Arun Kumar Gayen and
S. Ramakrishnan*
Department of Inorganic and Physical Chemistry, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore 560012, India. E-mail: raman@iisc.ac.in
First published on 11th February 2025
Linear polymers carrying electron-rich dialkoxy-carbazole (DACBZ) units linked by flexible oligooxyethylene segments were induced into a zigzag folded state by an external folding agent, which carries two subunits: an electron-deficient dinitro-naphthalene monoimide (NMI(NO2)2) acceptor and an ammonium perchlorate unit. The ammonium unit of the folding agent interacts with the backbone oxyethylene segment and, in turn, brings two adjacent CBZ moieties on either side of the electron-deficient NMI(NO2)2 unit of the folding agent to induce a charge-transfer (CT) interaction; this two-point interaction was shown to be crucial for the stability of the pleated chain structure. An interesting, and potentially useful, feature of this system is the possibility to incorporate a pendant unit at the carbazole nitrogen (N) site; a variety of segments, such as linear, branched, or chiral alkyl chains, were installed to examine if the folding of the chain is influenced by the nature of the pendant segment. The formation of the pleated structure was studied by 1H-NMR and UV-visible titration experiments; both these clearly revealed the presence of strong charge transfer (CT) interactions between the donor (D) and acceptor (A) units. The length of the spacer segment linking the NMI(NO2)2 acceptor unit and the ammonium group in the folding agent was varied, and it was seen that a 3-carbon spacer yielded the strongest cooperative interaction. To translate the folded conformation into the solid state, a solution of the donor polymer and the most efficient acceptor, taken in a 1:
1 (D:A) ratio, was cast on a quartz plate. UV-visible studies of the film revealed the retention of the CT band; more importantly, immersing the film into an aqueous NaHCO3 solution neutralized the ammonium group to generate the free amine. This caused an unexpected deepening of the colour, along with a hypsochromic shift of the CT band, suggesting that the free amine acceptor readjusts within the film to improve the CT interaction, exploiting the newly garnered freedom after de-coordination with the oligooxyethylene segment.
The concept of a small molecule folding agent to control the conformation of a polymer chain is attractive because of its reversibility; thus, this strategy could, in principle, be utilized to translate the control achieved in solution to organize polymer chains in the solid state. To achieve this, however, it is important to design systems where the interactions between the folding agent and the polymer chain are strong, yet reversible. Recently, we reported a new unsymmetrical D–A pair, based on dialkoxy-carbazole (DACBZ) and dinitro-naphthalene monoimide (NMI(NO2)2), which exhibited a relatively strong CT interaction.21 In the present study, we have incorporated the DACBZ donor unit along the polymer backbone linked via oligooxyethylene segments, and the NMI(NO2)2 acceptor was modified to carry a quaternized ammonium perchlorate. The interaction of the ammonium group with the oligooxyethylene segment via a podand-type interaction causes adjacent carbazole donor units to come together and form a CT complex with the NMI(NO2)2 acceptor, as depicted in Scheme 1; this two-point interaction is expected to stabilize the folded conformation.
We examined the folding using the evolution of the CT band in the UV-visible spectra and by following the variation in the proton NMR signals of the D and A units. Furthermore, we have examined the solid-state properties of the 1:
1 complex of one selected donor polymer and the most effective acceptor folding agent; it was seen that the CT complex-induced folded state is retained in thin films as well. Importantly, neutralizing the ammonium group by treatment of the film with an aqueous NaHCO3 solution releases the free amine and weakens the two-point interaction. Unexpectedly, this treatment led to a deepening of the colour, along with a small hypsochromic shift of the CT band, suggesting that the loosening of the podand-type interaction led to a slight rearrangement of the D and A units, causing a dramatic change in the absorption spectrum.
![]() | ||
Scheme 2 Synthesis of a donor-bearing polymer by a reaction of 3,6-dipropargyloxy-9-alkyl-carbazole and tetraethylene glycol diazide, using a Cu-catalyzed alkyne-azide click reaction. |
Comparison of the 1H-NMR spectra (Fig. 1) of the carbazole monomer with that of a representative polymer, poly-D(β-cit-S) (where R = (S)-β-citronellyl), confirms its structure; the disappearance of the propargyl proton peak at 2.54 ppm, the appearance of a new peak at 7.78 ppm corresponding to the triazole ring proton, and the downfield shift of the propargyl CH2 peak are in accordance with the structure of the expected polymer. Similarly, 3 other donor-containing polymers with different pendant units, namely, poly-D(C8-linear), poly-D(C8-branched), and poly-D(β-cit-rac), were synthesized; poly-D(β-cit-S) and poly-D(β-cit-rac) represent polymers carrying enantiomerically pure and racemic β-citronellyl units, respectively. The molecular weights of all the polymers were estimated by SEC using a triple detector system; three of the polymers had moderately high molecular weights (Mn > 30000), whereas one of them had a lower Mn value of ∼14
000, as seen in Table 1. An interesting observation was that the Mark–Houwink exponents, estimated using the in-line differential viscometer, reveal that the polymers bearing branched pendant units exhibit comparatively higher chain stiffness in THF (compare entries 1 and 2), while the other polymers adopt a random coil configuration in solution.
Having prepared the DACBZ donor-containing polymer, the synthesis of naphthalene monoimide-based external folding agents was undertaken; here, one of the objectives was to optimize the length of the spacer, linking the NMI(NO2)2 aromatic core and the ammonium group, for achieving maximum folding efficiency. Thus, 3,6-dinitronaphthalene anhydride was reacted with an excess of singly BOC-protected diamines, namely 1,2 diaminoethane, 1,3 diaminopropane, and 1,4-diaminobutane, as depicted in Scheme 3; the resulting naphthalene monoimides were then deprotected using perchloric acid to directly yield the required ammonium perchlorate salt.
For a comparative study of the folding process, a model n-propyl 3,6-dinitronaphthalene monoimide, which does not carry the ammonium unit (Scheme 3), was also prepared. The 1H-NMR spectra of all three folding agents (Fig. S1†) confirmed their structures.
The formation of the CT complex is well known to influence the chemical shift of the aromatic donor and acceptor protons;24 typically, since the CT complex undergoes rapid exchange on the NMR time scale, the observed chemical shift values represent a weighted average of the free (δD or δA) and complexed species (δDA). In Fig. 2, the proton NMR spectra of poly-D-C8-linear (aromatic regions of the donor and acceptor), in CDCl3:
CH3CN (1
:
2), with increasing concentrations of the acceptor, NMI(NO2)2-C2-NH3+ClO4−, are shown; in all cases, the two aromatic protons of the acceptor unit are seen to undergo a significant up-field shift with increasing formation of the CT complex species. It is important to note that, in the experimental protocol, the ratio of D
:
A is highest after the first aliquot of the acceptor is added; at this stage, most of the added acceptor will be complexed and the weighted average δ-value would be closest to that expected for the pure CT complex. Hence, the acceptor protons appear at a large up-field shifted value after the first addition, which then continuously moves down-field with increasing amounts of acceptor, as evident in the spectra (Fig. 2a, left panel). Likewise, all the donor aromatic protons also experience a gradual up-field shift upon CT complex formation (Fig. 2a, right panel); the extent of the shift is clearly not the same for all the protons, which is a reflection of the geometry of the CT complex.
The chemical shift variation of the three different carbazole aromatic protons, for this representative titration, with increasing amounts of added external acceptor molecule, is shown in Fig. 2b. To calculate the association constants (Ka), a binding isotherm (Fig. 2c), namely, the plot of the concentration of the CT complex as a function of the guest/host ratio, [G0]/[H0], was first generated from the chemical shift variation, using the online tool provided by Thordarson and co-workers, which uses a non-linear regression approach.25,26 From such fitted isotherms, the association constants were estimated, assuming a 1:
1 D–A complex. It is evident that the extent of folding that the polymer chain undergoes upon interaction with a folding agent will depend on the association constant (Ka) between them; here, note that the expected final structure will be one where the acceptor (A) would be sandwiched between two adjacent carbazole donors, as depicted in Scheme 1. Thus, the expected complexation ratio between D and A will be 1
:
1, when the entire chain adopts a folded conformation.
The values of association constants, estimated from the NMR titrations using the carbazole proton shifts, are listed in Table 2 (column 4); these values represent the average of the values obtained using the three different carbazole protons. Given that the typical percentage error in such a non-linear regression analysis, in our systems, is between 10 and 15%, one may conclude that the Ka values generally fall in the 1000–1500 M−1 range for different donor polymers, using the folding agent with a C2 spacer (compare entries 2–5). It is important to recognize that, here, we are not dealing with a simple D and A pair, where the product is a single D–A charge-transfer complex. In our systems, the donors are strung together in a polymer chain and the complexation is aided by the interaction of the ammonium group with the oligooxyethylene segment; this in turn would generate a D–A–D type of complex, in the early stages, where A gets sandwiched between two D units. In our earlier studies,17 using model compounds, we showed that the chemical shifts of the D protons of a simple D–A molecule are significantly different from those in the ADA trimer, but similar to those in the DAD trimer. In other words, when D lies between two A units, it experiences a larger shift than that in the simple DA case. Thus, as the chain folds, we would have a larger fraction of sandwiched D units. Therefore, it is evident that a fitting process, which optimizes for a single δDA value, would provide only a reasonable estimate of Ka values. Nevertheless, from these estimated values, it is evident that the nature of the lateral substituent does not affect the CT complexation very significantly, and consequently, the folding propensity is largely unaffected by the nature of the lateral substituent. On the other hand, variation in the spacer length in the folding agent would be expected to influence the folding, as was shown earlier;18 here, a flexible oligooxyethylene segment in the backbone of the polymer was specifically incorporated to coerce the folding via a podand-type interaction16–18 between the oligooxyethylene segment and ammonium of the acceptor folding molecule. To further examine this, the three folding agents, carrying spacer segments with two (C2), three (C3), and four (C4) methylene carbons, were compared; additionally, a model folding agent carrying a C3 segment without the ammonium unit was also studied. All the titration experiments were carried out with only a single donor polymer, namely poly-D(C8-linear); as earlier, titrations were carried out in a solvent mixture, namely CDCl3:
CH3CN (1
:
2). The 1H-NMR spectra as a function of varying amounts of different folding agents are shown in Fig. S5,† along with the variation of δ of different carbazole ring protons (Fig. S6†) and the calculated binding isotherms (Fig. S7†); the expected up-field shift of all the aromatic protons is seen with increasing CT complex formation. As earlier, we see that one of the three carbazole peaks (d) undergoes a significantly larger shift upon CT complex formation. Of the four folding agents, the change in the δ-value was maximum in the case of the C3 spacer, followed by C2 and then the C4 spacer (Fig. S6†). On the other hand, the model folding agent without the ammonium unit exhibited a much smaller change in the δ-values; as earlier, the nonlinear regression analysis yielded the association constant values, which are listed in Table 2 (entries 2, 6 and 7). It is evident that the spacer does play a very significant role; the folding agent with a C3 spacer exhibits a Ka value that is almost 75% greater than that of C2 and ∼100% greater than that of C4. Such an effect of the spacer segment in a two-point interaction was also seen earlier by Ghosh et al.18 On the other hand, the association constant value for the model folding agent (entry 1), with no ammonium group, was far smaller (264 M−1); thus, revealing the importance of the two-point interaction.
Entry | Polymer | Folding agent | Ka carbazole protons (M−1) |
---|---|---|---|
NMR titration method | |||
NE = not estimated (the CT band intensity is too low to estimate the Ka). | |||
1 | Poly-D (C8-linear) | NMI(NO2)2-C2-CH3 | 264 |
2 | Poly-D (C8-linear) | NMI(NO2)2-C2-NH3+ClO4− | 1316 |
3 | Poly-D (C8 branched) | NMI(NO2)2-C2-NH3+ClO4− | 1549 |
4 | Poly-D (β-cit-S) | NMI(NO2)2-C2-NH3+ClO4− | 1179 |
5 | Poly-D (β-cit-rac) | NMI(NO2)2-C2-NH3+ClO4− | 929 |
6 | Poly-D (C8-linear) | NMI(NO2)2-C3-NH3+ClO4− | 2032 |
7 | Poly-D (C8-linear) | NMI(NO2)2-C4-NH3+ClO4− | 1104 |
UV-visible titration method | Ka (UV-visible; λCT) | ||
8 | Poly-D (C8-linear) | NMI(NO2)2-C2-CH3 | NE |
9 | Poly-D (C8-linear) | NMI(NO2)2-C3-NH3+ClO4− | 1959 |
10 | Poly-D (C8 branched) | NMI(NO2)2-C3-NH3+ClO4− | 2325 |
11 | Poly-D (β-cit-S) | NMI(NO2)2-C3-NH3+ClO4− | 3395 |
12 | Poly-D (β-cit-rac) | NMI(NO2)2-C3-NH3+ClO4− | 4013 |
The UV-visible spectra of thin films of pure poly-D(C8-linear) and that of the 1:
1 polymer complex are compared in Fig. 4b; it is evident that the spectrum of a thin film of the CT-induced folded chains is similar to that in solution, with two CT absorption peaks at ∼455 nm and ∼590 nm. Likewise, the spectrum of the pure poly-D(C8-linear) film is essentially identical to that in solution (see the inset in Fig. 4b). To further understand the ordering present in the solid state, the WAXS profiles of thicker drop-cast films were compared (Fig. 4c); the films were evidently not highly ordered, but the broad peak at 20.98° in poly-D(C8-linear) and that at 22.58° in the CT complex film correspond to an average distance between the stacked aromatic rings of 4.2 and 3.9 Å, respectively. The small reduction in the average interplanar distance, in the presence of the aromatic acceptor, is consistent with the hypothesis that CT interaction-induced folding leads to stronger interactions and consequently a smaller average distance between the aromatic chromophores. As carbazole and its derivatives are known to be fluorescent,28–30 emission spectra were recorded for both thin films; it was seen that, while poly-D(C8-linear) was highly fluorescent, upon complexation with the acceptor molecules, the fluorescence was completely quenched (Fig. 4d), as expected.31,32 Together, these observations demonstrate that poly-D(C8-linear) retains the CT complexation with NMI(NO2)2-C3-NH3+ClO4− in thin films, presumably translating the folded structure via the two-point interaction.
To further probe the structure of the polymer in thin films, we carried out a few additional experiments. First, it is important to recognize that the two-point interaction of the acceptor with the polymer chain is crucial for reinforcing the formation of the folded structure, which in turn is formed only in the presence of the ammonium group in the acceptor, as was discussed earlier. Hence, releasing the free base of the acceptor by treatment of the film with aqueous NaHCO3 solution should weaken the interaction between the polymer and the acceptor; however, since the polymer chain has restricted mobility in the solid state, one may expect the pleated conformation to remain largely intact. Furthermore, since the acceptor-amine is not highly soluble in the aqueous medium, it will remain within the film.
To test these hypotheses, the film of the CT complex, coated on a quartz plate, was dipped in an aqueous solution of NaHCO3; effervescence due to the release of CO2 gas was noticed on the film surface during neutralization, and the colour of the film changed dramatically, as evident in Fig. 5a. The UV-visible spectra of the film, before and after bicarbonate treatment, revealed substantial changes; although the two peaks in the CT region remained intact, there was a significant hypsochromic shift of one peak from 455 nm to 436 nm and the second from 590 nm to 565 nm. In addition, there was a substantial increase in the intensity of both CT bands, with a slight decrease in the intensity of the shoulder in the UV region; this change apparently reflects a change in the relative position/orientation of the D and A units, once the interaction with the oxyethylene segment is destroyed, upon deprotonation. Hypsochromism in the UV region has been observed in biopolymers33 and aedamers,15 where the extended face-centered stacking of aromatic units induces this effect, and this has been used to estimate the extent of stacking. To reveal the changes in composition that have occurred, upon treatment with aqueous NaHCO3 solution, the 1H-NMR spectra of solutions prepared by dissolving the two films were compared (Fig. 5b); the most prominent change noticed was the disappearance of the peaks at 6.48 and 2.77 ppm, due to the –NH3+ and the –CH2 unit adjacent to the ammonium salt, respectively. This clearly reveals that treatment with NaHCO3 solution indeed transforms the ammonium salt into the free amine, while both components remain intact within the film. Thus, the change observed upon NaHCO3 treatment primarily reflects a change in the nature of interaction between the donor polymer and the acceptor, and the colour and spectral changes noticed are due to a change in the geometry of the CT complex. It may be noted that, since the polymer carries two triazole rings in each repeat unit, the acceptor-amine can also form H-bonds with the two triazole rings, providing an alternate, possibly weaker, two-point interaction.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4py01234h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |