Rongrong
Yu‡
b,
Song-Zhou
Cai‡
ab and
Xianjie
Fang
*ab
aKey Laboratory of Organosilicon Chemistry and Material Technology of Ministry of Education, Key Laboratory of Organosilicon Material Technology of Zhejiang Province, College of Material, Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Hangzhou Normal University, 2318 Yuhangtang Road, Hangzhou 311121, China. E-mail: fangxj@hznu.edu.cn
bShanghai Key Laboratory for Molecular Engineering of Chiral Drugs, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Shanghai Jiao Tong University, 800 Dongchuan Road, Shanghai 200240, China
First published on 22nd October 2024
Due to the multifaceted reactivities of cyclopropenes, the divergent hydrofunctionalization of these compounds has recently attracted significant attention. Herein, we present a Pd-catalyzed hydrocyanation of cyclopropenes via aluminum Lewis acid-controlled divergent chemoselectivity. In this study, the presence of aluminum Lewis acid plays a pivotal role in the reaction pathway. In the absence of aluminum Lewis acid, the reaction predominantly yields ring-opening hydrocyanation products, whereas the addition of Lewis acid directs the formation of ring-retentive products.
Nitriles are not only used as versatile synthons in organic chemistry but also widely occur in bioactive molecules, pharmaceuticals, and catalysts/ligands.4 Among various approaches, transition-metal-catalyzed hydrocyanation of unsaturated hydrocarbons represents the most atom-economical and straightforward method for the preparation of nitriles.5 Expanding the scope of unsaturated substrates and exploring the different reactivities of similar substrates are pivotal topics in this field.6 To our current knowledge, no literature has documented the hydrocyanation of cyclopropenes. Moreover, this reaction is of particular importance due to the potential formation of cyano-substituted cyclopropane motifs, which are prevalent in a wide array of natural products and bioactive molecules (Scheme 1c).4c Driven by our continuous interest in hydrocyanations and cyclopropene functionalizations,7,8 we herein disclosed a Pd-catalyzed hydrocyanation of cyclopropenes via aluminum Lewis acid-controlled divergent chemoselectivity (Scheme 1d). In this reaction, the presence of aluminum Lewis acid plays a crucial role in determining the reaction pathway. In the presence of aluminum Lewis acid, the reaction predominantly yields ring-retentive products, while the omission of Lewis acid would favor the formation of ring-opening products.
At the outset of the investigation, we employed cyclopropene 1a as the model substrate, Pd(dba)2 as the precatalyst (see Table S1† for the screening of precatalysts), and acetone cyanohydrin as the HCN source (see Table S4† for the screening of HCN sources). We first studied the ligand effects on the model reaction. The use of the most common monophosphine ligand PPh3 furnished the ring-opening allylic nitrile 2a with 20% yield (Table 1, entry 1). In contrast to monophosphine ligands, bidentate ligands exhibit superior behavior in facilitating the ring-opening hydrocyanation. When dppp and dppf were utilized as the ligands, the yields of 2a were 81% and 86%, respectively (Table 1, entries 2 and 3). However, the use of rac-BINAP resulted in a moderate yield of 45% (Table 1, entry 4). Gratifyingly, the employment of XantPhos as a ligand afforded 2a in a high yield of 92%, with an 85% isolated yield (Table 1, entry 5). Remarkably, no ring-retentive products were detected in the above reactions. In previous investigations on transition-metal-catalyzed hydrocyanation and C–CN activation, Lewis acids were frequently employed as additives to enhance reactivity and facilitate metal-mediated oxidative addition and reductive elimination processes.9,10 Accordingly, our focus shifted towards exploring Lewis acid additives and their potential impact on the hydrocyanation of cyclopropenes (see Table S2† for the screening of additives). To our delight, upon the introduction of 20 mol% BPh3 into the reaction, an 11% yield of the ring-retentive cyano-substituted cyclopropane 3a was observed, albeit with the predominant formation of the ring-opening product 2a (Table 1, entry 6). No ring-retentive product was detected when Ti(OiPr)4, LiCl and Zn(OTf)2 were used as Lewis acids (Table 1, entries 7–9). Surprisingly, the chemoselectivity was reversed when Al(OEt)3 was used, resulting in a 75% yield of 3a and only a 20% yield of the ring-opening product 2a (Table 1, entry 10). Subsequently, a series of aluminum Lewis acids was screened (Table 1, entries 11–13). Using Al(OiPr)3 as the Lewis acid, 3a was obtained as the major product with a chemoselectivity ratio of 6:
1 (Table 1, entry 11). Further investigation into solvents revealed that dimethoxyethane (DME) provided the best results in terms of both chemoselectivity and yield for ring-retentive hydrocyanation (Table 1, entry 16). It is worth mentioning that reducing the equivalent of Lewis acid would dramatically deplete the chemoselectivity, whereas increasing its equivalent showed no significant influence (Table 1, entries 18 and 19). Remarkably, the diastereoselectivity of the ring-retentive hydrocyanation was excellent, and no other diastereomer was detected. Preliminary studies on asymmetric catalysis using chiral ligands under the ring-retentive hydrocyanation conditions were performed (see Table S3† for details). Unfortunately, only DIOP achieved the ring-retentive product (16% GC yield), albeit with 0% ee. Thus, the conditions of entries 5 and 16 were selected as the optimized reaction conditions, respectively.
Entry | Ligand | Additive | Solvent | 2a yieldb/% | 3a yieldb/% |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Unless otherwise noted, all reactions were carried with 1a (0.2 mmol), Me2C(OH)CN (0.6 mmol), Pd(dba)2 (5 mol%), bidentate ligand (5 mol%) or monodentate ligand (10 mol%), additive (20 mol%), solvent (0.3 mL), 12 h. b Yield was determined via gas chromatography analysis using n-dodecane as an internal standard. c Isolated yield. d 30 mol% of additive. e 10 mol% of additive. | |||||
1 | PPh3 | — | Toluene | 20 | ND |
2 | dppp | — | Toluene | 81 | ND |
3 | dppf | — | Toluene | 86 | ND |
4 | BINAP | — | Toluene | 45 | ND |
5 | Xantphos | — | Toluene | 92(85) | ND |
6 | Xantphos | BPh3 | Toluene | 65 | 11 |
7 | Xantphos | Ti(OiPr)4 | Toluene | 35 | ND |
8 | Xantphos | LiCl | Toluene | 89 | ND |
9 | Xantphos | Zn(OTf)2 | Toluene | 80 | ND |
10 | Xantphos | Al(OEt)3 | Toluene | 20 | 75 |
11 | Xantphos | Al(OiPr)3 | Toluene | 12 | 72 |
12 | Xantphos | Al(acac)3 | Toluene | 25 | 53 |
13 | Xantphos | Al(OTf)3 | Toluene | 35 | 52 |
14 | Xantphos | Al(OiPr)3 | THF | 13 | 75 |
15 | Xantphos | Al(OiPr)3 | Dioxane | 13 | 77 |
16 | Xantphos | Al(O i Pr) 3 | DME | 10 | 83(78) |
17 | Xantphos | Al(OiPr)3 | DCE | 15 | 60 |
18d | Xantphos | Al(OiPr)3 | DME | 11 | 80 |
19e | Xantphos | Al(OiPr)3 | DME | 31 | 58 |
Having identified the optimal reaction conditions, the substrate scope of the ring-opening hydrocyanation was first explored. As shown in Scheme 2, a series of cyclopropenes were smoothly converted into the corresponding allylic nitriles with moderate to good yields. When para-substituents were introduced onto the phenyl rings, the ring-opening reaction was found to be compatible with both electron-donating groups, such as methoxyl (2b), t-butyl (2f), and methylthiol (2g), and electron-withdrawing groups, such as fluorine (2d) and trifluoromethyl (2e). Various functional groups, including halogens (2c, 2h) and thiophene (2n), were well tolerated. In addition, spirocyclic cyclopropene (1o) could also deliver the corresponding allylic nitriles with good yields. Interestingly, when R1 was phenyl and R2 was cyclopropyl, the corresponding allyl cyanide (2r) was successfully obtained with 50% yield, wherein the cyclopropyl group was retained and no secondary ring-opening products were detected. Unfortunately, dialkyl-substituted cyclopropene (1s) could not undergo ring-opening hydrocyanation, and cyclopropene 1s was nearly quantitatively recovered.
![]() | ||
Scheme 2 The substrate scope of the ring-opening hydrocyanation of cyclopropenes. Reactions were performed on a 0.2 mmol scale under the standard reaction conditions (Table 1, entry 5). Percentages represent isolated yields. |
Subsequently, we proceeded to examine the substrate scope of ring-retentive hydrocyanation (Scheme 3). Generally, cyclopropenes bearing various aryl groups proved suitable for this reaction, yielding the desired cyano-substituted cyclopropane derivatives in moderate to good yields and chemoselectivity. Multiple functional groups, such as methoxyl (3b, 3k, 3m), trifluoromethyl (3e), methylthiol (3g), bromide (3h, 3l), thiophene (3r) and phenyl (3i), were compatible under the optimized reaction conditions. However, this transformation was sensitive to the steric hindrance of the substrates—the ortho-substituted substrates (3m, 3n) gave relatively low yields and poor chemoselectivity. Apart from methyl substituents (R2 = Me), hydrogen and a variety of alkyl substituents were all suitable for this reaction (3y, 3v–3x). Spirocyclic cyclopropenes efficiently underwent ring-retentive hydrocyanation, affording the corresponding spirocyclic cyano-substituted cyclopropanes in satisfactory yields and chemoselectivity (3s, 3t). Furthermore, this reaction also exhibited good tolerance towards dialkyl-substituted substrates, furnishing products 3z and 3a-1 in 55% and 49% yields, respectively, without the formation of any ring-opening product.
![]() | ||
Scheme 3 The substrate scope of the ring-retentive hydrocyanation of cyclopropenes. Reactions were performed on a 0.2 mmol scale under the standard reaction conditions (Table 1, entry 16). Percentages represent isolated yields. r.r. = the ratio of the ring-retentive product to the ring-opening product, and it was determined by GC analysis. |
To demonstrate the practicality of this transformation, a gram-scale reaction and product derivatization were conducted (Scheme 4). The ring-retentive hydrocyanation of compound 1b was successfully performed on a gram scale, yielding 1.1 g of 3b with 75% yield and 8.5:
1 chemoselectivity (Scheme 4a). Subsequent treatment of 3a with LiAlH4 proceeded efficiently, resulting in the production of 3b-1 with high yield (Scheme 4a). Additionally, (±)-tranylcypromine (3y-2) was synthesized smoothly via hydrolysis followed by the Curtius rearrangement from 3y (Scheme 4b).11
To further understand the mechanism, a control experiment was performed with 3a under the standard ring-opening reaction conditions to determine if 3a was an intermediate (Scheme 5a). However, no 2a was formed and 3a was quantitatively recovered. This result indicated that 3a was not involved as an intermediate thereof. In addition, (CH3)2C(OD)CN was utilized as the HCN source for the hydrocyanation of 1p under both ring-opening and ring-retentive standard conditions (Scheme 5b). Deuterium incorporation at the allylic position (0.7D) was observed in the ring-opening product D-2l. Under ring-retentive conditions, the corresponding product D-3p was obtained, with deuterium incorporated exclusively at the methylene position (0.7D). This deuterium labeling experiment suggests an irreversible syn-hydropalladation process involving cyclopropene. Based on the aforementioned results and tracking time course study (see the ESI† for details), we propose a plausible mechanism to elucidate the two reaction pathways (Scheme 5c). The reaction initiates with palladium(0) species, which undergoes oxidative addition with acetone cyanohydrin to give a palladium(II) intermediate II. Intermediate II subsequently undergoes hydropalladation with cyclopropene 1a to give palladium cyclopropane complex III. This pivotal intermediate III can further react via two potential pathways: β-carbon elimination or reductive elimination. According to the investigations by Nolan, Moloy, and co-workers, the coordination of Lewis acids to metal cyanides can induce partial positive charge formation at the nitrogen and carbon atoms, thereby making the metal center more electron-deficient.10a This electron deficiency accelerates the reductive elimination process, which accounts for the predominant formation of the ring-retentive product in the presence of Lewis acid. Conversely, if intermediate III undergoes β-carbon elimination, it forms the ring-opening π-allyl palladium intermediate IV. Ultimately, allylic nitrile 2a is generated by reductive elimination from IV.
We have successfully developed a Lewis acid-controlled Pd-catalyzed chemodivergent hydrocyanation of cyclopropenes. In this study, the presence of aluminum Lewis acid plays a pivotal role in determining the reaction pathway. In the absence of aluminum Lewis acid, the reaction predominantly yields ring-opening allylic nitrile products. Conversely, the addition of Lewis acid favors the formation of ring-retentive cyano-substituted cyclopropane products. Further mechanistic studies and investigations into enantioselective ring-retentive hydrocyanation are currently underway in our laboratory.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures and NMR spectra of compounds. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4qo01609b |
‡ These authors contributed equally. |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2025 |