Fangfang Penga,
Bin Zhanga,
Runyao Zhaoab,
Shiqiang Liua,
Yuxuan Wuab,
Shaojun Xuc,
Luke L. Keenand,
Huizhen Liuab,
Qingli Qianab,
Tianbin Wua,
Haijun Yanga,
Zhimin Liuab,
Jikun Li*abe,
Bingfeng Chen*a,
Xinchen Kang*ab and
Buxing Han*abf
aBeijing National Laboratory for Molecular Sciences, CAS Laboratory of Colloid and Interface and Thermodynamics, CAS Research/Education Center for Excellence in Molecular Sciences, Center for Carbon Neutral Chemistry, Institute of Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China. E-mail: hanbx@iccas.ac.cn; kangxinchen@iccas.ac.cn; chenbf@iccas.ac.cn; jikunli@iccas.ac.cn
bSchool of Chemical Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 101408, P. R. China
cDepartment of Chemical Engineering, School of Engineering, The University of Manchester, Oxford Road, Manchester, M13 9PL, UK
dDiamond Light Source, Harwell Science Campus, Oxfordshire, OX11 0DE, UK
eBeijing National Laboratory for Molecular Sciences, Key Laboratory of Photochemistry, Institute of Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100190, China
fShanghai Key Laboratory of Green Chemistry and Chemical Processes, State Key Laboratory of Petroleum Molecular & Process Engineering, School of Chemistry and Molecular Engineering, East China Normal University, Shanghai, 200062, China
First published on 28th October 2024
Selective hydrogenolysis of biomass-derived furanic compounds is a promising approach for synthesizing aliphatic polyols by opening the furan ring. However, there remains a significant need for highly efficient catalysts that selectively target the Csp2–O bond in the furan ring, as well as for a deeper understanding of the fundamental atomistic mechanisms behind these reactions. In this study, we present the use of Pt–Fe bimetallic catalysts supported on layered double hydroxides [PtFex/LDH] for the hydrogenolysis of furanic compounds into aliphatic alcohols, achieving over 90% selectivity toward diols and triols. Our findings reveal that the synergy between Pt nanoparticles, atomically dispersed Pt sites and the support facilitates the formation of hydride-proton pair at the Ptδ+⋯O2− Lewis acid–base unit of PtFex/LDH through hydrogen spillover. The hydride specifically targets the Csp2–O bond in the furan ring, initiating an SN2 reaction and ring cleavage. Moreover, the presence of Fe improves the yield of desired alcohols by inhibiting the adsorption of vinyl groups, thereby suppressing the hydrogenation of the furan ring.
In addition to the active sites of catalysts, the selectivity for ring-opening products is also associated with the active hydrogen species. In catalytic hydrogenation reactions, the dissociation of H2 determines both activity and selectivity. It is widely accepted that on extended metal surfaces (metal–metal sites), H2 dissociation tends to favor the homolytic pathway. In contrast, when the local coordination structures of the metal centers involve Lewis acid–base units, H2 molecules are more inclined to undergo heterolytic dissociation at these sites, forming hydride–proton pairs.15–17 The resulting hydride–proton pairs facilitate the hydrogenation of polar bonds since polar bonds are excellent acceptors for both hydrides and protons.15,16 However, the relatively high energy barrier associated with the direct heterolytic pathway may lead to a sluggish hydrogenation kinetics compared with the barrierless homolytic dissociation of H2 on metal ensembles.15 Hydrogen spillover involves the homolytic dissociation of H2 on metals, where the resulting active H* species migrate to either the support or the metal sites. This migration can lead to charge separation into protons and/or hydrides.18–21 Specifically, we can infer from the local coordination structures of H2 heterolytic dissociation that proton and hydride pairs could form through charge separation of the active H* species when Lewis acid–base units are present on the catalyst.
Over the past decades, layered double oxides (LDOs) and hydroxides (LDHs) have made significant contributions to high-value upgrading reactions of biomass resources.22 Due to the availability of acid–base sites, they are excellent candidates for generating protons and hydrides via spillover. Herein, we developed Mg,Al-LDH-supported Pt/Fe catalysts (PtFex/LDH) for the hydrogenolysis of biomass-derived furanic compounds into their corresponding ring-opening alcohol products, achieving diol/triol yields exceeding 90% with complete conversion of the furanic compounds. The hydrogenolysis process of the Csp2–O bond was elucidated through spectroscopic measurements, Kinetic isotope experiment analysis, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations, highlighting the role of hydrogen species—H+ and H− pairs—in opening the unsaturated furan ring. The findings suggest that this selective hydrogenolysis follows an SN2 mechanism, with H− acting as the nucleophile. Furthermore, systematic characterization and control experiments revealed the synergy between Pt nanoparticles (NPs) and Ptδ+⋯O2− Lewis acid–base units, as well as the role of Fe in facilitating the ring-opening of furan compounds.
Diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS) was conducted over Pt/(Mg,Al)O and PtFe0.7/(Mg,Al)O using CO as the probe to further explore the structure of the catalysts (Fig. 1D–F). As seen in Fig. 1D, the doublet peaks at approximately 2167 cm−1 and 2119 cm−1 are attributed to CO gas.24,25 Similar features of CO adsorption bands are also observed in samples without Pt, such as Fe/(Mg,Al)O and (Mg,Al)O (Fig. S4†). The band at around 2070 cm−1 is assigned to CO linearly adsorbed on Pt metal sites, while the shoulder at approximately 2024 cm−1 corresponds to CO adsorbed on lower-coordination Pt metal sites.26–28 The decrease in intensity of the CO adsorption band at 2070 cm−1 indicates a significant reduction in the exposed Pt metal sites in PtFe0.7/(Mg,Al)O compared with Pt/(Mg,Al)O. This may be attributed to the Fe oxide/hydroxide species deposited on the surface of Pt nanoparticles, which obscure partial active sites of Pt,29 which aligns with the STEM-EDX line-scanning results (Fig. S3†). The weak peak at around 1830 cm−1 is assigned to bridge-bonded CO adsorption on Pt. In DRIFTS spectra of CO desorption (Fig. 1E and F), the peak at 2202 cm−1 is associated with CO bound to cationic Pt sites,24,30 which is more prominent in PtFe0.7/(Mg,Al)O than in Pt/(Mg,Al)O.
Quasi-in situ X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analysis of PtFex/LDH (the hydrothermally treated PtFex/(Mg,Al)O samples) was further conducted in an anaerobic environment. Pt 4f spectrum clearly demonstrates that both Pt0 and Pt2+ are present on the surface of these catalysts (Fig. 1G).31 Compared with Pt/LDH, the binding energies (BE) of Pt0 in PtFex/LDH exhibit a slight positive shift (Fig. S5†), indicating a lower electron density of surface Pt. This phenomenon could be attributed to electron transfer from Pt clusters to FeOx via Pt–O–Fe bonding.29 Notably, the oxidation state of Pt in PtFe0.7/LDH aligns with that observed in PtFe0.7/(Mg,Al)O sample (Fig. S6†). Additionally, the valence state of Fe is +2 under the anaerobic environment (Fig. 1H) but +3 in air (Fig. S7†). X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) were employed to analyze the local electronic and geometric structures of PtFex/(Mg, Al)O. The Pt L3-edge extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) spectra of PtFex/(Mg,Al)O exhibits two peaks at 2.0 and 2.7 Å, corresponding to the Pt–O and Pt–Pt bonds, respectively (Fig. S8, S9, and Table S2†), further affirming the co-existence of Pt single sites and clusters in PtFex/(Mg,Al)O. The Fe K-edge EXAFS spectra of PtFex/(Mg,Al)O (Fig. S10, S11 and Table S2†) also provide evidence for the absence of a Pt–Fe bond, confirming that no Pt–Fe alloy is formed.32,33 Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy were employed to characterize the paramagnetic centers of the catalysts. EPR signals of oxygen vacancies (Ov) were observed at 3350 G in our catalysts (Fig. 1I).
Catalyst | Conv. (%) | Selectivity (%) | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
m | n | f | e | m + n | ||
a Reaction conditions: 80 μL FA, 30 mg catalyst, 2.0 mL water, 1.0 MPa H2, 150 °C, 5.5 h. Pentanol including 1-pentanol and 2-pentanol.b The solvent was 2.0 mL mixture of ethanol and water (v/v = 1/1).c The solvent was 2.0 mL ethanol. | ||||||
PtFe0.7/LDH | 100 | 82.0 | 8.9 | 4.8 | 2.3 | 90.9 |
Pt/LDH | 100 | 70.1 | 9.1 | 1.5 | 16.3 | 79.2 |
Fe/LDH | 1.4 | — | — | — | — | — |
PtCo0.8/LDH | 100 | 60.8 | 7.5 | 14.0 | 13.2 | 68.3 |
PtNi0.7/LDH | 100 | 17.0 | 10.4 | 1.0 | 69.3 | 27.4 |
PtMn0.7/LDH | 12.1 | 28.2 | 15.0 | 2.9 | 30.5 | 43.2 |
PtFe0.7/LDHb | 59.1 | 73.8 | 18.2 | 6.3 | 1.7 | 92 |
PtFe0.7/LDHc | 12.6 | 37.7 | 18.5 | 3.2 | 24.0 | 56.2 |
Furthermore, when Fe in PtFe0.7/LDH is substituted with other transition metals including Co, Ni and Mn, the conversion of FA or the selectivity of diols decreases. Specifically, the conversion of FA over PtMn0.7/LDH is only 12.1%, while the selectivity of diols is only 27.4% over PtNi0.7/LDH. The influence of the Fe/Pt ratio on the catalytic performance was further investigated (Fig. 2A). With increasing Fe content in PtFex/(Mg,Al)O, the formation of the ring hydrogenation product tetrahydrofurfuryl alcohol (THFA) is suppressed, leading to increased selectivity toward 1,2-PeD. However, with further increasing Fe content, the conversion of FA noticeably decreases, indicating that the excessive Fe may reduce the activity of the catalyst. Recycling experiments were conducted to assess the stability of the PtFe0.7/LDH catalyst.34 The selectivity and conversion results indicate that the catalyst remains relatively stable over three cycles (Fig. S12).†
Fig. 2B and C illustrates the time-dependent FA conversion over Pt/LDH and PtFe0.7/LDH. 1,2-PeD remains the dominant product consistently over Pt/LDH and PtFe0.7/LDH. Notably, the cyclic hydrogenation product THFA is significantly inhibited by Fe introduction. This effect could be attributed to the reduced electron density of Pt nanoparticles (Fig. S5)† in the presence of Fe, which hinders the adsorption of CC bonds and thereby suppresses ring hydrogenation.29,31 Kinetic isotope effect (KIE) experiments, which compare the reaction rates using H2 and D2, or H2O and D2O, were conducted by replacing hydrogen (H) with deuterium (D) either in water (KIEH2O/D2O = kH2O/kD2O) or in H2 (KIEH2/D2 = kH2/kD2) (Fig. 2D–F). The apparent KIEH2/D2 value is approximately unity in both ring-opening and ring-hydrogenation reactions. Gas chromatography-mass spectrometer (GC-MS) (Fig. S13 and S14†) and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) (Fig. S15†) spectra indicate that D is distributed across almost all carbon atoms of the products. Considering the ∼16:1 total H/D ratio in the system, exchange between H and D likely occurs during hydrogen spillover (see below) before hydrogenation. The apparent KIEH2O/D2O values for THFA production and the ring-opening reaction are noticeably different, with values of ∼2 and >5, respectively. The higher KIEH2O/D2O value for the ring-opening reaction suggests that it is more likely to involve a high-barrier hydrogen transfer process than THFA production.
Hydrogenolysis reactions of other furanic compounds, including furan, furfural (FFR) and 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF), were also conducted over the PtFe0.7/LDH catalyst. As anticipated, high selectivity towards ring-opened alcohols was achieved (Fig. S16–S19 and Table S4†). Furanic compounds with oxygenated side chains, such as FA, FFR and HMF, exhibit higher selectivity toward ring-opened products, benefiting from the oxygenated side chain preferentially absorbing on the catalyst surface. These catalytic results confirm that PtFe0.7/LDH is indeed a highly active and selective catalyst for the hydrogenolysis of various furanic compounds to polyols. Particularly, it is observed that FFR is fully converted into FA over PtFe0.7/LDH within 30 min (Fig. S20†), demonstrating the high activity of hydrogen species for the hydrogenation of polar CO bond.
An in situ diffuse reflection infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy (DRIFTS) study in H2 over Pt/(Mg,Al)O and PtFe0.7/(Mg,Al)O catalysts was conducted to analyze the surface species (Fig. 3B and C). The bands observed in the range of 2800∼3700 cm−1 and around 1600 cm−1 are assigned to hydroxyl stretching vibrations and water bending vibrations, respectively, which derives from the reduction of the supported PtOx phase.40,41 It seems that the addition of Fe reduces the intensity of the hydroxyl and water peaks. According to the previous reports,41,42 the peaks at ∼2050 cm−1 and ∼1950 cm−1 are related to strongly adsorbed linear Pt–H species. The difference between these two strongly adsorbed species might be related to the type of environment around the hydride. It has been proven that under negative fields, the stretching frequency of Pt–H can shift to a lower frequency.43 As shown in Fig. 3B and C, compared with Pt/(Mg,Al)O, PtFe0.7/(Mg,Al)O exhibits a higher ratio of low-frequency Pt–H to high-frequency Pt–H, indicating that the addition of Fe promotes the generation of more negatively charged Pt–H species.
From the experimental observations, we propose that H2 molecules first undergo barrierless homolysis activation on metallic Pt NPs of PtFex/(Mg,Al)O catalysts, forming neutral active H* species. In the presence of Ptδ+⋯O2− Lewis acid–base sites, these neutral active H* species can then migrate either to Pt single sites, producing Pt–Hδ− species, or interact with oxygen species, producing O–H+ species.44 Therefore, Pt–Hδ− and O–H+ likely function as active species for the ring-opening reaction. Low conversion and diols selectivity are observed when the reaction is conducted in ethanol or a water/ethanol mixture (Table 1), suggesting that water is crucial for the hydrogenation/hydrogenolysis of FA, likely due to its role in hydrogen spillover and proton transfer.18,45–49
As mentioned above, a significant normal KIE is observed (KIEH2O/D2O > 5) in the ring-opening reaction (Fig. 2D and E). Such a large H–D KIE in hydrogenation has also been observed on a Pd single atom catalyst (kH/kD = 5.75),17 suggesting that the rate-determining step is proton transfer rather than the hydrogen atom or hydride transfer from the Pt–Hδ− motif. Otherwise, an inverse KIE would be observed as the force constant of Pt–H bond is smaller than that of C–H bond.50–52 By comparison, for the ring hydrogenation to THFA, a smaller KIE (KIEH2O/D2O ∼2) is observed, which may be attributed to a weighted average of two pathways: one involving neutral hydrogen (H*) on the Pt nanoparticle surface, and the other involving polar hydrogen (Hδ− and H+). The former pathway is dominant due to the nonpolar nature of the CC bond.47
Based on the experimental and theoretical evidence, we propose the reaction mechanism for the ring-opening of FA over PtFex/LDH as illustrated in Fig. 4. The FA hydrogenolysis starts from the barrierless homolysis activation of H2 on the Pt NPs, and then the active H* species migrate to the Pt single sites and the LDH support, producing Pt–Hδ− and O–H+ (proton) species at the Ptδ+⋯O2− Lewis acid–base unit of PtFex/LDH.44 It should be noted that in an aqueous solution, H+ may migrate to other oxygen atoms on the support or form hydrated protons during the transfer process. DFT calculations indicate a reduction in the LUMO energy after the furanic compounds are protonated (Fig. 3E and S22†). This suggests that the reaction is initiated by the proton combining with O on the furan ring, and subsequently Hδ− attacks the carbon atom of the Csp2–O bond in the furan ring, initiating an SN2 reaction that cleaves the furan ring. Upon completion of the ring-opening, the reaction intermediates form unsaturated alcohols. Subsequent hydrogenation of these unsaturated alcohols yields the final desired alcohol products.
Further examination of the DFT results reveals the Löwdin population of the LUMO on the carbon atom with oxygenated side chain is lower compared with that without such a chain (Fig. S22†), leading to Hδ− predominantly targeting the carbon atom of the Csp2–O bond furthest from the hydroxymethyl group. The steric hindrance caused by the hydroxymethyl group may be another reason for the higher selectivity of 1,2-PeD over 1,5-PeD.53 The addition of Fe enhances catalytic selectivity by facilitating the formation of Fe oxide/hydroxide species on the Pt surface, which inhibit the adsorption of vinyl groups and consequently suppress the hydrogenation of the furan ring.29
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc05751a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |