Qianfeng
Qiu‡
a,
Qingkai
Qi‡
b,
Junichi
Usuba
a,
Karina
Lee
a,
Ivan
Aprahamian
*b and
Grace G. D.
Han
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, Brandeis University, 415 South Street, Waltham, MA 02453, USA. E-mail: gracehan@brandeis.edu
bDepartment of Chemistry, Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH 03755, USA. E-mail: ivan.aprahamian@dartmouth.edu
First published on 26th September 2023
We present here a group of Azo-BF2 photoswitches that store and release energy in response to visible light irradiation. Unmodified Azo-BF2 switches have a planar structure with a large π-conjugation system, which hinders E–Z isomerization when in a compacted state. To address this challenge, we modified the switches with one or two aliphatic groups, which altered the intermolecular interactions and arrangement of the photochromes in the solid state. The derivative with two substituents exhibited a non-planar configuration that provided particularly large conformational freedom, allowing for efficient isomerization in the solid phase. Our discovery highlights the potential of using double aliphatic functionalization as a promising approach to facilitate solid-state switching of large aromatic photoswitches. This finding opens up new possibilities for exploring various photoswitch candidates for molecular solar thermal energy storage applications.
In pursuit of visible and/or near IR activated photoswitches, a series of Azo-BF2 complexes were developed,27–30 which exhibit red-shifted πnb–π* and blue-shifted n–π* transitions caused by the coordination of the azo moiety with the Lewis acid (BF2).27 The control over the absorption wavelengths, photoisomerization quantum yields, PSS ratios, and thermal half-lives of the Z isomer was demonstrated through the modular design of Azo-BF2 compounds bearing various functional groups.28 Because of the limited examples of MOST compounds that can be activated by long visible or near IR light, the Azo-BF2 design presents a unique opportunity to harness the longer end of the solar spectrum, complementary to the conventional MOST compounds that absorb UV or short visible light.16 However, the evaluation of Azo-BF2 for MOST applications has not been explored, because the planarity of the large photochromic core induces significant π interactions that reduce the conformational freedom of the photoswitches in condensed phases. Such interactions were preliminarily investigated in concentrated solutions of Azo-BF2 that resulted in aggregation and impacted the thermal reversion half-life of the Z isomers.31
Herein, we report the design principle of Azo-BF2 derivatives that enables reversible photoswitching in the solid state, exclusively triggered by visible light. We present the first demonstration of MOST energy storage in Azo-BF2 compounds, facilitated by the introduction of aliphatic substituents that display out-of-plane distortion and reduce π interactions among the Azo-BF2 cores. Unlike previous reports that demonstrated solid–liquid phase transitions of azobenzenes or arylazopyrazoles that are functionalized with an aliphatic group,14,15,32–34 the Azo-BF2 derivatives exhibit unique solid-state transitions and solar energy storage.
We examined the thermal stability of all the Azo-BF2 derivatives using thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) (Fig. S18†), and the phase of their E and Z isomers by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) (Fig. 2 and S19†). The DSC plots of compounds 2 and 5 are shown in Fig. 2 as an example. As a result of the extended planar structure of the Azo-BF2 core, all the E isomers display crystalline phases with high melting points (Tm) as listed in Table 1. Compound 1-E, functionalized with a short ethoxy group, exhibits the highest Tm (>164 °C) among all the compounds, which is accompanied by thermal decomposition. Compounds 3-E and 4-E, featuring extended alkoxyl groups, exhibit notably lower melting points at 124 °C. This observation contradicts the typical trend observed in paraffins, where longer chains with enhanced London dispersion forces tend to result in higher melting points.35,36 This unusual phenomenon bears resemblance to previous reports involving some alkyl-functionalized azo(hereto)arene photoswitches,14,33,37–39 where the introduction of lengthy alkyl chains also resulted in a significant reduction in melting points. This observation in the case of 3-E and 4-E can be attributed to the weakening of π interactions among the aromatic photoswitch cores (vide infra). Compound 2-E with a branched 2-ethylhexyloxy group was designed to lower the Tm to 97 °C by further reducing the π interactions (Fig. 2a), which is a commonly applied strategy in forming a liquid-phase MOST compound.15,40 Nevertheless, strong π stacking of the photochroms results in the formation of a crystalline solid. Moreover, compounds 1–4 show high melting points (>66 °C) for their Z isomers as well, because of the planarity of the Z configurations. Most importantly, none of these derivatives underwent E → Z photo-isomerization in the solid state, as a consequence of the strong π interactions.
E | Z | Z → E | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
T m (°C) | ΔHm (kJ mol−1) | T m (°C) | ΔHm (kJ mol−1) | T iso (°C) | ΔHiso (kJ mol−1) | τ 1/2 (min) | |
a T m: melting point, ΔHm: melting enthalpy, Tiso: isomerization temperature, ΔHiso: isomerization enthalpy, τ1/2: thermal half-life at room temperature, —: unable to measure. | |||||||
1 | >164 | — | >107 | — | 117 | 7 | 69 |
2 | 97 | 21 | 82 | 12 | 104 | 4 | 50 |
3 | 124 | 54 | 66 | 1 | 90 | 20 | 11 |
4 | 124 | 70 | 100 | 17 | 101 | 22 | 36 |
5 | 100 | 19 | 70 | 3 | 87 | 3 | 7 |
Therefore, the substitution of both ends of the Azo-BF2 with alkyloxy groups was explored as a new strategy to further reduce the intermolecular interactions in both the E and Z isomers. As shown in Fig. 2b, compound 5-E displays a low Tm of 100 °C, similar to that of compound 2-E (96 °C), and a Tm of 5-Z at 70 °C that is comparable to the lowest Tm of 3-Z (66 °C). Surprisingly, despite the crystallinity of both the E and Z phases, compound 5 undergoes facile and reversible E/Z isomerization in the solid state (vide infra). All the thermal parameters of compounds 1–5 measured by DSC are summarized in Table 1. In general, the Z isomers exhibit 15–58 °C lower Tm values than the corresponding E isomers, and the crystal packing differences between the E and Z isomers are corroborated and elucidated by the powder X-ray diffraction measurements (Fig. S20†).
The measurement of DSC exotherms associated with the Z → E back-isomerization allows for the evaluation of the density of energy storage (ΔHiso) in each compound. For example, thermal activation of 2-Z leads to the melting of Z at 82 °C, followed by back-isomerization (Fig. 2a). Compound 5-Z, similar to 1-Z, 3-Z, and 4-Z, displays the first melting of Z, then Z → E back-isomerization, subsequent crystallization of E, and the melting of the formed E crystals (Fig. 2b and S19†). The accurate measurement of ΔHiso is challenging because of the convoluted processes. The values of the exotherm peaks are summarized in Table 1. Overall, the ΔHiso values of Azo-BF2 derivatives are lower than those of azo(hetero)arenes, indicating that the Z isomer is not as strained as in these systems. DFT calculations (Fig. S21 and Tables S3–S10†) corroborate the experimental results, predicting ΔHiso values of 19–25 kJ mol−1 (Table S11†), which is significantly lower than the value predicted (62 kJ mol−1) or experimentally measured (49 kJ mol−1) for pristine azobenzene.41 We also note that excessive heating above 125 °C can lead to the partial (∼20%) thermal decomposition of the Azo-BF2 derivatives, and subsequent formation of their hydrazone precursors, which can also impact the accuracy of the enthalpy measurements.
As aforementioned, compound 5 undergoes reversible solid-state E/Z isomerization under 625 and 470 nm irradiation, as opposed to the other compounds that do not isomerize in the solid state. Thin films of compounds 1–5 (0.1–0.75 μm thick) were prepared (Fig. S22–S26†), irradiated with a 625 nm LED for 10 min and a 470 nm LED for 2 min, and evaluated by UV-Vis absorption and NMR spectroscopy. Negligible colour change was observed for compounds 1–4 upon irradiation (Fig. 3a and S27†), and small changes in optical spectra (Fig. 3a and S28†) and Z percentage (Fig. S29–S32†) of the films were detected. Notably, compound 4 with the longest alkyloxy substituent rapidly (within a minute) aggregates in the cast film, forming large domains that scatter light and induce substantial changes to the absorption profiles. The aggregated state is not altered by the irradiation, and the absorption profile of compound 4 remains unchanged (Fig. S28†).
Compound 5 also shows aggregation-induced reduction of absorbance in films compared to the initially cast state (Fig. S28†), but the reversible photoswitching of E/Z in films (average thickness of 0.37 ± 0.17 μm, Fig. S26†) was monitored upon 625 and 470 nm irradiation (Fig. 3b). The optical microscopy images clearly demonstrate the colour changes between blue (PSS470 48% E) and red (PSS625 70% Z) (Fig. S33†). Compared to the solution state, the PSS ratios obtained in the condensed phase are lower, which is attributed to the incomplete penetration of 470 nm (0.22 μm through E) and 625 nm (0.47 μm through Z) lights (Fig. S34†) and uneven film thickness. The effect of light penetration was confirmed by the irradiation experiment on thinner films (average thickness of 0.18 ± 0.09 μm), which displayed an improved PSS625 of 81% Z and similar PSS470 of 47% E (Fig. S35†). We note that the reduced conformational freedom of the photoswitches in the solid state also contributes to the lower PSS ratios. The switching is repeatable over 10 cycles (Fig. 3c), displaying small variations in absorbance after each cycle, which is intrinsic to solid-state UV-Vis measurement of films with imperfect uniformity. Additionally, 17% of photo-degradation was detected by NMR for the thin films after 10 cycles of irradiation (Fig. S36†), which can also induce small absorbance changes. The thermal half-life of 5-Z at 20 °C was characterized to be over 4 days (Fig. S37 and Table S12†), significantly extended from that measured in solution (7 min), which indicates the sterically hindered thermal back-isomerization of the compound in films.31,42
To elucidate the mechanism behind the unique photo-switchability of compound 5 in films, we performed crystal structure analysis of compounds 1 and 3–5 in the E isomeric state (Table S13 and Fig. S38–S53†). 2-E did not form high-quality crystals suitable for X-ray diffraction. Fig. 4a shows the twisted head-to-head packing of 1-E, formed by π stacking of Azo-BF2 cores. Within the structures of 3-E and 4-E, the long alkyloxy chains assume an important role in mediating parallel molecular stacking driven by London dispersion forces. Also, the interaction between the electron-rich phenolic moiety and electron-poor Azo-BF2 induces an offset molecular arrangement (Fig. 4b and c). Interestingly, the crystal structure of 5-E does not exhibit any noticeable inter-chain interactions or aligned alkyloxy chains, presumably because of the shorter substituents that do not yield significant London dispersion forces in the offset arrangement. Instead, 5-E displays pronounced π stacking between the neighbouring Azo-BF2 cores (Fig. 4d), similar to 1-E. The alkyloxy groups show staggered arrangement (top view, yellow highlighted) and out-of-plane distortion in the crystal lattice (side view, yellow highlighted), which clearly differentiates 5-E from the other compounds. This unique packing of compound 5 is hypothesized to reduce the intermolecular interactions in the solid state, which is manifested as low Tm and melting enthalpies of both the E and Z isomers (Table 1). In addition, the van der Waals space fill models that are obtained based on the crystal structures illustrate the largest fraction of void space (29.5%) in compound 5 compared to the others (23.8–27.5%) (Fig. S41, S45, S49, and S53†). This finding reveals an important strategy for enabling solid-state isomerization of large planar photochromic compounds such as Azo-BF2 through the introduction of two aliphatic chains into the core structure, which creates a non-linear geometry of the compound that is less prone to compact packing in the solid state. The balance between the π interactions among the aromatic cores and London dispersion43–47 among the aliphatic chains is critical to decrease the overall intermolecular interactions and increase the conformational freedom needed for isomerization in the solid state.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Methods, synthesis, UV-Vis spectra, quantum yield, TGA, DSC, kinetic analysis, film studies, DFT results, X-ray diffraction. CCDC 2257907–2257910. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3sc03465h |
‡ Equal contributions. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |