Tobias Rexab,
Sebastian Baumertc,
Alexander Heppa,
Gustavo Fernández*c and
Cristian A. Strassert*ab
aUniversität Münster, Institut für Anorganische und Analytische Chemie, Corrensstraße 28/30, 48149 Münster, Germany. E-mail: ca.s@uni-muenster.de
bUniversität Münster, CeNTech, CiMIC, SoN, Heisenbergstraße 11, 48149 Münster, Germany
cUniversität Münster, Organisch-Chemisches Institut, Corrensstraße 36, 48149 Münster, Germany. E-mail: fernandg@uni-muenster.de
First published on 9th October 2024
Transition metal complexes are archetypal luminescent probes that are widely used for various applications ranging from optoelectronics to biomedicine. However, they face significant challenges such as photobleaching and photooxidative stress, which limit their performance. Herein, we introduce a photosystem-inspired concept based on the use of a vitamin (ascorbic acid, Asc-Ac) to adaptively suppress photobleaching of molecular luminophores. As a proof-of-concept compound, we have selected a new bis-cyclometalated Pt(II) complex (Pt-tBu) and investigated its adaptive photoluminescence resulting from singlet dioxygen (1O2) photoproduction in the presence of Asc-Ac. Interestingly, the excited state quenching and subsequent photobleaching of Pt-tBu in aerated solutions is suppressed by addition of Asc-Ac, which scavenges the 1O2 photosensitized by Pt-tBu upon irradiation and results in an adaptive oxygen depletion with enhancement of luminescence. The adaptation is resilient for successive irradiation cycles with oxygen replenishment, until peroxidation overshooting leads to the degradation of Pt-tBu by formation of a dark Pt(IV) species. The complexity-related adaptation with initial overperformance (luminescence boost) relies on the external energy input and cascaded feedback loops, thus biomimicking inflammation, as the repeated exposure to a stressor leads to a final breakdown. Our antioxidative protection mechanism against photobleaching can be successfully extended to multiple coordination compounds (e.g., Ir(III), Ru(II) and Re(I) complexes), thus demonstrating its generality. Our findings broaden the scope of molecular adaptation and pave the way for enhancing the stability of molecular luminophores for multiple applications.
A long-standing challenge in chemical systems that would greatly benefit from protective measures is the phenomenon of photobleaching.6 Akin to biological systems, molecular luminophores are significantly affected by oxidative stress, which can modulate their properties and function.7–9 Despite their widespread interest and versatile applications in optoelectronics,10–14 bioimaging15–18 and photocatalysis,19 transition metal complexes (including Ru(II), Ir(III) and Pt(II) coordination compounds) are among the luminophores that suffer from photobleaching mainly due to Dexter energy transfer to triplet dioxygen, i.e., quenching by 3O2 to yield highly reactive 1O2.20–23 As a result, they can be used as photosensitizers (PS)24–26 in photodynamic therapy (PDT).27,28 A prominent molecular design strategy to improve the performance and stability of Pt(II) complexes lies in the use of tetradentate bis-cyclometallated ligands, which enable a stabilizing rigidification of the coordination environment.29–31 However, if quenching is not suppressed by deoxygenation, photooxidative stress triggered by irradiation with 1O2 generation ultimately leads to degradation.32–34 In recent years, various strategies have been developed to improve photostability through molecular design.35 These approaches include increasing the oxidation potential of molecules,36 introducing structural changes in the auxiliary ligand37 and creating supramolecular architectures such as micelles38 to enhance photostability. Additionally, the linking of protective agents39 or the embedding of luminophores in frameworks40,41 as well as the use of chelate complexes42 are effective methods for protection against chemical degradation. However, these strategies often alter the emission properties and the chemical environment of the luminophores. Therefore, there is a substantial need to develop alternative chemical approaches to stabilize luminophores in solution against oxidative stress while preserving their optical properties.
Herein, we introduce a bioinspired antioxidative strategy that adaptively suppresses quenching and prevents photobleaching of photosensitizing luminophores. To demonstrate our approach, we synthesized a Pt(II)-based luminophore bearing a tetradentate bis-cyclometalated ligand (Pt-tBu, Fig. 1)43,44 and examined its adaptive response to irradiation in the presence of 3O2 and Asc-Ac (for synthesis and characterization, see Fig. S2†). The three peripheral tert-butyl groups of Pt-tBu were included to prevent aggregation, while the square-planar coordination geometry remains accessible to dioxygen. Pt-tBu exhibits an intense photoluminescence in liquid solutions upon deoxygenation, but it rapidly undergoes photobleaching if quenched by dissolved 3O2 (Fig. 1). Interestingly, Asc-Ac scavenges the photosensitized 1O2 generated by Pt-tBu, leading to a significant luminescence enhancement due to the depletion of 3O2. Re-equilibration with oxygen, followed by successive irradiation cycles, ultimately leads to the peroxidation of the Pt-tBu to a Pt(IV) species. Hence, the initial overperformance followed by breakdown upon repeated aggression resembles stress-adaptation of organisms leading to collapse, irreparable damage or chronic conditions, such as rheumatoid arthritis or other autoimmune diseases.45
ΦL(air) (±2) (%) | ΦL(Ar) (±3) (%) | τ(air) (ns) | τ(Ar) (ns) | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Pt-tBu | <2 | 59 | 124.6 ± 0.3 | 6895 ± 9 |
The phosphorescence of Pt-tBu is quenched by 3O2 in a diffusion-controlled exciplex formation (Dexter energy transfer), leading to the production of 1O2. In fact, the phosphorescence of 1O2 becomes evident in the NIR (peaking at 1275 nm, Fig. S37†).
To assess the potential degradation of Pt-tBu due to photooxidative stress, we examined its stability under UV irradiation (λex = 365 nm) by measuring the UV-vis absorption spectra and the photoluminescence intensity (Fig. S35 and S36†). Subsequent irradiation of Pt-tBu solutions at two different concentrations (10 μM and 25 μM) with UV light in a photoreactor revealed that Pt-tBu undergoes partial decomposition in the presence of 3O2. This was verified by the loss of the 1MLCT band at 400 nm in the UV-vis spectra and the drop of emission intensity in the photoluminescence spectra (Fig. 2a, S35 and S36†). On the other hand, Pt-tBu exhibits resistance against UV irradiation upon deaeration, as evident from its invariant absorption and emission features (Fig. 2a, S38 and S39†). These results confirm that photosensitized 1O2 is the primary cause for the photobleaching of Pt-tBu.
To study the biomimetic protection involving an antioxidant, we prepared a mixture that combines Asc-Ac and Pt-tBu. In DMF, an excess of Asc-Ac in the presence of Pt-tBu under UV irradiation (in a photoreactor) indicated that the stressor (3O2 photoconverted into 1O2) no longer affects the luminophoric PS Pt-tBu. Hence, only minor changes were observed in the MLCT absorption band before and directly after long-term irradiation (120 s, Fig. 2a and S40†).
The changes in the higher energy absorption bands (<400 nm) can be attributed to the formation of H2O2, dehydroascorbate, and a new coordination-chemical species (Fig. 1 and S40†). Furthermore, a narrowing of these bands becomes evident upon aging after irradiation (Fig S40,† right), which is accompanied by a decrease in the MLCT band located around 400 nm, which can be associated to the formation of a Pt(IV) species. Herein, a hydroperoxo ligand is incorporated upon oxidation of the former Pt(II) complex, thus influencing both absorption and emission spectra. Remarkable, though, was the immediate boost of the emission intensity and the prolonged excited state lifetime of Pt-tBu (Fig. 2b and S49†).
To understand this behavior, we explored the influence of gradual irradiation on the emission intensity of Pt-tBu at two different concentrations (10 μM and 25 μM), in order to double the 1O2 photoproduction rate, in the presence of Asc-Ac at two different concentrations (5 mM and 10 mM) (Fig. S41 and S42†). It was ensured that there was no gaseous headspace for the air-equilibrated system, as otherwise external oxygen could re-diffuse into the solution. Notably, the phosphorescence intensities increased until they reached a plateau, indicating that the Pt-tBu is no longer quenched by 3O2 (Fig. 2c). In addition, we observed that both the concentration of Pt-tBu and the irradiation time (10 s and 15 s) influence the rate of adaptation. A higher concentration of Pt-tBu results in a reduced lag time to reach the plateau (Fig. 2c). We attribute this phenomenon to an increased 1O2 production rate and its trapping by the excess of Asc-Ac at higher concentrations of Pt-tBu. This suggests that 3O2 is converted to 1O2 and subsequently neutralized by Asc-Ac to form dehydroascorbate. In contrast, decreasing the irradiation intervals from 15 s to 10 s at a constant concentration (10 μM) resulted in a significantly delayed intensity rise (Fig. 2c). Thus, a substantial enhancement in emission can only be achieved upon extended irradiation (60 s). This can be explained by the slower oxygen photoactivation and reaction with Asc-Ac. On the other hand, we observed that an increase in the concentration of Asc-Ac from 5 mM to 10 mM had no effect on the onset. Note that the most efficient protection of the luminophore occurs using 200–1000 equivalents of ascorbic acid to ensure the quenching of the 1O2 produced during the irradiation process. Moreover, plotting (I/Imax) − 1 vs. increasing quencher concentration (i.e., vs. 1 − (t/tmax), meaning progressively shorter irradiation times) revealed that the process can be represented in a Stern–Volmer-like plot (Fig. S43†). Besides the intensity changes, the lifetimes after reaching the plateau were measured. For Pt-tBu (10 μM) with Asc-Ac (5 mM), the lifetime increased to τ = 5.0 μs after irradiation (120 s). This contrasts with the shorter lifetime of τ = 120 ns observed for Pt-tBu in air-equilibrated solutions (Fig. S47 and S49†), confirming the partial scavenging of the quencher (3O2). Nevertheless, it does not reach the lifetime upon full deoxygenation (vide infra), indicating the involvement of other quenching phenomena or residual 3O2. This is also evidenced by the fluctuations within the plateau phase.
After a full irradiation cycle (90 s) of the sealed air-equilibrated mixture (identical to those in Fig. 2b) with a waiting period of one hour, the traces of re-diffused oxygen can be again scavenged, achieving the previous plateau yet without substantial photobleaching, as indicated by the minimal change in the MLCT band (Fig. S44,† inset). We hypothesize that the observed drop after three iterations may be associated with the depletion of Asc-Ac resulting in the slower kinetics due to a constant trigger. To ascertain that oxygen is indeed the predominant factor mediating the process and to rule out the formation of other species such as Pt-tBu-Asc-Ac, we conducted experiments upon Ar-purging and visually tracked the re-diffusion of minute oxygen traces into the system. The lifetimes of the Ar-purged samples, both with and without Asc-Ac, were identical (Fig. S48 and S51†). Notably, after irradiating the Ar-purged mixture yet including Asc-Ac, even the last traces of oxygen are evidently scavenged (Fig. 3a, S51 and S52†) while maximizing the lifetime.
Contrastingly, in an open system (i.e., with air headspace), the significant drop of lifetime upon passive oxygen re-equilibration was confirmed by lifetime measurements at different recovery times. Monitoring irradiation of the system in the photoreactor, followed by immediate and delayed (2 min) lifetime measurements, a drastic shortening was observed (Fig. 3a). This rapid re-equilibration of the system through passive oxygen diffusion (after the quencher has been scavenged) illustrates the dynamic nature of the process. Furthermore, the intensity gradient at the interface can be visually observed under UV light (inset Fig. 3a), confirming that the 3O2 is the central actor. To gain further insights into how sustained stress exposure affects the system's resilience, we systematically re-equilibrated the mixture after each irradiation cycle (90 s) with air (Fig. 3b and c).
We observed two significant features: the adaptation ability at each cycle (before complete breakdown) depends on the concentration of both Pt-tBu and Asc-Ac. Increasing the concentration of Pt-tBu and Asc-Ac leads to a longer stability of the system, which can be explained in two ways: Firstly, higher Pt-tBu concentrations generate comparatively more 1O2 accompanied by an increased conversion of Asc-Ac before bleaching of Pt-tBu can occur. Secondly, the conversion capacity increases with a higher Asc-Ac concentration, thereby hindering the reaction of Pt-tBu with 1O2. However, after several cycles, the system undergoes degradation with exhaustion and observable depression due to permanent re-equilibration with the stressor. Mass spectrometry revealed that the photobleaching and the generated H2O2 results in the formation of a non-emissive Pt(IV) derivative of Pt-tBu, wherein oxygen occupies an axial position (Fig. S33†). Overall, the response resembles initial performance boost of biological systems as a response to an aggressor, followed by fatigue and breakdown upon repeated or sustained exposure to harm.46 Hence, adaptation to stress with suppression of the stressor (3O2) causes an overperformance of the system (higher luminescence intensity), much like an organism immediately adapting to stress (adrenaline, short-term response) and coping with it in a sustained manner (cortisol, mid-term response); however, sustained exposure causes fatigue and failure.47,48
To ultimately demonstrate the broad applicability of the concept, we subjected different photosensitizing coordination compounds (including Ir(III),49 Ru(II)50 and Re(I)51 complexes as well as another Pt(II)24 species, 25 μM) to irradiation with Asc-Ac (10 mM) in DMF (Fig. 4). Remarkably, Asc-Ac scavenges the photosensitized 1O2 generated by the three PS, resulting in a significant increase in emission intensity upon adaptation in the respective emission maxima from green to red (Fig. 4a–c, middle cuvettes). The rapid re-equilibration of the system, driven by passive oxygen diffusion, can be visually observed at the interface (Fig. 4a–c, right cuvettes), which underlines the generality of this adaptation for all tested PS and demonstrates the broad scope of our antioxidative mechanism.
Fig. 4 Structural formulae of fac-tris-(2-phenylpyridine)iridium(III)49 (a), tricarbonyl(cyanido)(1,10-phenanthroline)rhenium(I) (b),51 [PtCl(LTh)]24 (c) and tris(2,2′-bipyridyl)ruthenium(II) dichloride hexahydrate50 (d). Shown are the corresponding pictures of the cuvettes with each complex (25 μM) and Asc-Ac (10 mM) in DMF before and after the irradiation in a photoreactor (as observed under UV light, λex = 365 nm). Pictures on the right demonstrate the diffusion of fresh oxygen from the headspace after irradiation. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc06096b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |