Taishi
Oka
a,
Takeshi
Maeda
*a,
Daisuke
Sakamaki
b,
Naoya
Suzuki
a,
Shigeyuki
Yagi
a,
Shintaro
Kodama
a and
Hideki
Fujiwara
*b
aDepartment of Applied Chemistry, Graduate School of Engineering, Osaka Metropolitan University, Naka-ku, Sakai 599-8531, Japan. E-mail: tmaeda@omu.ac.jp
bDepartment of Chemistry, Graduate School of Science, Osaka Metropolitan University, Sumiyoshi-ku, Osaka 558-8585, Japan. E-mail: hfuji@omu.ac.jp
First published on 23rd October 2024
We synthesized squaraine dyes incorporating 4-membered thionated oxocarbon and chalcogenopyrylium moieties, which displayed intermediate diradical character as confirmed by bond-length analysis and temperature-dependent behaviors observed in 1H NMR and ESR spectroscopy. The 1H NMR signals of the cyclobutenedithione dyes disappeared at lower temperatures compared to the cyclobutenedione analogues, indicating a lower thermal transition to the excited triplet state and thus greater diradical character. Moreover, we identified cis–trans isomerization in the thionated dyes. Notably, an increase in diradical character lowered the activation energy of this isomerization, facilitating the structural transition between cis and trans isomers. These dyes exhibit strong near-infrared absorption, with slight temperature-dependent shifts likely arising from the closely matched electronic transition energies of the isomers.
The diradical character not only influences the physical properties of these molecules but also affects their structural conversions. For instance, some singlet diradicaloids induced structural transformations through diradical configurations (Fig. 1A).20 Kozaki, Okada, et al. reported the thermal cis–trans isomerization of a dithienoquinoid analogue of Chichibabin's hydrocarbon (Fig. 1B).21 More recently, Wu et al. reported that oxindolyl-based Chichibabin's hydrocarbons induced cis–trans isomerization due to the contribution of the diradical forms (Fig. 1C).22 These cases collectively highlight the pivotal role of intermediate diradical character in driving dynamic structural changes.
Fig. 1 An example of a structural change in a diradical form (A). Thermal cis–trans isomerization of Chichibabin's hydrocarbon analogues (B and C). |
Until recently, the range of compounds classified as singlet diradicals was relatively narrow. However, it is now clear that a variety of compounds with extended π-electron systems exhibit sustained singlet diradical character. In fact, even molecules traditionally considered as closed-shell, such as certain diketopyrrolopyrrole derivatives and donor–acceptor conjugated polymers with quinoid repeat units, can exhibit intermediate diradical character.23–28 We also demonstrated that croconaine dyes, typically classified as closed-shell species, actually exhibited intermediate diradical character.29 These dyes consisting of chalcogenopyrylium and five-membered oxocarbons (see Fig. 2A), displayed notable temperature-dependent magnetic properties due to their thermally accessible triplet states.
In addition to the croconaine dyes, chalcogenopyrylium-based squaraine dyes, that were four-membered oxocarbon analogues for the variable applications,30–33 also exhibited intermediate diradical character.34 Although we previously confirmed that the chalcogenopyrylium moiety influences the contribution of the diradical structure, the impact of the central oxyallyl structure on the diradical character remains unclear. Thioxyallyl derivatives, where sulphur atom replaces the oxygen atom in the oxyallyl structure, are known to exhibit diradical character, unlike oxyallyl derivatives.35 Therefore, investigating the effect of sulphur-substitutions in the central skeleton on diradical character of squaraine dyes is of particular interest.
In this study, we synthesized novel chalcogenopyrylium-based squaraine dyes featuring a cyclobutenedithione central skeleton (SQ2a: X = O, SQ2b: X = S) to evaluate their intermediate diradical character (Fig. 2B). These dyes exist as cis–trans isomers, where their intermediate diradical character is likely to influence the isomerization behavior. To investigate this further, we examined the cis–trans isomerization of the obtained dyes and compared their behaviour with existing squaraine dyes containing cyclobutenediones (SQ1a–b).
Fig. 3 displays the X-ray structures of SQ2a and SQ2b, with detailed information available in the ESI.‡ Both dyes were analysed as planar trans isomers. In the crystal structure of SQ2a, two crystallographically independent molecules are present. We investigated the degree of diradical character by examining four major resonance forms (α to δ) chosen from 16 possible resonance forms (Fig. 3C, and Fig. S3‡). To evaluate their contribution, we analysed the difference in average bond lengths along the thio-oxyallyl part, denoted as ΔD = ave(g, p) − ave(h, q), where ave(a, b) represents the average of bond lengths a and b. For closed-shell mesoionic structures (α and β), ΔD = 0 due to identical bond lengths in the double and single bond pairs (g, p) and (h, q). In contrast, for the diradical δ form, ΔD > 0 because the outer parts (g and p) are single bonds while the inner parts (h and q) are double bonds. The γ form shows the reverse trend with ΔD < 0. Importantly, the ΔD values from the X-ray structures of SQ2a and SQ2b are positive (ΔD > 0), suggesting that the large contribution of diradical δ form, with unpaired electrons on the chalcogenopyrylium components (Table 1).
Fig. 3 Single crystal X-ray structures of SQ2a (A) and SQ2b (B) at 100 K. Bond lengths of the methine part (g and p) are shown in the Table 1. Resonance contributors of mesoinonic structures (α and β), thio-oxyallyl diradical (γ), and chalcogenopyranyl radical (δ) (C). ΔD is defined as ΔD = ave(g, p) − ave(h, q). |
The singlet diradical nature of SQ2a–b was also confirmed by DFT calculations (see ESI, Table S3‡).37–40 The ΔD value obtained from the crystal structure was intermediate between the values for the singlet and triplet states from DFT-optimized structures at the UB3PW91/cc-pVDZ level (Table 1). This suggests that SQ2a–b is in a state that lies between a pure singlet and triplet state.
The diradical index y0, where y0 = 0 and y0 = 1 correspond to a perfect closed-shell and an open-shell electronic structure, respectively, is commonly used to express the degree of contribution of the diradical form in singlet diradicaloids (see ESI‡).41 We estimated y0 values for trans isomers of SQ2a and SQ2b using the spin-projected unrestricted Hartree–Fock (PUHF) theory using the 6-31G(d,p) basis set, obtaining values of 0.24 and 0.37, respectively (Table 2). These results suggest that the thiopyrylium skeleton enhances the contribution of the diradical form.
Dye | Signal-disappearance temperature in 1H NMR a | Vibrational frequency (cm−1) b | λ max (nm) (logε)c | ΔG‡d (kcal mol−1) | y 0 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a The temperatures at which the signals assigned to the protons of the chalcogenopyrylium skeleton disappear in DMSO-d6. b Frequencies of the stretching bands around methine groups in CHCl3. Details are shown in ESI.‡ c Electronic absorption maxima in DMSO. The values in parentheses indicate logarithm of molar absorptivity. d The Gibbs free energies of activation (ΔG‡) for the cis–trans isomerization calculated by dynamic NMR method. Details are shown in ESI.‡ e The diradical index calculated by the spin-projected unrestricted Hartree–Fock (PUHF) theory using the 6-31G(d,p) basis set. Details are shown in ESI.‡ | |||||
SQ2a | 333 | 1480 | 754 (5.22) | 13.7 | 0.24 |
SQ2b | >303 | 1470 | 849 (5.28) | 13.4 | 0.37 |
SQ1a | <423 | 1487 | 721 (5.37) | — | 0.37 |
SQ1b | 403 | 1478 | 822 (5.44) | 14.5 | 0.47 |
In addition to the bond length analyses, ESR spectra of these dyes displayed a signature of singlet diradicaloids. While the signal intensity of SQ2a was very low, both SQ2a and SQ2b exhibited signals with g values of 2.006, indicating the presence of carbon-centred radicals (Fig. 4). While SQ2a displayed negligible temperature-dependent behaviour, SQ2b showed increased signal intensity with rising temperature, indicating a thermal transition from singlet to triplet states that reflects its singlet diradical nature. This observation suggests that the thiopyrylium skeleton likely enhances the diradical contribution.
Unlike metal-free organic dyes with closed-shell structures, SQ2a–b exhibit characteristic temperature-dependent behavior in their 1H NMR spectra in DMSO-d6 due to their diradical character (Fig. 5A for SQ2a, Fig. 5B for SQ2b). At 303 K, SQ2a showed signals attributed to the proton on the pyrylium component. As the temperature increased, the signal broadened and completely disappeared at 333 K (Table 2). In SQ2b, no signal corresponding to the proton on the thiopyrylium components was observed, even at 303 K, where DMSO-d6 barely freezes. These results indicate an increase in thermally excited triplet species with increasing temperature, confirming the intermediate diradical nature of SQ2a–b. Thus, 1H NMR studies, along with ESR data, clearly show that the intermediate diradical character of SQ2b is higher than that of SQ2a.
We previously reported that SQ1a–b, with cyclobutenedione skeletons (precursors to SQ2a–b), also exhibits intermediate diradical character. For SQ1a–b, the proton signals disappear above 400 K, whereas for SQ2a–b, the proton signals vanish at a lower temperature, around 300–330 K (Table 2). This is because SQ2a–b reach their thermally excited triplet state at a lower temperature, indicating a smaller energy gap between the singlet and triplet states and a significant contribution from the diradical forms. Thus, thionation of the central skeleton enhances the contribution of the diradical structure, even though the diradical index y0 values for SQ1a–b are estimated to be larger than those for SQ2a–b due to limitations in computational accuracy.
The single crystal of SQ1b contains both cis and trans isomers, confirming that cis–trans isomerization occurs in solution.42 Similar to SQ1b, SQ2a–b also exhibited cis and trans isomers at lower temperatures in CDCl3 (Fig. 5A for SQ2a, Fig. 5B for SQ2b and Fig. S9–10‡ for SQ1a–b). Signals corresponding to the protons on the chalcogenopyrylium component coalesced at 278 K for SQ2a and at 273 K for SQ2b, suggesting that the isomerization is promoted at higher temperature condition and the signals for isomers is no longer observed in the NMR timescale. The Gibbs free energies of activation (ΔG‡) for the cis–trans isomerization of SQ2a and SQ2b were estimated using the dynamic NMR method, resulting in values of 13.7 and 13.4 kcal mol−1, respectively (Fig. 5C, and Table 2).43 Although some error was introduced by the inability to observe peak shifts at temperatures below 213 K due to the freezing of CDCl3 used in the measurements, SQ2b, with a cyclobutenedithione skeleton, exhibits a lower ΔG‡ than SQ1b, which has a cyclobutenedione skeleton (ΔG‡ = 14.5 kcal mol−1).44 The higher diradical contribution of SQ2b compared to SQ1b may lower the activation barrier and promote isomerization.
To measure the strength of the C–C double bond involved in isomerization, FT-IR spectra of these dyes in CHCl3 were recorded. The IR absorption corresponding to the stretching vibration around the methine group in SQ2b was observed at a lower wavenumber compared to SQ2a, indicating that the bond in the methine group of SQ2b is relatively weaker (Table 2, Fig. S11 and 12‡). Thus, increased diradical character appears to diminish the double bond character of the methine group in the ground state, thereby promoting cis–trans isomerization.
The electronic absorption spectra for the dyes SQ2a and SQ2b, compared with those of SQ1a and SQ1b, are illustrated in Fig. 6 and summarized in Table 2. SQ2a and SQ2b each exhibit strong and sharp absorption peaks at 754 nm and 849 nm, respectively. The dyes with the cyclobutenedithione skeleton (SQ2a, SQ2b) exhibited absorption bands in a longer wavelength region compared to those with corresponding cyclobutenedione analogues (SQ1a, SQ1b). Notably, SQ2b, which has a high contribution from the diradical structure, demonstrated a lower transition energy. This is consistent with our previous results that a greater diradical character results in reduced transition energy according to the perturbation theory proposed by Fabian et al.34,45 We also examined the temperature-dependence in absorption spectra of these dyes (Fig. 6B, and Fig. S15‡). With increasing temperature, the absorption bands of SQ2a and SQ2b were red-shifted by 2 nm and 5 nm, respectively. This change in absorption band with temperature might be attributed to cis–trans isomerization. DFT calculations estimate that the transition energy of the cis isomer is slightly lower than that of the trans isomer, suggesting that the equilibrium shifts towards the trans isomer at low temperatures due to cis–trans isomerization (Table S3 and S4‡).
Footnotes |
† Dedicated to Prof. Dr Frank Würthner on the occasion of his 60th birthday. |
‡ Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2194625 and 2194626. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4qo01722f |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2025 |