Yongkang
Yao
,
Yutao
Zhang
,
Chenxu
Yan
,
Wei-Hong
Zhu
and
Zhiqian
Guo
*
Key Laboratory for Advanced Materials, Institute of Fine Chemicals, Feringa Nobel Prize Scientist Joint Research Center, Frontiers Science Center for Materiobiology and Dynamic Chemistry, School of Chemistry and Molecular Engineering, East China University of Science and Technology, Shanghai 200237, China. E-mail: guozq@ecust.edu.cn
First published on 16th July 2021
β-Galactosidase (β-gal), a typical hydrolytic enzyme, is a vital biomarker for cell senescence and primary ovarian cancers. Developing precise and rapid methods to monitor β-gal activity is crucial for early cancer diagnoses and biological research. Over the past decade, activatable optical probes have become a powerful tool for real-time tracking and in vivo visualization with high sensitivity and specificity. In this review, we summarize the latest advances in the design of β-gal-activatable probes via spectral characteristics and responsiveness regulation for biological applications, and particularly focus on the molecular design strategy from turn-on mode to ratiometric mode, from aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ) probes to aggregation-induced emission (AIE)-active probes, from near-infrared-I (NIR-I) imaging to NIR-II imaging, and from one-mode to dual-mode of chemo-fluoro-luminescence sensing β-gal activity.
Fluorescence techniques provide a powerful way to visualize dynamic biological processes in living cells and organisms owing to their high detection sensitivity, excellent resolution and non-invasive real-time detection abilities.18,19 In particular, fluorescence imaging in the near-infrared window (NIR-I, 650–900 nm; NIR-II, 1000–1700 nm) has gained more attention and been designed for biological analytes/microenvironmental factors.20–24 Comparison with the emission falling into the visible region, these NIR fluorophores could effectively decrease background interference and achieve deeper penetration with superior imaging qualities.25–27 In general, fluorescent probes are divided into two main categories of “always-on” probes and activatable probes. Indeed, activatable probes could switch the fluorescence from the “off” to the “on” state (turn-on probes) or adjust the dual-emission ratio (ratiometric probes) upon activation by a specific target, thus achieving a lower limit of detection and higher signal-to-noise ratio.28 Considering that current β-gal detection is generally based on β-gal-catalyzed enzyme reaction, elaborately activatable NIR fluorescent probes are expected to realize sensitive and real-time detection, thereby assessing the biological activity of β-gal with high specificity.
The primary themes for activatable probe design and application are the use of spectral characteristics of fluorophores and the strategy employed to regulate its responsiveness. The key properties of fluorophore scaffolds include finely tuning spectroscopic properties and brightness, regulating the wavelength to the NIR region, and uniting multiple modalities for β-gal imaging. Here, we focus on the latest progress in the design of enzyme-activatable fluorescent probes, especially for monitoring β-gal activity in live cells and in vivo application. We highlight the rational design strategy for constructing versatile platforms of activatable β-gal probes (Fig. 1), including from turn-on mode to ratiometric mode with accurate quantification, from aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ) to aggregation-induced emission (AIE)-active probes with long-term tracking properties, from the NIR-I to the NIR-II wavelength region with deeper penetration, and dual-modality of fluorescence and enriched chemiluminescence (CL) imaging with high sensitivity. In addition, we also constrain our survey to the β-gal-catalyzed reaction by removing the trigger moiety and liberating the activated moiety for magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and photoacoustic imaging β-gal.
In order to enhance the in vivo performance, much effort has been made to develop suitable NIR fluorophores as the signal moiety.34–39 As is well known, commercially available ICG dye – an FDA approved NIR contrast agent with good biocompatibility and biodegradability – is widely employed as a fluorescent reporter. Shabat and co-workers developed a turn-on NIR probe (QCy7-βgal) for the imaging of β-gal (Fig. 2), which contains a NIR cyanine fluorophore (QCy7) and an enzyme-activatable group (β-D-galactopyranoside).34 The only probe QCy7-βgal displayed almost no fluorescence in the NIR region. Upon incubation with β-gal, QCy7-βgal underwent a cleavage reaction with the broken β-glycosidic bond and subsequently released the active Cy7 fluorophore through self-immolation. Turn-on NIR emission at 720 nm was observed owing to the distinctive change in their π-conjugated system, along with an obvious color change from original yellow to dark (Fig. 2b and c). Based on the advantages of high selectivity and NIR fluorescence, the probe was successfully applied in living mice. As shown in Fig. 2d, the in vivo experiments indicated that QCy7-βgal exhibited a significant NIR fluorescence enhancement toward β-gal, showing good biocompatibility and a high signal-to-background ratio.
Fig. 2 (a) Fluorescence response of the NIR fluorescent probe QCy7-βgal to β-gal. Fluorescence response (b), absorbance response (c), and in vivo imaging (d) of QCy7-βgal. |
Considering that de-acidification is a unique characteristic of lysosomes in senescent cells, it is important to distinguish senescence-associated β-galactosidase (SA-β-gal) from other endogenous β-gal. Very recently, Guo and co-workers presented two-dimensional fluorescent probes (KSA01 and KSA02) to specifically track cellular senescence (Fig. 3a).40 These probes were designed by endowing merocyanine-based fluorescent dyes with carboxyl groups, so that they could monitor senescence in a second dimension: lysosomal pH. Upon the addition of A. oryzae β-gal (pH 4.0), the galactose moiety of KSA02 was removed to liberate the phenolic hydroxyl moiety, showing green fluorescence at a short wavelength (534 nm) (Fig. 3b). Differently, upon adding E. coli β-gal (pH 7.4), KSA02 liberated the phenolic oxygen anion and emitted at a long wavelength (562 nm) (Fig. 3c). Furthermore, based on the fact that senescent cells exhibit higher lysosomal pH than ovarian cancer cells, the probes were successfully evaluated in senescent HL-7702 cells and ovarian cancer-associated SKOV-3 cells. As depicted in Fig. 3d, KSA02 mainly produced a red fluorescence in HL-7702 cells but a green fluorescence in SKOV-3 cells, indicating sensitive differentiation of SA-β-gal from cancer-associated β-gal.
Recently, Guo et al. constructed two ratiometric NIR probes (DCM-βgal and BODIPY-βgal) for β-gal (Fig. 4a), which depends on optimizing the incorporated electron-withdrawing unit to regulate the ICT process.47,48 Specifically, dicyanomethylene-4H-pyran (DCM) and the 4,4-difluoro-4-bora-3a,4a-diaza-s-indacene (BODIPY) fluorophore are utilized as NIR signal reporters, and the D-galactose unit is functionalized as a β-gal triggered moiety. When reacting with β-gal, the D-galactose unit of DCM-βgal and BODIPY-βgal could be specifically hydrolyzed to form phenol, a strong electron-donating group (EDG), thus providing a remarkable ICT-based switch for ratiometric NIR analysis. For DCM-βgal, its initial absorption peak at 440 nm declined, and the new peak extended to 535 nm, accompanied by an obvious yellow-to-rose color change (Fig. 4b). The fluorescence signals remarkably decreased at 500 nm and concurrently increased at 685 nm, thereby obtaining a good linear relationship between the intensity ratio (I685 nm/I500 nm) and β-gal concentration (R2 = 0.98845) (Fig. 4c). In light of its ratiometric NIR mode, endogenous β-gal in OVCAR-3 cells was quantitatively detected and imaged by the probe DCM-βgal (Fig. 4d and e). More importantly, DCM-βgal allows for high resolution three-dimensional mapping of β-gal activity in living mice (Fig. 4f and g). Considering that DCM has been a commercial dye since 1989,49 DCM-βgal could be easily synthesized and employed as a potential optical tool for ratiometric measurement of β-gal under physiological conditions. And this work was also highlighted by Nature Methods due to its excellent abilities for real-time tracking β-gal in vivo.50
As a pioneering study, Tang and co-workers discovered a fascinating photophysical phenomenon, aggregation-induced emission (AIE).56–58 Different from typical ACQ fluorophores (e.g. fluorescein59 and rhodamine60), AIE luminogens (AIEgens) generally displayed weak or no fluorescence in their molecular state but strong fluorescence in their aggregated state. Notably, the more AIEgens aggregate, the brighter their emission becomes, making them become a kind of promising material for tracking biomolecules with high fidelity in living systems. Recently, some typical AIE fluorescent probes based on the tetraphenylethene (TPE) core have been reported for the detection of β-gal.61,62 For example, Ding and co-workers developed a β-gal-responsive AIE probe that could selectively identify and remove senescent cancer cells through enzyme-activatable self-assembly and efficient reactive oxygen species (ROS).62
However, the initial state of AIE-active probes before the probes interacting with targets of interest is generally “always-on”, thereby leading to a “false-positive” signal. In this regard, it is necessary to develop an AIE-active strategy to form in situ AIE nanoaggregates, enhancing retention for long-term imaging and performing turn-on fluorescence (Fig. 5a). Specifically, the AIE probes with a hydrophilic moiety display good solubility in the physiological environment; when reacting with enzymes, a highly efficient enzyme-catalyzed hydrolysis reaction could liberate hydrophobic AIEgens, followed by in situ aggregation to form nanoparticles with intensive emission at the activation site, and the nanoaggregates promote diffusion-resistant on-site sensing in living cells.
Recently, Guo et al. elaborately designed a new AIE building block of quinoline-malononitrile (QM), which just incorporates the N-ethyl group to replace the oxygen atom of the DCM core. Subsequently, an AIE-active probe (QM-βgal) was developed for tracking β-gal (Fig. 5b and 6a).63 Because of the hydrophilic β-gal-activatable unit bestowing favorable water-solubility, QM-βgal almost showed very weak emission in aqueous solution; while activated by β-gal, the hydrophobic QM-OH was in situ generated and converted into nanoaggregates, accompanied by remarkable fluorescent enhancement at 560 nm (Fig. 6b). Meanwhile, the plot of fluorescence intensity I560 nm against the concentration of β-gal shows a good relationship (R2 = 0.992) (inset of Fig. 6b). To verify that this AIE-active strategy could achieve on-site sensing and long-term imaging, the typical ACQ probe DCM-gal was chosen as a control for the in vivo imaging experiment. As shown in Fig. 6c and d, the incubation time in SKOV-3 ovarian cancer cells prolonged over 12 h, but the intracellular fluorescent signals from QM-βgal were still observed and accumulated with low background interference in living cells.
Fig. 6 (a) Chemical structure of QM-βgal. Fluorescence response (b), long-term cell images (c) and averaged fluorescence intensity (d) of QM-βgal. |
Furthermore, to extend the emission wavelength into the NIR region, a β-gal-active probe QM-HBT-βgal was elaborately synthesized by introducing the 2-(2-hydroxyphenyl) benzothiazole group as an external π-conjugated structure (Fig. 5b).64 The results of the Cell experiment revealed that QM-HBT-βgal could realize long-term NIR fluorescence imaging in SKOV-3 cells. Considering the high performance of QM-HBT-βgal and QM-βgal, it was believed that the AIE-active strategy provides a new pathway to design enzyme-activatable probes for on-site sensing and long-term tracking in living samples.
Towards enzyme-activated NIR-II probes, Zhao et al. established a universal platform with tunable emission from the NIR-I to the NIR-II region.70 The emission of BODIPY-based fluorophores (EW-BOD-SH) was effectively red-shifted to a longer wavelength via incorporating an electron-withdrawing group into the 3-position of the BODIPY core, which exhibited a long tail falling into the NIR-II region (1000–1300 nm) (Fig. 7a). Furthermore, this platform was engineered by attaching enzymic substrates into EW-BOD-SH through a self-immolative benzyl thioether linking spacer (Fig. 7b). When the designed probes were catalyzed and triggered by the specific enzyme, they would subsequently undergo a 1,6-elimination reaction to liberate the sulfur atom of thiol-modified BODIPY with enhanced electron-donating ability, thereby ultimately generating desired NIR emission with large Stokes shifts. In this way, diverse activatable probes could be designed for the NIR-I/NIR-II fluorescence sensing of enzymes (such as NTR, NQO1 and ALP).
More importantly, using a similar design strategy, Gu and co-workers successfully developed two turn-on NIR-I and NIR-II probes (BOD-K-βgal and BOD-M-βgal) to recognize β-gal in ovarian cancers (Fig. 7b), which were also incorporated with a D-galactose residue as a β-gal activatable trigger.71 Upon titration with β-gal, BOD-K-βgal and BOD-M-βgal displayed significant turn-on NIR-I or NIR-II responses, respectively. Furthermore, the in vivo ovarian tumor imaging was carried out in the SKOV3 subcutaneous xenograft nude mice. As shown in Fig. 7d, the obvious strong NIR-II signals of BOD-M-βgal could be observed even at a 2 mm depth, but the NIR-I signals of BOD-K-βgal were almost undetected even at 1 mm. These results further demonstrated that NIR-II imaging could penetrate deeper tissue and provide higher resolution than NIR-I imaging because of almost zero-autofluorescence and markedly suppressed photon scattering.
Fig. 8 (a) Fluorescence mechanism of photochromic probe NpM@HSA. Fluorescence response (b) and super-resolution imaging (c) of β-gal in senescent cells. |
Given the advantage of the tissue-penetration depth of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), Meade et al. developed a series of self-immolative β-gal-responsive contrast agents, and synthesized intermolecular and intramolecular architectures to optimize the coordination of water to Gd3+ (Fig. 10a and b).13 Among them, 6-C pendant carboxylate (10c) was demonstrated as an effective MR contrast agent in the mouse model, which exhibits a visible MR signal at the 4 h time point (Fig. 10c). Consequently, considering the diversity of imaging modalities, it would be a powerful strategy to design β-gal-activatable probes with synergetic fluorescence and other imaging modalities.
Fig. 10 (a) Self-immolative MRI contrast agents with intermolecular or intramolecular architecture for β-gal detection. (b) MR information of (10b–d) ±β-gal at 7 T. (c) MR images of living mice. |
Recently, some researchers focus on CL imaging which produces photons through specific chemical reactions rather than light excitation. Because CL imaging doesn't require an exogenous excitation light, the limitations from tissue autofluorescence and light scattering could be effectively avoided, thus obtaining a much higher signal-to-noise ratio.74–76 However, current conventional CL probes, such as oxalate esters and luminol, were activated by the oxidation reaction and limited to the detection of oxidative species, making them difficult to real-time sense chemical or biological species. Schaap's adamantylidene-1,2-dioxetane with an analyte-responsive phenol trigger moiety emerged as a favored platform for CL imaging (Fig. 11a).77–79 Upon the removal of the trigger moiety, the resulting phenolate intermediate is unstable and undergoes an electron transfer event and decomposition, accompanied by the blue glow-type emission.
Based on Schaap's dioxetane, many dioxetane probes were developed for a variety of analytes, including β-gal discussed here. For example, Mason and co-workers used the commercially chemiluminescent probe (Galacton) together with the addition of a surfactant-dye adduct for in vivo detection of β-gal. Moreover, in order to extend light emission to the NIR region, Shabat and co-workers designed the probe DCM-gal-C through integrating the DCM unit as an extended π-electron system at the para position of Schaap's 1,2-dioxetanes.
Although CL imaging could provide ultra-sensitive detection signals, it's still difficult to achieve longitudinal study in a dynamic biological environment due to its single-time output pattern. Considering that fluorescence imaging could obtain real-time feedback through light repeated excitation, the combination of CL imaging and fluorescence imaging into one unimolecular system could simultaneously meet the requirement of ultra-sensitive and real-time detection. Besides, these dioxetane-based probes produced only a sustained but weak CL signal because of their uncontrollable photon release, which immensely limits their practical application.
Towards this end, Guo et al. presented a dual-lock strategy to construct dual-mode probes with sequential trigger activation, exhibiting AIE-active fluorescence and enriched CL signals (Fig. 11b).80 Specifically, the recognition moiety as the first lock was triggered by the analytes, leading to the generation and accumulation of stable pre-chemiluminophores. Owning to the double bond replacing the high-energy dioxetane group and the accumulation of AIEgens QM, pre-chemiluminophores could display better stability than reported dioxetane probes, and then generated stronger emission under light excitation. Subsequently, the electron-rich double bond as the second lock was triggered by irradiation with white LED light, thereby forming 1,2-dioxetane accompanied by bright and enriched CL signals. Based on this dual-mode imaging of dual-lock sequential control, they realized accurate in vivo sensing of β-gal. It was believed that this dual-lock strategy could expand the analytical toolboxes in biological research and clinical trials.
Although remarkable progress has been made for tracking β-gal, there are still many opportunities and challenges: (i) designing high-performance small-molecular NIR-II platforms with better fluorescence quantum yields and longer wavelength. The current reported NIR-II organic fluorophores always need a complicated synthetic procedure but just possess low quantum yield and little coverage in the NIR-II window, which still limits their application in vivo. It is imperative to develop a new strategy of simple structural design and easy modification of NIR-II dyes with brightness and longer emission. (ii) Integrating multiple imaging modalities (e.g. MRI, PET, CT, photoacoustic and fluorescence imaging) into a unimolecular system for the synergetic detection of β-gal. (iii) Distinguishing human endogenous β-gal from β-gal of other species. For the study of human β-gal, bacterial β-gal, especially E. coli β-gal, is habitually used as the substitute enzyme, but there is still structural difference between them. It is worth developing high-performance probes for the detection of human β-gal activity. We anticipate that these rational strategies for the probes would bring more breakthroughs in β-gal detection and related biological applications in the future.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |