Hyo Won
Lee
ab,
Kwangho
Yoo
b,
Lars
Borchardt
*b and
Jeung Gon
Kim
*ac
aDepartment of Chemistry and Research Institute of Physics and Chemistry Jeonbuk National University, Jeonju, 54896, Republic of Korea. E-mail: jeunggonkim@jbnu.ac.kr
bInorganic Chemistry I, Ruhr-Universität Bochum, Universitätsstraße 150, 44801 Bochum, Germany. E-mail: lars.borchardt@rub.de
cDepartment of JBNU-KIST Industry-Academia Convergence Research, Jeonbuk National University, Jeonju 54896, Republic of Korea
First published on 4th January 2024
In this study, we present a green and economical approach to chemical recycling of commercial polycarbonates and poly-esters, specifically poly(bisphenol A carbonate), poly(ethylene terephthalate), and poly(lactic acid). Our method involves mechanochemical ball-milling of a heterogeneous mixture of plastic and methanol, resulting in quantitative depolymerization to yield monomers or useful chemical units that already have high demands. We found that the energy-intensive step is forming physical contact between the reactants, rather than the chemical methanolysis itself. Mechanochemical ball-milling facilitates sufficient physical contact and energy transfer between plastics and methanol, eliminating the need for solvents and catalysts. Our study demonstrates a practical and sustainable process with minimal chemical input and simple output for the chemical recycling of these plastics.
This report centers on the chemical recycling of carbonate and ester polymers, including poly(bisphenol-A carbonate) (BPA-PC), poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET), and poly(lactic acid) (PLA), which are significant constituents of common plastics.5–7 BPA-PC waste is concerning because of its bisphenol A content, which is a xenoestrogen.8,9 PET is the plastic targeted for efficient mechanical recycling.10,11 However, the market for post-PET products is insufficient to handle current PET waste levels. PLA is a representative bio-based green plastic that is quickly replacing other petro-based polymers. Nonetheless, its degradation in nature is slow, leading to persistent plastic issues such as microplastics.7,12 All of these materials require practical and fully circular chemical recycling processes to become sustainable plastics.
Polycarbonates, such as BPA-PC, and polyesters, such as PET and PLA, contain chemically active ester and carbonate groups, making their chemical recycling an area of interest.13–15 Previous reports on chemical recycling using alcohols and amines have claimed high efficiency and mild conditions, but they require homogeneous conditions and activating reagents, resulting in complex processes and high costs. In addition, PET presents a particular challenge due to its poor solubility in common solvents.16,17 Recently, Wang and colleagues reported the successful catalyst- and solvent-free degradation of BPA-PC, PET, and PLA using amino alcohols.18 The direct amidation between reagent and polymer was feasible under proper conditions and reagents. However, PET and PLA depolymerization resulted in diol products that do not have market need at this moment. Therefore, there is a need to develop a catalyst- and solvent-free chemical recycling process that produces monomers or chemical products with existing bulk usage, which would be highly desirable for sustainable plastic recycling.
The present study proposes the use of mechanochemistry as a means of enhancing the sustainability and cost-effectiveness of the chemical recycling of BPA-PC, PET, and PLA.19–21 Mechanochemistry employs physical processes like collision, shearing, and grinding to initiate chemical reactions, leading to efficient mixing and energy transfer, solvent elimination, and maximum green chemistry. This technique has been shown to be effective in degrading even highly insoluble plastics, such as BPA-PC, PET, and PLA, using methanol, into their constituent raw materials through high-speed ball-milling transesterifications (Fig. 1), without the need for solvents or catalysts.22–24 The mechanical energy and contact provided by mechanochemistry promote the depolymerization of the ester- and carbonate-based polymers, even with highly immiscible methanol, resulting in a simple and efficient process with minimal chemical input and low energy consumption. The kinetic study of model system proved that high thermal energy input is necessary to overcome physical immiscibility and catalyst is not necessary for transesterification. The mechanochemical methanolysis of BPA-PC, PET, and PLA with methanol quantitatively produced BPA, dimethyl carbonate (DMC), dimethyl terephthalate (DMT), and methyl lactate. These products have high demand in the current market and can be reused in the production of BPA-PC and PET or other applications.
Fig. 1 Concept of mechanochemical recycling methanolysis of carbonate & ester plastics: no catalyst, no solvent, and high efficiency. |
Fig. 2 Catalyst-free DPC methanolysis to DMC. (A) DPC and methanol mixture at 100 °C. (B) Planetary ball milling (SUS 12 mL, 5 mm balls 50 ea, 600 rpm). |
To the vial, we added DPC (1.0 mmol) and MeOH (70 mmol). DPC was slightly soluble in MeOH at ambient conditions, and no chemical reaction occurred. However, upon heating the mixture to 100 °C in a closed vessel, it became homogeneous and promoted non-catalytic methanolysis to MPC, DMC, and phenol (Fig. 2A). Within an hour, 57% of DPC had turned into 51% MPC and 6% DMC. The consumption of DPC continued, but the second methanolysis from MPC to DMC was slow. After a near quantitative DPC conversion, a significant amount of MPC (55%) remained.
The same combination was tested under mechanochemical conditions, whereby a heterogeneous mixture of DPC and MeOH was subjected to ball-milling in a 12 mL stainless steel (SS) jar containing 50 × 5 mm SS balls, using planetary ball milling (PM100, Restch) at 600 rpm (Fig. 2B). The results indicated that DPC conversion to MPC and DMC occurred more rapidly than in solution reactions at 100 °C. Within 1 hour, more than half of DPC (75%) had transformed to MPC (60%) and DMC (15%), while milling for 3 hours completely consumed DPC, producing MPC (27%) and DMC (73%). Full conversion to DMC was achieved after 5 hours. The reaction profile over time showed a temporary accumulation of MPC before the second step, similar to that observed in solution reactions. These findings suggest that mechanochemical ball milling methanolysis followed the same reaction profile. The mechanochemical condition exhibited superior performance to the conventional one. However, there is a possibility that the SS media used in the milling process may have catalyzed the methanolysis. There have been reports of milling media participating in the reaction.26–28 To investigate this, we conducted a solution reaction at 100 °C with a fine powder of SS (SUS304, 100 mesh) to elucidate the media effect. However, there was no significant rate acceleration by metal powder, ruling out the possibility of direct catalysis by the milling media (see ESI, Table S2 and Fig. S2†).
Entry | Type | MeOH (mmol) | Conv. (%) | BPA (%) | BPAMC (%) | BPADC (%) | Comments |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Reaction time – 6 hours. b Conversions and yields were determined by 1H NMR spectroscopy after methanol removal. | |||||||
Solution reaction, 100 °C | |||||||
1 | Powder | 70 | 0 | — | — | ||
Planetary ball-milling, SUS 25 mL, 5 mm × 50 ea, 600 rpm | |||||||
2 | Powder | 70 | 97 | 78 | 18 | 1 | 12 ml jar |
3 | 70 | 99 | 99 | — | — | ||
4 | 30 | 99 | 99 | — | — | ||
5 | 10 | 55 | 14 | 10 | 31 | ||
6 | Pellet | 30 | 0 | — | — | — | |
7 | 30 | 99 | 99 | — | — | DMC 2 mmol |
Subsequently, mechanochemical conditions were employed for the same mixture. Planetary ball milling of the heterogeneous mixture of BPA-PC (powder, 1 mmol) and MeOH (70 mmol) with 50 SS balls (5 mm diameter) in a 12 mL SS jar resulted in near-quantitative depolymerization after 6 hours (entry 2). However, the resulting mixture consisted of monomeric species, including BPA (78%), BPA-dimethylcarbonates (BPADC, 1%), and BPA-monomethylcarbonate (BPAMC, 18%). Switching to a 25 mL jar led to full conversion to BPA and DMC (entry 3), likely due to better ball movement and mixing facilitated by the increased volume. Reducing the amount of MeOH to 30 equiv. retained the depolymerization efficiency with quantitative production of BPA and DMC (entry 4). However, further reduction below 30 equiv. compromised the reactivity (entry 5).
The time-resolved reaction tracking allowed us to understand how the depolymerization process progressed (Fig. 3). After an hour, the mixture remained heterogeneous. The 1H NMR spectra contained a mixture of polymeric BPA-PC (yellow), monomeric BPAMC (blue), and BPA (green). Although a significant amount of monomeric species was produced, the BPA-PC portion maintained a high molecular weight (9.7 kg mol−1). BPA-PC on the surface reacted with methanol during collisions and generated low molecular weight fragment`s, while the core BPA-PC remained unreacted. After 3 hours, a homogeneous mixture was formed, as shown by both the 1H NMR and SEC results, with no traces of polymeric BPA-PC. The reaction continued homogeneously, and after 5 hours of ball milling, only BPA was detected.
1H NMR measurements were obtained in CDCl3 after filtration and methanol removal to enhance the visibility of the BPA peaks. However, since DMC has a boiling point of 90 °C, it evaporated during the process. To confirm the production of DMC, a separate measurement using non-deuterated proton NMR spectroscopy was performed on a crude aliquot, and the presence of DMC was confirmed (Fig. S4†).31
To confirm the catalytic effect of the metallic components in the SS jar and balls, the reaction was conducted using a zirconia jar and balls. A mixture of BPA-PC (powder, 1 mmol) and MeOH (30 mmol) in a 50 mL zirconia jar with 26 g of 5 mm balls resulted in partial depolymerization. The resulting mixture contained 37% BPA, 26% BPAMC, and 5% BPADC. This supports the notion that PC methanolysis can occur without metal catalysis, as demonstrated in Fig. S5.† The reduced reactivity could be attributed to the weaker mechanical energy resulting from the lower density of zirconia. However, we cannot completely rule out the potential catalytic effect of the metallic components in the SS jar and balls.
We also evaluated the effect of mechanical fragmentation. Mechanical force on polymer chains could result in chain fragmentation, which might help the BPA-PC depolymerization process.32,33 But, the same milling process without MeOH did not show a notable effect on PC. A molecular weight change of less than 2% from 16.4 kg mol−1 to 16.1 kg mol−1 proved that representative engineering plastic BPA-PC with excellent impact resistance endured a milling force (Fig. S6†). The depolymerization proceeded solely by methanolysis.
In the following study, the shape of BPA-PC was investigated. A chunk shape was more prevalent than powder in waste plastics. Therefore, pellet PC was depolymerized to simulate waste-PC under identical conditions. After six hours, the pellet shape PC retained its shape and could not be broken down to powder through milling due to its mechanical robustness. Furthermore, depolymerization was not detected through 1H NMR (entry 6). To address this, a liquid-assisted grinding system was devised, where a small amount of a good solvent, such as DMC, was used to swell the pellet and penetrate its polymer domain. The final mixture contained the same three components, making the postseparation process less complicated. The BPA-PC pellets (1 mmol) and DMC (2 mmol) were milled for 30 minutes, and the resulting powder had a larger surface area. Further milling with MeOH (30 mmol) allowed for complete depolymerization to BPA and DMC (entry 7).
In a previous study by Kim et al., BPA-PC methanolysis was analyzed step-by-step at high temperatures.34 They used pellet BPA-PC and methanol in a tightly closed tube for depolymerization. At high temperatures above 160 °C, depolymerization to BPA and DMC occurred. To evaluate the effect of temperature on high-speed ball-milling, we monitored the temperature change of the reactor and the reaction mixture. At the end of milling, the reaction jar was opened, and an infrared thermometer recorded the temperature of the mixture. The reaction of Table 1, entry 4 was repeated, and the reactor reached 54 °C, where the thermal reaction would not proceed (Fig. S7†). We speculated that high thermal energy input to near 200 °C was necessary to locate MeOH inside the BPA-PC domain under heterogeneous conditions, rather than chemical transesterification. Mechanochemical conditions successfully provided both sufficient contact and activation energy.
The conditions developed at a 1 mmol (255 mg) scale were scaled up to grams (Fig. 4). BPA-PC (5.0 g, 20 mmol) was treated with DMC (3.4 mL, 40 mmol) in a 125 mL SS jar containing 500 ∅ 5 mm balls. Crushed BPA-PC was mixed with MeOH (24 mL, 600 mmol). Milling at 600 rpm for 6 hours resulted in quantitative depolymerization to BPA and DMC. Pure BPA (3.9 g) was isolated after silica filtration.
The chemical recycling of waste polycarbonates continued using compact discs (CD, Mn = 16.4 kg mol−1, Đ = 2.15) and safety glasses (Mn = 21.1 kg mol−1, Đ = 2.55), which contained additives such as UV stabilizers and mold release agents that could interfere with the depolymerization process. The mechanochemical process proceeded regardless of the molecular weight and additives. The full conversions to BPA and DMC showed promise for the mechanochemical process. BPA were isolated of 4.1 g (90%) from CD and 3.6 g (80%) from safety glasses, respectively.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3gc03643j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |