic CO oxidation. As shown in Fig. 7(a)–(c), only a small amount of CO is converted to CO2 on the HZ and Ag/HZ catalysts, resulting in around 240 and 365 ppm outlet CO2 concentrations, respectively. Notably, no CO is detected in the outlet gas for the Au/HZ catalyst. That is, CO is fully oxidized to CO2 on Au/HZ under the plasma. The CO conversion of different catalysts is presented in Fig. 7(d). Ag/HZ shows a slightly higher CO conversion (24%) compared to HZ (15%), while Au/HZ achieves complete CO conversion (100%). This is well consistent with the CO2 selectivity obtained in plasma-catalytic oxidation of C7H8, suggesting that enhanced CO2 selectivity of Au/HZ in C7H8 oxidation is correlated with its good CO oxidation activity in plasma.
To further investigate C7H8 and CO adsorption on the HZ, Ag/HZ, and Au/HZ catalysts, TPD tests of the catalysts were carried out. First, TPD experiments on the HZ, Ag/HZ, and Au/HZ catalysts with identical amounts of adsorbed C7H8 were conducted, as shown in Fig. 8(a). C7H8 desorption on HZ occurs at approximately 200 °C. In contrast, Ag/HZ and Au/HZ display two distinct desorption peaks for C7H8. Apart from the peak near 200 °C attributed to C7H8 adsorption on the HZ sites, additional desorption peaks at around 300 and 440 °C, respectively, are observed for Ag and Au adsorption sites. The C7H8 desorption temperatures suggest the adsorption strength of the catalysts for C7H8 follows the order: HZ < Au/HZ < Ag/HZ.
Then CO-TPD tests of the HZ, Ag/HZ, and Au/HZ catalysts were also carried out. Simulated air containing CO was passed through the catalyst bed for 5 min of adsorption, followed by 10 min of Ar purging. Subsequently, the catalyst bed was heated from room temperature to 550 °C (at a ramp rate of 10 °C min−1) under an Ar atmosphere. The CO-TPD curves for the HZ, Ag/HZ, and Au/HZ catalysts are shown in Fig. 8(b). A distinct CO desorption peak is observed on Ag/HZ, while nearly no CO desorption peak is detected on HZ. Differently, Au/HZ exhibits a small amount of CO2 desorption, coming from CO oxidation on Au/HZ during the TPD process. In other words, Au/HZ demonstrates moderate CO adsorption, and Ag/HZ displays a stronger CO adsorption ability than Au/HZ and HZ. Furthermore, in situ DRIFT was performed to investigate the adsorption process of CO on HZ, Ag/HZ, and Au/HZ, as shown in Fig. 8(c). The CO adsorption peaks on Au/HZ are observed at 2115 and 2172 cm−1, which are close to the positions on HZ (2116 and 2172 cm−1). Since the CO adsorption on HZ and Au/HZ is weak, the adsorption peak on them is close to the infrared spectra of gaseous CO (located at 2120 and 2173 cm−1, respectively, with symmetrical peak shapes). With increasing the adsorption time, the intensity of the CO adsorption peak on HZ changes slightly, with a slight increase in the vibration peak at 2172 cm−1. In contrast, the CO adsorption peaks at 2115 and 2172 cm−1 on Au/HZ show a certain increase, attributed to the reduction of a small amount of Auδ+ species to Au0 by CO.25,26 This is consistent with the XPS and UV-vis DRS characterization results of Au/HZ. In contrast, CO adsorption on Ag/HZ is much stronger than those on HZ and Au/HZ (with an intensity difference of nearly two orders of magnitude), with an obvious blue shift. Due to the strong adsorption of CO by Ag/HZ, the intensity of the vibrational spectral peak of CO located at 2177 cm−1 (Ag adsorption site) is much larger than that of the peak at 2122 cm−1 (HZ adsorption site). In conclusion, the Au/HZ catalyst exerts a moderate adsorption effect on CO, which is important for the plasma-catalytic oxidation of C7H8 and CO.
In summary, TPD experiments of C7H8 and CO adsorption on the HZ, Ag/HZ, and Au/HZ catalysts indicate that Au/HZ shows a moderate adsorption effect on C7H8 and CO. As for plasma-catalytic oxidation of adsorbed C7H8, catalysts with excessively strong adsorption may lead to prolonged occupation of active sites, resulting in incomplete C7H8 oxidation and lower CO2 selectivity. Conversely, catalysts with weak adsorption may cause partial desorption of C7H8 during the discharge process, leading to decreased CO2 selectivity and carbon balance. Compared to HZ and Ag/HZ, Au/HZ exhibits a moderate adsorption strength for C7H8 and CO, which contributes significantly to its superior performance in plasma-catalytic oxidation of C7H8.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4ey00159a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |