Moinak
Dutta‡
a,
Angelos B.
Canaj‡
a,
Tilen
Knaflič
bc,
Christopher M.
Collins
a,
Troy D.
Manning
a,
Hongjun
Niu
a,
Luke M.
Daniels
a,
Aikaterini
Vriza
a,
Luke A.
Johnson
a,
Bhupendra P.
Mali
a,
Yuri
Tanuma
b,
T. Wesley
Surta
a,
John B.
Claridge
a,
Neil G.
Berry
a,
Denis
Arčon
bd,
Matthew S.
Dyer
a and
Matthew J.
Rosseinsky
*a
aMaterials Innovation Factory, Department of Chemistry, University of Liverpool, 51 Oxford Street, L7 3NY Liverpool, UK. E-mail: rossein@liverpool.ac.uk
bCondensed Matter Physics Department, Jožef Stefan Institute, Jamova 39, SI-1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia
cInstitute for the Protection of Cultural Heritage of Slovenia, Research Institute, Poljanska cesta 40, SI-1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia
dFaculty of Mathematics and Physics, University of Ljubljana, Jadranska 19, SI-1000, Ljubljana, Slovenia
First published on 9th December 2024
We report the synthesis, structural characterization and magnetic properties of K3coronene, and demonstrate a computational screening workflow designed to accelerate the discovery of metal intercalated polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH), a class of materials of interest following reports of superconductivity, but lacking demonstrated and understood characterised material compositions. Coronene is identified as a suitable PAH candidate from a library of PAHs for potassium intercalation by computational screening of their electronic structure and of the void space in their crystal structures, targeting LUMO similarity to C60 and the availability of suitable sites to accommodate inserted cations. Convex hull calculations with energies from crystal structure prediction based on ion insertion into the identified void space of coronene suggest that the x = 3 composition in Kxcoronene is stable at 0 K, reinforcing the suitability of coronone for experimental investigation. Exploration of reaction conditions and compositions revealed that the mild reducing agent KH allows formation of K3coronene. The structure of K3coronene solved from synchrotron powder X-ray diffraction features extensive reorientation and associated disorder of coronene molecules compared with the parent pristine host. This is driven by K+ intercalation and occupation of sites both within and between the coronene stacks that are partially retained from the parent structure. This disruption of the host structure is greater when three cations are inserted per coronene than in reported metal PAH structures where the maximum ratio of cations to PAH is 2. Superconductivity is not observed, contrary to previous reports on Kxcoronene. The expected localised moment response of coronene3− is suppressed, which may be associated with the combination of extensive disorder and close coronene3−–coronene3− contacts.
One of the major difficulties in synthesizing and characterizing phase pure alkali metal intercalated PAHs is the complex reactivity of PAHs under reducing conditions9,10 and the extreme sensitivity of these intercalated materials to oxygen and moisture. Use of strong reducing agents such as K metal is found to break the C–H σ bonds,8 generally yielding KH as the major product, along with intercalated amorphous phase(s), instead of or together with any crystalline phase.9 Solid-state synthesis using the milder reducing agent KH has been successful in reliably synthesizing and characterizing K+ intercalated PAHs, namely, K2picene, K2pentacene, K2rubrene and K2tetracene.9,11,12 Solution synthesis affords the solvent-free Cs1phenanthrene.10 However, none of the aforementioned compounds, which are characterized fully, show superconductivity.
The challenges in developing suitable synthesis protocols mean that appropriate selection of PAH targets for intercalation would be invaluable in accelerating the exploration of this chemistry. Pristine picene, pentacene, rubrene and tetracene all adopt herringbone packing with alternating layers having parallel rows of aligned molecules with opposing inclinations (Fig. S1, ESI†). Given these structural similarities between the PAHs where alkali metal intercalation has been demonstrated, alternative PAHs with similar structures (Fig. S1, ESI†) can be identified as potential hosts. We present a combined computational and experimental methodology where PAH candidates are evaluated by considering the porosity in the solid crystalline form of a PAH as a measure of its propensity for the intercalation of metal atoms. This evaluation was combined with assessment of their electronic structures and benchmarked against C60, the parent molecule of the A3C60 (A = alkali metal) superconductors.13 Coronene was identified as the most promising candidate, with convex hull calculations based on simple metal insertion model structures suggesting K3coronene as the most appropriate target composition. Successful experimental synthesis of K3coronene allowed insertion of three alkali cations per PAH to be demonstrated experimentally, and subsequent understanding of the material's magnetic properties.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (a) Hierarchical clustering of 195 aromatic PAHs based on their molecular orbital energies from HOMO−1 to LUMO+4. Coronene is clustered with C60 and away from picene, pentacene and tetracene. (b) The six molecular orbital energies used for the clustering are plotted, comparing coronene with C60, picene, pentacene and tetracene. Coronene and C60 have a degenerate lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO), unlike the other three PAHs compared here. Occupied molecular orbitals are plotted in blue, unoccupied in red (c) porosity analysis of 30 PAHs quantified by finding the diameter of the largest included sphere and free sphere using Zeo++,14 C60 falls significantly outside of the range for most PAHs, with the largest included sphere diameter of 3.61 Å (x co-ordinate) and the largest free sphere diameter of 1.17 Å (y co-ordinate), and so is omitted from this plot. (d) Convex hull constructed for Kxcoronene with x = 1–4, following density functional theory (DFT) calculations on structures (Fig. S2, ESI†) obtained using a simple intercalation approach as described in Computation details, Methods in ESI.† The difference in DFT energy between the intercalated structure and pristine coronene and K is plotted, with the convex hull shown as a solid black line. The most stable composition identified is for x = 3 (i.e., K3coronene) which lies on the convex hull. |
In our analysis of 195 PAHs, hierarchical clustering was used to group molecules by similarity of their molecular orbital energies from HOMO−1 to LUMO+4. Coronene was in the same cluster as C60 (Fig. 1a), and thus prioritised for further investigation as the A3C60 (A = alkali metal) phases are confirmed superconductors.13 Coronene also displays orbital degeneracy in the LUMO, in contrast to the other PAHs (picene, pentacene, tetracene etc.) for which metal intercalation has been unequivocally established previously (Fig. 1b).18 Kekulene (C48H24), in the same cluster as C60 and coronene, also shows degenerate LUMO and LUMO+1 orbitals.
In addition to the electronic structure, the crystal structure of a candidate needs to have sufficient void space to be able to accommodate intercalated cations. Porosity screening, as a proxy for void space, of 30 PAHs whose structures are reported in the Cambridge Structural Database (CSD)19 was performed by finding the diameter of the largest included sphere and free sphere using Zeo++.14 These metrics were used to compare PAH porosity (Fig. 1c and Table S1, ESI†). This evaluation reveals that the porosity in pristine coronene is similar to that of the PAHs demonstrated to intercalate potassium. Kekulene, with a largest free sphere diameter of 2.06 Å, and the largest included sphere diameter of 1.44 Å, is also a suitable candidate for experimental studies but was not considered for further exploration due to not being easily available commercially. Coronene is thus prioritised for study based on both electronic and crystal structure grounds.
Coronene (C24H12), is a PAH that belongs to the sub-class of circumarenes wherein the central arene (in this case benzene) is completely enclosed by another outer ring of fused benzene rings (Fig. 2a). Pristine coronene crystallizes in the monoclinic space group P21/a with a = 16.119(6) Å, b = 4.702(4) Å, c = 10.102(6) Å and β = 110.9(1)°.21 Coronene adopts a herringbone packing similar to picene,9,18 containing two crystallographically equivalent molecules in the lattice centred at (0, 0, 0) and (½, ½, 0) that are tilted at an interplanar angle (ω) of ∼85.42° (Fig. 2b),18,21 forming two alternating chains (X and Y) of coronene molecules stacked along the crystallographic b-axis that are separated by a distance of 4.70 Å, with voids located between adjacent chains (Fig. 2c).
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) Molecular structure of coronene (C24H12). Brown and light pink spheres represent carbon and hydrogen atoms, respectively. (b) Herringbone packing of coronene viewed along the crystallographic c-direction with hydrogen atoms omitted. (c) Void space in crystalline coronene computed and plotted using Mercury20 with a probe radius of 0.65 Å, showing voids lie between the chains. |
Density functional theory (DFT) calculations were performed on hypothetical structures of Kxcoronene (x = 1–4) by first inserting K in the largest existing void spaces in pristine coronene, located using Mercury (Fig. 2c and S3 ESI†) and on the basis of the porosity calculated using Zeo++, and then relaxing the resulting structures. The energies of the structures that resulted from this simple metal intercalation approach were then compared with those of solid crystalline coronene and K to produce the convex hull shown in Fig. 1d. These calculations indicate that Kxcoronene (x = 2–4) are more stable than isolated coronene and K, with K3coronene being on the convex hull and thereby most likely to form (Fig. 1d). The lowest energy structure of K3coronene optimized using plane–wave based density functional theory (DFT) as implemented in VASP22 (see Computational details in Methods, ESI†) revealed a significant rearrangement of the coronene molecules to accommodate the K+ ions. The rearrangement resulted in an increase of the coronene–coronene centre distance to 7.91 Å from 4.70 Å, the angle between two coronene molecules being increased to 101.24° from 85.42° (Fig. S2 and S3, ESI†). The position of K3coronene on the convex hull suggests that the energetic cost of the positional and orientational coronene rearrangement can be overcome by the electrostatic energies associated with intercalation to afford the salt.
Guided by the DFT results, synthesis at the nominal ratio of 3:
1 KH
:
coronene was investigated initially. Variable temperature powder X-ray diffraction (VT-PXRD) data were measured in situ on a 3
:
1 KH
:
coronene mixture at 303 K, 423 K, 473 K and 523 K, held for 10 minutes with a measurement period of 1 hour at each temperature (Fig. S4, ESI†). This reveals the formation of a new crystalline phase (reflections marked by *) at 473 K. As the temperature is increased to 523 K, the peaks of the new phase become dominant, with KH Bragg reflections having low intensity, and no coronene reflections observed, indicating near complete reaction at this temperature.
The stoichiometry of Kxcoronene was further explored by synthesising samples with nominal x = 2, 2.5, 3, 4, and 5 at 523 K in an evacuated quartz ampoule. The powder pattern of the reaction run at a 3:
1 ratio of KH
:
coronene contains the new crystalline peaks which were observed by VT-XRD (denoted as K3coronene, marked as *), with no observable peaks that can be attributed to the starting materials (Fig. S5, ESI†). As the ratio of KH in the starting mixture decreases (i.e., 2.5
:
1 and 2
:
1 ratio of KH
:
coronene), a second set of new peaks separate from those associated with K3coronene are observed, indicating that a mixture of two different phases form for x < 3. The intensities of the peaks associated with the secondary phase (denoted Kxcoronene′) increase with decreasing KH
:
coronene ratio (Fig. S5, ESI†). Ratios greater than 3
:
1 (i.e., 4
:
1 and 5
:
1 ratio of KH
:
coronene) result in unreacted KH in the product (Fig. S5, ESI†) alongside the peaks associated with K3coronene. Therefore, the nominal ratio of 3
:
1 (KH
:
coronene) and reaction temperature of 523 K for two durations of 6 hours with intermediate regrinding, are the optimal synthesis conditions for the formation of K3coronene. Reactions using K metal and coronene at the same compositions yielded amorphized products along with KH (Fig. S6 and S7, ESI†), highlighting the limitation of using strong reducing agents in the synthesis of intercalated PAHs, as this can lead to cleavage of the C–H σ bond and the formation of KH. Therefore, no further characterizations and measurements were done for K-metal:coronene products.
Fig. 3 shows the PXRD patterns of five different batches of K3coronene (labelled as K3cor-1 to K3cor-5), all of which were prepared using the same synthetic protocol of solid state grinding and annealing for 6 hours at 523 K (see Methods in ESI†). All the batches show a majority crystalline phase of K3coronene with no unreacted KH or coronene and, except K3cor-1, a small amount of Kxcoronene′ (marked by □). The strongest Bragg reflection from Kxcoronene′ is 1.4(5) %, 2.2(4) %, 3.4(8) %, 6.1(7) % of the strongest reflection from K3coronene for K3cor-2 to K3cor-5 respectively. In addition to K3coronene and Kxcoronene′, each sample contains varied amounts of an amorphous phase (quantified using internal diamond standard27) ranging from 0.0 wt% for K3cor-2 to 27.4 wt% for K3cor-4 (Table S2, Section S4, ESI†). This illustrates the challenge in isolating a phase pure powder of K3coronene due to competing side reactions to produce secondary crystalline phase(s) or amorphous phases, and is highly dependent on the characteristics of individual reactions, possibly due to a combination of variances in hand-ground mixing and weighing discrepancies (±0.2 mg) between samples (Table S2†). From these synthesis outcomes, it can be concluded that a 3:
1 ratio of KH and coronene gives a single crystalline phase that can be isolated nearly free from amorphous and other crystalline components but is prone to undergo decomposition at temperatures above 473 K (Fig. S6, ESI†), suggesting metastability and sensitivity to precise reaction conditions that is challenging to fully control.
Elemental analysis (using ICP and CHN) of K3cor-1 to K3cor-5 is close to the nominal composition (Table S2, Section S4, ESI†). To understand the fate of the coronene molecule during the synthesis process, mass spectroscopy (MS) and 1H-Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (1H-NMR) spectroscopy were performed on K3coronene samples that had been oxidised by controlled exposure to air (see Methods in ESI†). From MS we observe the most intense peak at 301.10 m/z corresponding to C24H13+ (coronene, C24H12, molecular weight: 300.1 g mol−1) (Fig. S8, Section S5, ESI†). 1H-NMR of oxidised K3coronene, using toluene-d8 as solvent, shows a singlet at chemical shift (δ) = 8.65 ppm as the most intense peak belonging to hydrogens in the coronene molecule (coronene has only 1 type of H present, manifested as a singlet) alongside minor peaks due to the side hydrogenation reaction of coronene to form 1,2 dihydrocoronene (Fig. S10, Section S5, ESI†). From both MS and 1H-NMR, we see that the majority of the coronene molecules remain intact during the synthetic process, with a minor hydrogenation by-product. Given the low solubility of coronene in toluene-d8, the exact amount of 1,2 dihydrocoronene cannot be ascertained. However, the total amount of the hydrogenation by-product is small (<5 mol%) given the low intensity of the extra peaks in the 1H-NMR spectrum (Table S3, ESI†) and absence from the MS (see Section S5 in ESI† for more details regarding MS and 1H-NMR).
Compound | Coronene | K3.03(3)coronene | Kxcoronene′ |
Space group | P21/a | C2 | Cc |
a (Å) | 16.119(6) | 15.0524(12) | 41.789(9) |
b (Å) | 4.702(4) | 21.892(2) | 13.227(4) |
c (Å) | 10.102(6) | 13.3640(14) | 20.853(3) |
β (o) | 110.9(1) | 122.917(5) | 34.065(5) |
Vol (Å3) | 715.2(9) | 3696.1(6) | 6457(3) |
Source | Ref. 21 | Rietveld | Pawley |
The final refined structure contains two independent coronene sites, both on general positions. One site (denoted site 1) contains a single fully occupied ordered molecule (coronene ‘a’), while the second site (site 2) accommodates two disordered molecules (coronene ‘b’ and ‘c’, with refined occupancies of 0.25 (10) and 0.75 (10) respectively). The disordered coronene molecules are centred on the same co-ordinates but rotate independently of each other (Fig. 4a–d). The K sites are generally disordered within the structure and were all located using simulated annealing during the structure solution (see ESI†). The structure has 11 occupied K sites, nine of which are on the general 4c position, with the remaining two on the 2b position, four of which are fully occupied (K1, K3, K7 and K9), three with a refined occupancy of 0.5 (K5, K6 and K10), one with a refined occupancy of 0.41 (K11), with the remaining three sites having refined occupancies between 0.25–0.28 (K8, K4 and K2) (Fig. 4e). The refined structure differs significantly from the computed structure of K3coronene, displaying even greater disruption of the original herringbone coronene packing driven by intercalation of the K+ ions. The overall refined composition is found to be K3.03(3)coronene which is close to the composition obtained from ICP and CHN (Table S2, ESI†).
Given the disordered coronenes (coronene ‘b’ and coronene ‘c’, Fig. 4d) are in the ratio of 0.25 (10):
0.75 (10), a locally represented model can be assembled where they are periodically arranged in a 1
:
3 ratio, within one unit cell. As each of the two coronene sites are on the general 4c position, this generates a total of 8 coronene molecules in the full unit cell. For site 1, the coronenes (coronene ‘a’) are fully ordered and thus contribute the first four molecules to the model. For site 2, the first molecule was set in the ‘b’ orientation, with the remaining three in the ‘c’ orientation, maintaining the refined ratio (Fig. 5a–c). When building this model, for each K site that does not have an occupancy of either 1, 0.5 or 0.25, their occupancies are rounded to whichever of these values is nearest (for example, K11, which has an occupancy of 0.41, is rounded to 0.5), resulting in a model with a composition of K3.125coronene. For the K2 and K8 sites, of the four sites generated, only the sites around the ‘a’ coronene generated from site 1 were retained, maintaining their rounded occupancy of 0.25. For the remaining partially occupied K+ sites, the corresponding number of K+ sites were retained to maintain the stoichiometry of the structure (e.g., half of the sites were retained for occupancy of 0.5, and a quarter of the sites generated for the remaining site with an occupancy of 0.25). The choice of which sites to retain was made retaining physically reasonable distances between neighbouring K+ sites and the individual coronene molecules. The distances and angles between the K+ ions and the centre of the closest aromatic ring of coronene molecules in the locally represented model are given in Fig. S11, ESI and Table S4, ESI.† Each K+ ion is bound to multiple coronene molecules, although the co-ordination is off-centre. Each K+ is closer to one coronene molecule, except for K2, which is equidistant to two neighbouring coronene molecules, the bonding to the closest coronene is shown for each K+ in Fig. S12.† The off centre co-ordination of the K+ ions is similar to that observed in K2picene. These distances and angles are comparable with the other K–PAH structures that have been reported, indicating the interactions in K3coronene are similar to the other K intercalated PAHs studied.29
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (a)–(c) A locally represented model of the structure of K3.03(3)coronene, derived from the disordered refined K3.03(3)coronene model. The rounding of K occupancies when assembling the local representation gives the composition K3.125coronene. Brown and pink spheres represent carbon and hydrogen, respectively. Purple and orange spheres represent K+ ions present within a chain and between the chains, respectively (see Fig. 6). |
In the locally represented model, coronene stacks in three types of chains along the a-axis. Chain 1 consists of ordered coronene in site 1 (coronene ‘a’) with alternating centre-to-centre spacing of 4.98 (5) Å and 10.08 (5) Å (Fig. 6a) (here “centre” refers to the geometric centre of each coronene molecule), compared with 4.70 Å in pristine coronene. This alternation arises from the insertion of K+ ions (K1, K3, K4, K7) between every pair of coronene molecules in the chain creating the 10.08(5) Å separation, with a 4.98(5) Å separation within the pairs themselves (Fig. S14, Section S6, ESI†). Chain 1 retains the same face-to-face orientation of coronene molecules observed in pristine coronene, but with the alternating spacing between pairs of molecules to allow for the intercalation of K+ ions. In chain 2, coronene ‘c’ from site 2 stacks along a-axis with alternating 8.38(6) Å and 6.67(6) Å spacings. Similarly, chain 2′ comprises alternating coronene ‘b’ and coronene ‘c’ molecules, with alternating 8.38(6) Å and 6.67(6) Å separation (Fig. 6a). In both chains 2 and 2′, there are intercalated K+ between every coronene molecule (Fig. S15 and S16, ESI†), in contrast to the presence of coronene pairs in chain 1. Apart from these K+ ions located within the chains, the remaining K+ ions (K6, K8 and K11) reside between the chains as shown in Fig. S17, ESI.† The orientation of molecules in both variations of chain 2 do not follow that observed in pristine coronene.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 (a) Locally represented model of K3coronene derived from the refined disordered structure shown in Fig. 4, showing the different chains formed along the a-axis. The distances between the centres of coronene molecules along the chain and the angles between different coronene molecules are also shown. The K+ ions intercalate both within and between the chains, and are shown in Fig. S14–S17, ESI.† (b–d) Void space of the locally represented model of K3coronene computed and plotted using Mercury20 with a probe radius of 1.0 Å along a-, b- and c-crystallographic directions respectively. Coronene molecules are removed in (b) and (d) to get a clearer view of the void space. The K atoms (purple spheres) reside inside the computed voids (green area). |
In crystalline K2pentacene, K2picene K2rubrene and K2tetracene, the predominant C–H⋯π interactions that were present in the structure of the parent molecule were found intact after incorporation of the K+ ions, with formation of a large void within the herringbone chains, via simple rotation around the molecular axis (Fig. S18 and S19, ESI†).9,11,12 These voids can only accommodate ∼2 K+ ions per PAH molecule. Attempts to synthesise phases with a higher ratio (>2:
1 of KH
:
PAH) of K+ ions resulted in unreacted KH in the product mixture for picene and pentacene,9 while for K+-intercalated rubrene, they resulted in a significant amount of a secondary phase KxR′.11 For K+ ion intercalated tetracene, there are only two voids that K+ ions can occupy and therefore, cannot physically intercalate a higher ratio (>2) of K+ ions.12 In the parent crystalline coronene, the coronene molecules are also packed in a herringbone fashion similar to picene and pentacene (Fig. 2b).21 However, unlike any previously reported K+ intercalated PAHs, the formation of a K+ ion intercalated phase in coronene is possible at a ratio of ∼3
:
1 between KH and coronene. Given pristine coronene has similar porosity, calculated by Zeo++, to the other PAHs mentioned (Table S1, ESI†), intercalation of more K+ ions per molecule than the other PAHs required a more extensive reorientation of the coronene molecules in order to create multiple pockets within the chains, thereby disrupting its original herringbone motif. In pristine coronene, the angle between the two coronene molecules in neighbouring chains is 85.42° (Fig. 2b), whereas after the K+ ions intercalation and subsequent reorientation of the coronene molecules, the angles between the coronene molecules decreases to 36.85° between coronene molecules ‘b’ and ‘c’ and 16.48° between coronene molecules ‘a’ and ‘c’ (Fig. 6a). In contrast the angles between molecules in pristine picene (57.89°), pentacene (52.9°), and tetracene (51.4°) can rotate to open up more void space in K2pentacene, K2picene K2rubrene and K2tetracene where the molecules in alternating chains align at ∼90° to each other.9,11,12 K+ intercalation in coronene results in the extensive reorientation of chain 2/2′ giving coronene molecules with much shallower angles between chain 1 and chain 2/2′ (Fig. 4a–c). The reorientation of coronene molecules increases the void fraction (the percentage of the unit cell calculated to be void space) from 4.3% of the unit cell volume in the parent to 22.7% allowing the incorporation of three K+ ions per coronene molecule. The void fraction in K3.03(3)coronene is higher compared to K2picene (6.0% of the unit cell) and K2pentacene (12.5% of the unit cell), thereby affording the larger number of K+ ions within the cell, reflecting the much greater disruption to the original herringbone packing in the original coronene case. When incorporating 3 K+ ions into C60 its void fraction increases from 13% in the pristine material to 19.4% in K3C60, a much smaller increase overall compared to K3.03(3)coronene but with a similar value for the intercalated materials, indicating the larger void fraction necessary to accommodate 3 K+ ions and manifesting via the disruption to the original herringbone packing.
After incorporation of K+ ions in coronene, although there is disruption to the herringbone packing, part of the original motif remains intact. The chains in pristine coronene are stacked along the crystallographic b-axis, with each chain being surround by six neighbouring chains in the ac plane (Fig. 7a). In K3.03(3)coronene, although we see reorientation of the coronene molecules, the close packing of the chains is retained, with each chain being similarly surrounded by six neighbouring chains (Fig. 7b). The retention of packing motif between chains upon K+ intercalation is also observed for picene and pentacene (Fig. 7a, b and S19, ESI†).
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 (a) Packing of different chains in pristine coronene along the b-axis. The chains consist of equivalent coronene molecules. Each coronene chain is surrounded by six neighbouring chains as depicted by their respective distances. The brown spheres represent the carbon atoms of coronene. Hydrogens are removed for clarity. (b) Packing of different chains in K3.03(3)coronene viewed along the a-axis (equivalent to the b-axis in coronene). Similar to coronene, each chain in K3.03(3)coronene is also surrounded by six neighbouring chains. The K+ ions are removed for clarity. Chains including K+ ions positions are shown in Fig. S20, ESI.† (c) Crystal structure of coronene viewed along the c-axis, and (d) crystal structure of K3.03(3)coronene viewed along the b-axis. Chain 1 consists of a larger coronene–coronene centre-to-centre distance between a molecular pair separated by K+ ions that alternates with a shorter distance which does not contain such K+ ions. The motif of coronene orientations in chain 1 resembles that of chain X in pristine coronene while chain 2/2′ reorients and forms a disordered chain in order to accommodate the K+ ions (purple spheres represent K+ ions within the chain and orange spheres between the chains). While disordered in the experimental structure, chain 2/2′ form two distinct chain types when a locally represented model was determined. The red boxes in (c) and (d) are representative of the packing of coronene with the vertices placed at either end of a chain of four coronene molecules in Chain X (coronene) and Chain 1 (K3.03(3)coronene), which is heavily distorted upon K+ intercalation, with alternating short and long coronene–coronene distances (the box does not represent the unit cell, the unit cell is given by the black solid lines). |
In chain 1 in K3.03(3)coronene, consisting only of ordered coronene ‘a’, the molecular arrangement resembles that of chain X in pristine coronene (Fig. 7c, d and S20, ESI†). The larger coronene–coronene centre-to-centre distance of 10.08(5) Å is due to the intercalation of K+ ions between pairs of coronene molecules. The alternate shorter coronene–coronene centre distance of 4.98(5) Å in chain 1, between which there are no intercalating K+ ions, is close to the distance of 4.70 Å in pristine coronene. Despite their alternating long and short distances, their orientation remains similar to that of pristine coronene (Fig. 7c, d and S20, ESI†). The other chain of pristine coronene (chain Y), however, undergoes a reorientation and becomes disordered forming chain 2/2′ in K3.03(3)coronene, together with an increase in the molecular separation to accommodate the K+ ions between every coronene in the chain.
The as-measured ZFC-FC susceptibility data show a divergence in their temperature dependence below 300 K indicative of ferromagnetic impurities. The starting material coronene, when measured without any previous thermal treatment, shows diamagnetism. A similar ZFC-FC divergence to K3coronene (Fig. S23a, ESI†) is observed for pristine coronene after treatment with the temperature profile used in the synthesis of K3coronene (Fig. S23b, ESI†). To remove the contributions from these unknown ferromagnetic impurities, the 2–300 K magnetic susceptibility (χ) was determined as the difference in the high field magnetic moment at applied fields of 6.5 and 5.5 T (Fig. 9a). The magnetic susceptibility obtained in this way is comparable with the susceptibility values obtained directly from the M(H) isotherms. Field-dependent magnetization isotherms were also measured on samples K3cor-1 between 2–300 K from 0 to 7 T (Fig. S24†). The susceptibility was obtained from the slope of the linear component between 5–7 T (see methods in ESI†). The susceptibility increases with decreasing temperature, has a maximum at 4.5 K and then decreases with temperature upon cooling. We note though that the maximum in χ may be artificial as it could result from paramagnetic saturation at high fields and low temperatures affecting the extracted magnetic susceptibility.
The susceptibility data fitted with a modified form of the Curie–Weiss law32 taking into account the temperature-independent background contributions (χ0), in the temperature range of 10–300 K, yields a Curie–Weiss temperature (θCW) of −3.0 (3) K indicative of antiferromagnetic interactions. The Curie constant, C is found to be 0.0128 (4) emu K mol−1 Oe−1 corresponding to an effective magnetic moment, μeff of 0.319 (4) μB per f.u. The number of unpaired electrons (n) is then calculated using the equation, and corresponds to 0.05 unpaired electrons per coronene molecule. The temperature independent term χ0 is found to be 15.60 (4) × 10−4 emu mol−1 Oe−1. Should χ0 indicate Pauli susceptibility of the metallic K3coronene phase, then this phase would be characterised by a large density of states at the Fermi energy that is comparable with Rb2CsC60 (χ0 = 7 × 10−4 emu mol−1)31 and K3C60 (χ0 = 3.8 × 10−4 emu mol−1).33 As this is very unlikely even for a narrow band correlated system and is not corroborated by EPR spectra (vide infra) we conclude that large χ0 probably results from our difficulties in complete subtraction of the ferromagnetic impurity contributions. All the fitting parameters are given in Table S5, Section S7, ESI.†
Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, which is sensitive to the magnetic coronene molecules only, is performed for a more detailed magnetic characterization. At room temperature, we observe an intense X-band EPR signal for all K3coronene samples (Fig. 9b and S25, Section S7, ESI†). The EPR spectrum is centred at g = 2.0033, as expected for a PAH molecular system with a very weak spin–orbit coupling. A very small deviation of measured g-factor from the free-electron value ge = 2.0023 suggests that the EPR response is dictated largely by the coronene molecular orbitals and that the remaining s-electron density on the potassium metals must be very small.34 The measured EPR signal does not show any significant lineshape anisotropy that would be attributed to the Dyson lineshape typically found in metallic samples. 35 A fit to a Lorentzian lineshape (Fig. 9b) yields the room-temperature EPR linewidth of ΔB = 0.40 ± 0.01 mT while the EPR signal intensity calibration shows that only around 10% of the coronene molecules contribute to the measured signal which is close to the 5% of unpaired spins estimated from SQUID magnetometry.
On cooling, the intensity of EPR signal, χEPR, increases with decreasing temperature, initially approximately following the Curie–Weiss law between room temperature and ∼20 K (Fig. 9c). This agrees with the insulating nature of the K3coronene compound and corroborates the absence of Dyson-like lineshape asymmetry (Fig. 9b). The EPR linewidth first decreases with decreasing temperature down to 25 K where ΔB reduces to 0.16 ± 0.01 mT (Fig. 9d). We notice that in the large temperature interval between 50 K and 150 K, the EPR linewidth follows linear temperature dependence. In the same temperature interval between room temperature and 25 K, the g-factor remains constant within the experimental precision. However, below ∼20 K, we start to observe deviations from the high-temperature trends in all EPR parameters. First, χEPR becomes dependent on the precise cooling protocol that is used. For example, in measurements taken after rapidly cooling the sample to the lowest temperature of T = 4 K, χEPR is suppressed compared to the Curie–Weiss-like dependence, but above ∼20 K it coincides with the data taken in the slow cooling experiments. Similarly, the EPR spectra start to broaden on cooling below ∼25 K and ΔB increases to 0.22 ± 0.01 mT at 4 K (Fig. 9d) in the slow cooling experiment. On the other hand, the broadening (ΔB = 0.19 ± 0.01 mT at 4 K) is less pronounced if the sample has been initially rapidly cooled.
The almost ideal Lorentzian lineshape of EPR spectra and the Curie–Weiss-like temperature dependence of EPR spin susceptibility confirm the insulating state of K3coronene. This speaks for the charge localisation on orientationally disordered coronene molecules. The two main mechanisms for the charge localisation are the disorder-induced localisation in Anderson insulators and electron–electron driven localisation in Mott insulators.36 As both the disorder and electron correlations are present in the investigated system, the emerging magnetic state may be especially complex.
Yet the small magnitude of EPR spin susceptibility of K3coronene containing formal coronene3− units is surprising from the perspective of molecular orbital energies (Fig. 1b). Our SQUID and EPR data exclude itinerant paramagnetism and the magnetic response is compatible with the local moments. Structural motifs, especially for the chains 1 and 2′, comprise two coronene molecules in close contact (Fig. S13, ESI†). Model DFT calculations of exchange coupling of coronene3− pairs show that the singlet state is their ground state, but the exact details of exchange depend on the relative molecular shift and tilt (see Section S8 DFT calculations in ESI†). Therefore, there is a strong tendency for singlet formation at the observed coronene separations and the structural motifs determined for K3.03(3)coronene are consistent with complete moment suppression. This may then explain the extensive magnetic moment loss, which is consistently observed in both SQUID and EPR measurements on multiple samples where the chemical composition, phase purity and crystalline content are consistent. However, as the structure itself is heavily disordered (Fig. 4a–c), the optimal coronene3−–coronene3− contact is not satisfied in all cases, e.g., for chain 2′, and thus some of the unpaired coronene3− spins are recovered and detected in our experiments. The studied K3coronene structure is too disordered to reliably identify all the specific pairwise interactions that in reality contribute to the balance between singlet coronene dimers and coronene3− free moments. The extensive disorder and the range of relative molecular shifts and tilts that will combat this align with our robust observation of incomplete moment suppression in EPR and SQUID measurements.
In contrast to the previously characterized K+ intercalated PAHs (namely picene, pentacene, rubrene and tetracene), structural investigation of K3.03(3)coronene revealed that the herringbone motif is disrupted by the incorporation of K+. Pristine picene, pentacene, rubrene and tetracene all have angles between the molecules in the herringbone structure of 50°–60° (Fig. S1†), and on intercalation these angles increase close to 90° (Fig. S18†) to create the voids for K+, but the herringbone motif is not significantly disrupted. In pristine coronene the angle between molecules in the herringbone structure is already close to 90° (85.4°, Fig. 2b) meaning the structural response to intercalation is through the disruption of the herringbone motif, although the chains and their packing are retained. The disrupted herringbone structure allows the intercalation of more K+ ions per PAH in coronene compared to the PAH hosts studied previously, reflected in the larger void space. K3.03(3)coronene consists of chains of ordered coronene in site 1 and disordered coronene in site 2 along the crystallographic a-axis. Despite the apparent disruption of the herringbone packing, after the K+ intercalation site 1 is identifiable as retaining the motif of pristine coronene. The K+ ions in the lattice reside in the voids formed both within and between chains as a result of the rearrangement of the coronene molecules. Contrary to previous reports, none of the K3coronene batches synthesized here show superconductivity in the temperature range of 2–300 K: since there are now an uneven number of electrons transferred per PAH, this must focus attention on still-unidentified amorphous decomposition products as candidate superconductors, or other phenomena as potential sources of the reported negative magnetisation than superconductivity. Magnetic measurements on K3coronene are instead consistent with local-moment magnetism where extensive loss of magnetic moments is due to the spin-singlet formation on pairs of nearest neighbouring coronene3− anions.
Given the challenges in synthetic isolation of alkali metal PAH materials, the computationally-enabled workflow applied here can enable experimental effort to be targeted on the most tractable candidates, both in terms of PAH host and intercalation composition. This would assist assessment of newly synthesised PAH as candidate intercalation hosts, and also allow evaluation of the use of multiple metals to occupy the potential inter- and intrachain sites within the herringbone packings studied here. Although K3.03(3)coronene is definitively not superconducting, the 3− anion charge and degenerate LUMO indicate that it is possible to attain high-level compositional and electronic similarity with the A3C60 systems.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Materials and methods, porosity analysis, PXRDs of reactions between coronene with K-metal and KH, elemental analysis, relative impurity phase, amorphous content, mass spectra and 1H-NMR spectra, crystal structure of K3coronene, MAS-NMR, magnetization data, DFT calculation. CCDC 2371799. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc05128a |
‡ MD and ABC contributed equally in this manuscript. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |