Xian-Bao
Cai
ab,
Dong
Liang
a,
Deng-Chao
Zhang
c,
Ji-Hui
Jia
c,
Xiao-Yuan
Wu
a and
Can-Zhong
Lu
*abd
aCAS Key Laboratory of Design and Assembly of Functional Nanostructures, Fujian Provincial Key Laboratory of Nanomaterials, Fujian Institute of Research on the Structure of Matter, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Fuzhou, Fujian 350002, China. E-mail: czlu@fjirsm.ac.cn
bCollege of Chemistry, Fuzhou University, Fuzhou, 350116, P. R. China
cSchool of Materials Science and Engineering, Fujian University of Technology, Fuzhou, Fujian 350118, P. R. China
dFujian College, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Fuzhou, Fujian 350002, China
First published on 23rd April 2025
Controlling excited-state dynamics is crucial for achieving dual emissions of ultralong room-temperature phosphorescence (URTP) and thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF), but remains challenging in the exploration of transition-metal compounds. Herein, we propose a new strategy to develop highly efficient TADF and URTP dual-emission materials by modulating URTP organic molecules through metal ion coordination. Specifically, Ag+ ions narrow the singlet-triplet energy gap (ΔEST) and enhance spin–orbit coupling (SOC), thereby accelerating intersystem crossing (ISC) and facilitating reverse intersystem crossing (RISC). The Ag+ ions also balance radiative transitions and RISC processes of the T1 state. Consequently, coordinating the URTP molecule Phen-Tpa with Ag+ ions results in an Ag(I) complex that exhibits efficient ligand-centered TADF and URTP dual emissions in MeOBP films, with a quantum yield of 85%, an afterglow duration of 6 seconds, and a record long emission lifetime of 575.7 ms. Moreover, Phen-Tpa can be used to fabricate organic white light-emitting diodes (LEDs), while both Phen-Tpa and the Ag(I) complex offer high-security anti-counterfeiting capabilities. These results deepen the understanding of how metal fragment coordination influences luminescence mechanisms and provide a new approach for achieving dual emissions with coexisting TADF and URTP in transition-metal compounds.
kISC(RISC) ∝ 〈1Ψ|ĤSO|3Ψ〉/exp(ΔEST2) |
TADF and URTP phenomena have also been reported in certain Ag(I) complexes.31–35 In 2019, Yersin and co-workers designed an Ag(I) material that exhibits intense phosphorescence with an unprecedentedly long lifetime of τ = 110 ms.36 In this Ag(I) complex, the lowest triplet state frequently features a ligand-centered (LC) character due to relatively high ionization potential of Ag(I) with low-lying d-orbitals. This LC property also contributes to ligand-centered fluorescence and long-lived phosphorescence in many Ag(I) complexes.37,38 Consequently, the development of Ag(I) TADF compounds has been significantly hindered. Therefore, Lu and co-workers have focused on the ligand-centered nature of silver compounds as a novel approach to designing TADF, referred to as coordination-induced TADF.39,40 In these materials, the HOMO and LUMO are mainly distributed on the donor and acceptor (D–A) moieties of the ligand, and the corresponding excited states (S1 and T1) typically exhibit intra-ligand charge transfer (ILCT) characteristics. The coordination of silver ions significantly reduces ΔEST and enhances SOC between S1 and T1, thereby facilitating RISC and enabling the generation of TADF, which highlights the crucial role of silver ions in regulating excited-state dynamics. It is widely accepted that silver ions play a crucial role in regulating emission mechanisms and achieving TADF and URTP emissions. However, their specific role in modulating dual-emission systems that combine TADF and URTP remains largely unexplored. Therefore, investigating the influence of metal ions on controlling these dual-emission behaviors is of great significance. Such dual-emission materials are not only important for advancing our understanding of new luminescence mechanisms but also hold significant potential for enabling advanced applications.26
In this paper, dual TADF and URTP emissions were successfully achieved through metal coordination. We synthesized the previously reported pure organic D–A-type phosphorescent molecule,41 4,4′-(1,10-phenanthroline-3,8-diyl)bis(N,N-diphenylaniline) (Phen-Tpa), in which the triphenylamine (Tpa) groups act as electron donors and the phenanthroline moiety (Phen) acts as an electron acceptor. The photophysical properties of the ligands in MeOBP films were investigated, revealing white emission with CIE (x, y) coordinates of (0.31, 0.32) and yellow afterglow photoluminescence (PL), achieving a total quantum yield of 99% and a phosphorescence quantum yield of up to 37.2%. It also displays a long RTP lifetime of 781.6 ms. With the Phen-Tpa and phosphine ligands (4,5-bis(diphenylphosphino)-9,9-dimethylxanthene (Xantphos)), a green- and yellow afterglow-emitting Ag(I) complex was designed, exhibiting ligand-centered TADF and URTP dual emission pathways that coexist in the films, with a high quantum yield of 85% and a long lifetime of 575.7 ms at room temperature. In addition, the intriguing luminescent properties of Phen-Tpa and its silver complex make them promising candidates for white LED devices and anti-counterfeiting applications. To the best of our knowledge, this compound is the first reported Ag(I) molecule that simultaneously exhibits both TADF and URTP properties, along with the longest emission lifetime. Our findings not only provide a new strategy for designing Ag(I) compounds with dual TADF and URTP emission capabilities and long afterglow properties, but also offer deeper insights into how metal fragment coordination influences luminescence mechanisms, expanding the potential for high-performance application.
The chemical and X-ray structures of the free Phen-Tpa ligand and its silver complex are shown in Fig. 1a; selected crystallographic data are listed in Table S1.† As shown in Fig. 1a, the Ag(I) cation chelated with the free ligand Phen-Tpa and the phosphorus ligand Xantphos to form twisted tetrahedral structures. The Ag–N distances are 2.317(15) and 2.374(18) Å, and the Ag–P distances are 2.513(6) and 2.389(6) Å. These distances are in the normal range. The dihedral angle between P–Ag–P and N–Ag–N in complex 1 is 86.2(6)°. The dihedral angles between the donor triphenylamine moieties and the acceptor phenanthroline are 19.504(19)° and 47.071(17)° for the Phen-Tpa ligand and 33.298(25)° and 46.754(10)° for complex 1 (Fig. S1†). Compared to the free ligand Phen-Tpa, complex 1 exhibits a larger torsion angle between the donor and acceptor moieties, which leads to a reduced ΔEST and improved TADF performance.
To investigate the influence of metal coordination on photophysical properties, the UV-vis absorption and emission spectra of the Phen-Tpa ligand and complex 1 were measured. The photophysical parameters are listed in Table 1. The energy levels of these compounds calculated from their electrochemical and photophysical data are summarized in Table 2. Fig. 1b shows the UV-vis spectra of Phen-Tpa and complex 1 in CH2Cl2 solution. The absorption spectra of the free ligand Phen-Tpa and complex 1 exhibit intense absorption bands between 260–450 nm and 260–475 nm, respectively, assigned to the π → π* transitions within the Phen-Tpa and phosphine ligands. In addition, the broad absorptions at around 450 to 500 nm for Phen-Tpa and 475 to 520 nm for complex 1 are attributed to the charge transfer from the donor to the acceptor moieties. The absorption spectrum of complex 1 is clearly red-shifted compared to that of the Phen-Tpa ligand, indicating a slightly smaller HOMO–LUMO gap, consistent with the DFT and TD-DFT calculation results. The optical energy gaps (Eg) estimated from the absorption edges are 2.88 eV and 2.65 eV for the Phen-Tpa ligand and complex 1, respectively. To further investigate the photophysical properties of Phen-Tpa and complex 1, organic films were fabricated by doping both compounds at a 0.05 wt% concentration in 4-methoxybenzophenone matrices using the melt-casting technique, following a previously reported procedure.42–44 A low dopant concentration was used to prevent the quenching caused by high concentrations of triplet excitons. As shown in Fig. 1c, both Phen-Tpa and complex 1 emit in the organic films, with afterglow durations of 6 to 7 seconds. Fig. 1b shows the steady-state PL spectra of Phen-Tpa and complex 1 in air. The structured spectrum of Phen-Tpa indicates that the excited state has local excitation (LE) characteristics. The free Phen-Tpa ligand exhibits white emission with CIE (x, y) coordinates of (0.31, 0.32) and displays a yellow afterglow PL in MeOBP films at room temperature, with a high quantum yield of 99%. The transient PL decay spectra of Phen-Tpa at 298 K show a prompt fluorescence lifetime of 2 ns for the S1 excited state, followed by long-lived phosphorescence with a lifetime of 781.6 ms (Fig. S7† and 2a). Time-resolved PL spectra (Fig. 2c) of the Phen-Tpa ligand show a redshift of the PL maximum from 456 to 544 nm after a delay of 5 ns and exhibit a strong vibrational shape after a delay of 68.3 ms at room temperature, indicating that the delayed emissions are not TADF. The different emission profiles at various delayed times demonstrate that the ligand has two components, ascribed to prompt fluorescence and ultralong RTP. Based on the above analysis, the emission band from 512 to 820 nm, primarily attributed to phosphorescence, exhibits a high quantum yield of 37.2%. The photophysical properties of Phen-Tpa were measured at 77 K to further investigate the nature of its excited states. The steady-state spectrum of Phen-Tpa is shown in Fig. S8a.† It differs from the spectrum at room temperature; the 77 K spectrum shows significantly enhanced phosphorescence, which becomes much stronger than fluorescence. Fig. S8c† shows the time-resolved PL spectrum at 77 K (delayed by 50 ms), which is similar to that at 298 K (delayed by 68.3 ms), with both attributed to the 3LE nature of the T1 state. From the emission spectra of the free Phen-Tpa ligand in MeOBP films at 298 K, the energy levels of S1 (3.01 eV) and T1 (2.48 eV) were estimated (Table 2), with an experimental ΔEST value of 0.53 eV, which is too large for TADF to occur.
Compound | 298 K | 77 K | ||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
λ max (nm) | Φ PL (%) | Φ DF (%) | Φ P (%) | τ F (ns) | τ TADF (ms) | τ P (ms) | k ISC (108 s−1) | k RISC (s−1) | k p (s−1) | λ max (nm) | τ (ms) | |
a Measured in the film with excitation wavelengths of 450, 400 nm for 1 and Phen-Tpa. b The phosphorescence (ΦP) portions [%] for Phen-Tpa estimated from the quantum yields of the emission band between 512 and 820 nm. For complex 1, the delayed fluorescence (ΦDF) and phosphorescence (ΦP) portions [%] were estimated from transient PL decay curves and ΦPL. c Calculated ISC rate constant (kISC) and RISC rate constant (kRISC) using exciton lifetime and ΦPL values. | ||||||||||||
Phen-Tpa | 456, 544, and 584 | 99 | — | 37.2 | 2.0 | — | 781.6 | 1.86 | — | 1.28 | 542 | 1129 |
1 | 532 | 85 | 40.9 | 34.8 | 2.2 | 13.8 | 575.7 | 4.0 | 358.7 | 1.74 | 550 | 737 |
Compound | E g eV | HOMOb eV | LUMOc eV | 1CTd eV | 3LEe eV | ΔESTf(exp.) eV |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Estimated from the onset wavelengths of the absorption spectra measured in CH2Cl2 solution. b Calculated from the oxidation potentials of cyclic voltammetry measured in CH2Cl2 solution. c Calculated from the HOMO energy levels and ΔEg. d Estimated from the onset prompt fluorescence for 1 and Phen-Tpa. e Estimated from the onset wavelengths of the 298 K emission spectra (delayed 150 ms for 1 and delayed 68.3 ms for Phen-Tpa). f ΔEST = 1CT − 3LE. | ||||||
Phen-Tpa | 2.88 | −5.33 | −2.45 | 3.01 | 2.48 | 0.53 |
1 | 2.65 | −5.41 | −2.76 | 2.73 | 2.53 | 0.20 |
The Ag(I) complex emits greenish and yellow afterglow PL (λmax = 532 nm) in MeOBP films at room temperature and exhibits a high quantum yield of 85%. The PL spectra (Fig. 1b) at 298 K are broad and unstructured, suggesting that the corresponding emissive excited state possesses a charge-transfer character. The transient PL spectra of complex 1 were investigated to clarify the nature of its emissions. As shown in Fig. 2a and S7,† complex 1 displays two-component emission decays: a prompt nanosecond decay and a long-lived decay, with lifetimes of 2.2 ns and 575.7 ms, respectively. The time-resolved PL spectra of complex 1 were measured to further investigate its emission properties. The spectra of complex 1 at different delayed times (10 ns, 2.5 μs, and 3.5 ms) are identical (Fig. 2d), confirming that the delayed emission of complex 1 at room temperature contains TADF. At a delay time of 150 ms, the emission spectrum displays a pronounced red shift and a change in shape, indicating that the emission after 150 ms corresponds to phosphorescence. The delayed fluorescence transient PL spectra of complex 1 were measured (Fig. 2b) and show a long lifetime of 13.8 ms. The different emission profiles at various delayed times demonstrate that complex 1 has three components, attributed to prompt fluorescence, delayed fluorescence, and ultralong RTP. The photophysical properties of complex 1 were also investigated at 77 K. Fig. S8d† shows the time-resolved PL spectrum of complex 1 at 77 K with a delay time of 150 ms, which is consistent with the spectrum observed at 298 K at the same delay time. Both spectra are attributed to the T1 excited state with LE characteristics. The energy levels of S1 (2.73 eV) and T1 (2.53 eV) are estimated (Table 2) from the emission spectra at 298 K, giving an experimental ΔEST value of 0.20 eV. The smaller ΔEST compared to the free ligand and the heavy atom effect of Ag+ ions effectively promote the RISC process, enabling the observation of TADF in complex 1. The kRISC and kp values calculated from the photophysical properties are 358.7 and 1.74 s−1, respectively, while the kISC values for Phen-Tpa and complex 1 are 1.86 × 108 and 4 × 108 s−1. In complex 1, the RISC process is extremely slow, while the ISC process is notably faster compared to the ligand, leading to more efficient accumulation of T1. The comparable kRISC and kp values support the simultaneous occurrence of RISC and radiative transitions from T1, allowing the coexistence of TADF and ultralong RTP dual emissions. The dual emission results from the Ag+ ions balancing the radiative transition and the RISC processes of the T1. Additionally, the heavy-atom effect induced by Ag+ ions accelerates T1 radiative transitions, resulting in shorter decay times for complex 1 compared to the Phen-Tpa ligand.
To deeply understand the mechanism of the dual emission pathways of TADF and URTP, the molecular and electronic properties of both the ligand and complex 1 were investigated using DFT and TD-DFT calculations. These calculations offered further insights into the emission properties and the corresponding energy levels of the excited states in these compounds. The distributions of the HOMO and LUMO, along with the calculated frontier orbital energies in the optimized S0 structure, and the singlet (S1) and triplet (T1) energy gaps in the optimized S1 and T1 structures for Phen-Tpa and complex 1 are shown in Fig. 3a. In both the ligand Phen-Tpa and complex 1, the HOMO is primarily localized on the triphenylamine donor groups, with a small portion extending to the phenanthroline group, while the LUMO is mainly distributed on the phenanthroline acceptor, with only a minor contribution from the triphenylamine donor. The separation between the HOMO and LUMO in both the free ligand Phen-Tpa and complex 1 is facilitated by the large twisted geometry between the electron-donor (Tpa) and electron-acceptor (Phen) units. The optimized structure of the ligand shows a large gap of 3.73 eV between the HOMO and LUMO. Upon coordination with Ag+ ions, the energy levels of both the LUMO and HOMO of the ligand are decreased via electronic perturbation induced by the Ag+ ions, whereas the LUMO is stabilized more greatly for its direct connection to the Ag(I) group. The coordination of the Ag+ ions to the ligand in complex 1 results in a strong stabilization of 2.34 eV for the LUMO, with a smaller change observed in the HOMO energy (1.58 eV), leading to a reduced HOMO–LUMO energy gap of 2.97 eV.
Based on their optimized excited-state structures, the natural transition orbitals (NTOs) of the free Phen-Tpa ligand and complex 1 were analyzed. The SOC calculations were further conducted using the ORCA 5.0 program.45 The calculation results show that the S1 and T1 excited states are predominantly composed of transitions within the Phen-Tpa ligand (Fig. S4†). The calculated S1 state is principally composed of the HOMO–LUMO transition (98.56% for complex 1 and 96.24% for Phen-Tpa). NTO analyses indicate that, in complex 1, the S1 state is predominantly contributed by the charge transfer transition from the triphenylamine-based donor to the phenanthroline acceptor (81.43%), while in the ligand Phen-Tpa, the S1 state consists of a combination of charge transfer from the triphenylamine donor to the phenanthroline acceptor (54.46%) and localized excitation (LE) within the phenanthroline acceptor (45.54%). The calculated T1 state is mainly composed of the HOMO–LUMO transition (68.66% for the ligand and 77.98% for complex 1). And NTO analyses reveal that T1 consists of both a charge transfer transition from the triphenylamine-based donor to the phenanthroline-acceptor (53.61% for complex 1 and 19.41% for the Phen-Tpa) and LE inside the phenanthroline-acceptor (43.32% for complex 1 and 80.59% for the Phen-Tpa).
According to the El-Sayed rule,46 the distinct compositions of the T1 and S1 states in complex 1 increase SOC between them, thereby promoting ISC and RISC processes and enhancing TADF. In this case, the Phen-Tpa molecule has a large ΔEST value of 0.94 eV. The ΔEST is so large that it is not conducive to the occurence of TADF. Besides, the SOC value of 0.246 cm−1 between S0 and T1 is significantly higher than the 0.045 cm−1 between S1 and T1, ensuring a sufficiently fast transition rate from T1 to S0 for phosphorescence emission (Fig. 3a). Compared to the ligand Phen-Tpa, complex 1 has a lower calculated ΔEST of 0.08 eV and significantly increased SOC values of 2.703 cm−1 between T1 and S0, and 0.247 cm−1 between T1 and S1. The lower ΔEST and increased SOC facilitate the occurrence of TADF in complex 1 at room temperature. Meanwhile, the SOC from T1 to S0 was large enough, ensuring a relatively rapid transition rate from T1 to S0 for phosphorescence emission. From this, the coexistence of TADF and RTP dual emissions is expected to occur in the complex 1. Based on the theoretical calculations and experimental results, the PL processes of Phen-Tpa and the complex 1 are depicted in Fig. 3a. The Phen-Tpa ligand emits fluorescence and URTP; owing to the large ΔEST and weak SOC, TADF is not observed. After the coordination of Ag+ ions, the energy level of the S1 state is significantly lowered and that of the T1 state remains essentially unchanged. Therefore, ΔEST is reduced, and the Ag+ ions significantly enhance the SOC between the S1 and T1 states, thereby accelerating ISC and facilitating RISC. At the same time, the silver ions balance the radiative transition and the RISC process of T1, resulting in the dual emission of TADF and URTP in complex 1.
As mentioned above, the free Phen-Tpa ligand shows a white emission. To further authenticate its potential as a promising white-light emitter, we have fabricated a white LED (WLED) with the Phen-Tpa powders (0.05 wt% in MeOBP) covered on a commercial 365 nm UV chip. Then, bright white light emission could be observed when the LED is turned on (Fig. 3b) with CIE (x, y) coordinates of (0.35, 0.42) and a color-rendering index of Ra = 75 with a correlated color temperature (CCT) of 4921 K, corresponding to cool white light. Furthermore, the discrepant afterglow lifetime between Phen-Tpa and complex 1 could further improve the security level of anti-counterfeiting. Fig. 3c illustrates an encrypted pattern created using the free ligand Phen-Tpa and complex 1 powder (doped in MeOBP). Under 365 nm excitation, the pattern displays the number “8888”, which transitions to “1020” after the light is turned off due to the faster afterglow decay of complex 1 compared to Phen-Tpa. This method enables temporal anti-counterfeiting without the need for sophisticated time-gating technology.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2414838 and 2414839. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5sc00555h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |