Pratima Rathee
Solanki
a,
Ajeet
Kaushik
a,
T.
Manaka
b,
Manoj Kumar
Pandey
a,
M.
Iwamoto
b,
Ved Varun
Agrawal
a and
Bansi Dhar
Malhotra
*ac
aDepartment of Science and Technology Centre on Biomolecular Electronics, National Physical Laboratory (Council of Scientific Industrial Research), Dr K. S. Krishnan Marg, New Delhi, 110012, India. E-mail: bansi.malhotra@gmail.com; Fax: +91-11-45609310; Tel: +91-11-45609152
bDepartment of Physical Electronics, Tokyo Institute of Technology, 2-12-1-S3-33, O-Okayama, Maguro, Tokyo 152-8552, Japan
cCentre for Nano-Bioengineering and Spintronics, Chungnam National University, Daejeon, 305-764, Korea
First published on 18th October 2010
A self-assembled monolayer (SAM) of 11-amino-1-undecanethiol (AUT) has been fabricated onto a gold (Au) substrate to co-immobilize anti-ochratoxin-A antibodies (AO-IgGs) and bovine serum albumin (BSA) to detect food borne mycotoxin [i.e., ochratoxin-A (OTA)]. AUT/Au electrode, AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode and BSA/IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode have been characterized using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and electrochemical studies such as cyclic voltammetry (CV), differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) and electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS). Electrochemical studies reveal that the AUT-SAM with NH2 groups provide favorable conditions to immobilize AO-IgGs with better orientation, resulting in enhanced electron transport to obtain improved sensing characteristics. The EIS response studies of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode obtained as a function of OTA concentration reveal that the value of the charge transfer resistance (RCT) increases with increased OTA concentration. The BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode exhibits linearity over 0.5–6.0 ng/dl, detection limit of 0.08 ng/dl using 3σb/m criteria, response time of 30 s and sensitivity of ∼36.83 Ω/ng dl−1 cm−2 with a regression coefficient of 0.999. Attempts have been made to monitor the change in RCT of BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode on addition of coffee samples.
Self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) have recently attracted much attention due to their potential applications in biosensors, nanotechnology and biomolecular electronics.7–9 SAMs of organosulfur compounds on gold (Au) have attracted much interest since they offer several advantages such as order, homogeneity, simplicity and are versatile for immobilization of given biomolecules. Moreover, there is a possibility of changing the tail group enabling control of the surface structure of a SAM.10,11 In an electrochemical sensor, SAMs can be used as insulating barriers between an electrode and a redox couple for investigating long range electron-transfer and to measure fast electron-transfer kinetics. A variety of SAMs based biosensors have been developed for detection of food pathogens (mycotoxin i.e., ochratoxin A (OTA)),12 environmental monitoring13 and clinical analysis etc.11,14
OTA is a food contaminating mycotoxin produced by Aspergillus ochraceus and other stains of Aspergillus niger and Penicillium verrucosum.15,16 The presence of OTA has been reported in various agriculture crops such as cereals, pulses, coffee beans in animal feed as well as in tissues and blood of living beings. It has been found that OTA causes nephrotoxin, carcinogenic, genotoxic, immunosuppressive and teratogenic.17,18 Conventional techniques19–31 used for OTA detection require multiple steps including extraction, extensive sample clean-up, pre-concentration, and sometimes derivatization of the desired analyte. In this context, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) based immunosensors have been considered significant for rapid, sensitive and selective detection with improved stability and orientation of the electrode bound antibodies.
Electrochemical immunosensors based on conducting polymers, nanomaterials and nanocomposites have been used for OTA detection. Kaushik et al. 2009 have used sol–gel derived nanostructured cerium oxide films and chitosan (CS)-iron oxide nanocomposites to immobilize IgGs antibodies for OTA detection using differential pulse voltammetry (DPV) technique.27,28 Khan et al. have fabricated CS–polyaniline hybrid conducting biopolymer films and CS-titanium nanocomposite films for the immobilization of IgGs for OTA detection.29,30 Sol–gel derived nanostructured zinc oxide films have been used for co-immobilization of IgGs and BSA to detect OTA.31 A 4-carboxyphenyl film grafted onto a Au electrode by electrochemical reduction of in situ generated 4-carboxyphenyl diazonium salt (4-CPDS) has been used for immobilization of the antibodies for OTA detection using EIS.32 A self-assembled monolayer (SAM) of 1,6-hexanedithiol that mediates the assembly of a Au colloid layer has been utilized for immobilization of alkaline phosphatase labeled horse anti-mouse immunoglobulin G antibody for OTA detection.33 Quartz crystal microbalance based on a 16-mercaptohexadecanoic (16-MHDA) acid immunosensor has been reported for immobilization of AO-OTA IgGs for detection of OTA.23
In this manuscript, we report results of the studies relating to the co-immobilization of AO-IgGs and BSA onto NH2 terminal SAM of 11-amino-1-undecanethiol (AUT) to detect OTA using EIS.
Fig. 1 A) SEM image of the AUT/Au electrode, B) SEM image of the AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode, C) SEM image of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode, D) Schematic for the fabrication of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunosensor showing the biochemical reaction at the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode. |
The contact angle studies of AUT/Au electrode, AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode and BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode have been conducted using the Sessile drop method to assess the hydrophobic/hydrophilic nature of the surface. The value of the contact angle measured as 80° for the bare gold (Au) surface indicates both a clean as well as hydrophobic nature of the surface. The contact angle value decreases to 67° after the SAM formation on the gold surface, due to the presence of the NH2 groups of the AUT molecule on the gold substrate. Further, the contact angle value decreases to 55° and 37.78° in the case of the AO-IgGs/AUT/Au and BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode, respectively, due to hydrophilic nature of the protein (AO-IgGs and BSA) onto the AUT/Au surface.
To obtain an immunosensor with improved sensing characteristics, the carboxyl terminated group [fragment crystallisable (Fc)] of IgGs should be bind to electrode via electrostatic interactions and the free amino terminated site [fragment antigen binding (Fab)] part are free to bind with the antigen with high level of specificity. In our Scheme (Fig. 1D), the NH2 group of AUT-SAM binds with the carboxyl groups (Fc) of AO-IgGs via electrostatic interactions and the free amino terminal sites of AO-IgG (Fab) preferably bind with the carboxylic group of the OTA molecules via hydrogen bonding, ionic bands and van der Waals forces.
Fig. 2A shows results of the cyclic voltammetry (CV) studies conducted on the bare gold (Au) electrode, AUT/Au electrode, AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode, and BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode in PBS {50 mM, pH = 7.4 containing 0.9% NaCl and 5 mM [Fe(CN)6]3−/4−}. The magnitude of electrochemical current response of the AUT/Au electrode (18.5 mA, Curve b) is lower than that of the bare Au electrode (21 mA, Curve a), revealing the formation of AUT-SAM that hinders electron transfer from medium to Au electrode. However, the magnitude of the response current increases to 34.57 mA (Fig. 2A, Curve c) after the immobilization of AO-IgGs onto the AUT/Au electrode. It appears that an available NH2 group of the AUT-SAM binds with the carboxyl group (Fc, terminal) of AO-IgGs and the presence of free NH3+ groups of AO-IgGs (Fab, terminal) leading to increased diffusion of electrons onto the AO-IgGs/AUT/Au electrode that, in turn, results in easier electron communication to the electrode surface. Moreover, the magnitude of current response decreases to 31.35 mA with a slight shift of the redox potential towards the lower side on immobilization of BSA (Fig. 2; Curve d) onto the AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode, due to blocking of non-binding sites of IgGs that hinder electron transfer between medium and electrode, indicating immobilization of BSA onto the AO-IgGs/AUT/Au bioelectrode.
Fig. 2 A) Cyclic voltammogram of the modified SAM with IgGs at a scan rate of 50 mV/s in PBS containing [Fe(CN)6]3−/4−. B) Differential pulse voltammogram (DPV) of the bare Au electrode (a), AUT/Au electrode (b), AO-IgGs/AUT/Au bioelectrode (c) and BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode (d) at potential height as 0.4995 V, potential period as 0.07 ms and interval period as 0.14 ms in PBS containing [Fe(CN)6]3−/4−. C) EIS studies of bare Au electrode (a), AUT/Au electrode (b), IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode (c), BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode (d) in PBS containing [Fe(CN)6]3−/4−. Red lines indicate the simulated curves obtained by fitting model of proposed electronic circuit. Inset A shows the EIS spectra of the IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode (c), BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode (d). |
The results obtained from the CV studies have been correlated with those obtained with differential pulse voltammetry (DPV, Fig. 2B). The magnitude of the current response of the AUT/Au (Curve b) electrode is lower than that of the Au electrode (Curve a). However, magnitude of the current response of the IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode (Curve c) is higher than that of AUT/Au electrode (Curve c), due to the availability of the non-binding sites on IgGs resulting in enhanced electron transport between medium and electrode. The magnitude of the current response of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode (Curve d) is lower than that of AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode due to blocking of non-specific bonding sites of AO-IgGs that perhaps insulate the electrode and perturb electron communication.
The EIS provides an effective method for probing electrical characteristics of the desired surface modified electrode. A small-amplitude perturbing sinusoidal voltage signal is applied to the electrochemical cell and the resulting current is measured. The impedance is calculated as the ratio between the system voltage phasor, U (jω), and the current phasor, I (jω), that are generated by a frequency response analyzer during the experiments.5,34,35 The complex impedance can be presented as a combination of the real, Zre (ω), and imaginary, Zim (ω) components that originate mainly from resistance and capacitance of the cell that can be calculated using eqn (1).
Zω = U(jω)/I(jω) = Zre(ω) + jZim(ω); where ω = 2πf | (Eq. 1) |
A typical shape of the faradic impedance spectrum (presented in the form of the Nyquist plot) includes a semicircle region lying on the Zre (ω) axis followed by a straight line. The semicircle portion, observed at higher frequency, yields the electron transfer resistance (RCT), that exhibits electron transfer kinetics of the redox probe at the electrode interface, whereas linear part represents the diffusion process.34–36 This semicircle also represents the response of heterogeneous charge transfer kinetics (eqn (2) & 3).
RC = RT/nFI0 | (Eq. 2) |
I0 = nFA k0C | (Eq. 3) |
Fig. 2C shows the EIS spectra simulated by the electronic circuit Rs[QdL(RCTW)] [inset, Fig. 2C] for the bare Au electrode, AUT/Au electrode and BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode. It can be seen that RCT of the AUT/Au electrode is larger than (1.42 KΩ, Curve b) that of the bare gold electrode (Curve a) (1.21 K Ω). This may be attributed due to the formation of the monolayer on the Au surface that hinders direct electron flow from the redox probe [Fe(CN)6]3−/4− to the electrode surface. Further, the RCT value decreases to 0.052 KΩ (Curve c) after the immobilization of AO-IgGs onto AUT/Au electrode revealing immobilization of AO-IgGs onto AUT/Au electrode. It appears that of IgGs cationic AO-IgGs/AUT/Au facilitate electron communication between the redox probe [Fe(III)/Fe(IV)] and the electrolyte. Moreover, the value of RCT increases to 0.115 KΩ after immobilization of BSA onto the AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode (Curve d) revealing that insulating BSA layer perhaps hinders diffusion of ferricyanide ions toward the electrode surface. The observed change in RCT after BSA immobilization can be assigned to the dielectric changes and insulating features at the electrode-electrolyte interface arising due to successive immobilization of biomolecules. The immobilized BSA blocks non-specific sites of AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immuonelectrode for adsorption of OTA.
The electrochemical impedimetric response of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode has been investigated as a function of OTA concentration (0.5–6.0 ngdL−1) in PBS containing [Fe(CN)6]3−/4− with incubation time of 30 s (Fig. 3A). It has been found that the RCT value increases linearly on addition of OTA concentration onto BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode (Fig. 3B). The increased RCT value indicates blocking behavior of the redox couple. It appears that transfer of [Fe(CN)6]3−/4− redox ions is blocked due to formation of highly organized layers on the electrode surface because these redox species do not penetrate the layer and enter into the conductive electrode surface. In general, the charge transfer rate constant k0 indicates an electrical barrier that can be reflected by the electron transfer resistance of the redox probe of [Fe(CN)6]3−/4−. On exposure of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode to OTA molecules, the presence of an insulating layer formed on the electrode results in increased diameter of the semicircle, implying high electron transfer resistance. The diameter becomes larger and the charge transfer rate constant k0 diminishes. The EIS curve obtained as a function of OTA concentration has been simulated by electronic circuit Rs(QdL(RCTW) and the generated curves are represented as lines (red) to show goodness of fit in Fig. 3A.
Fig. 3 A) Sensing characteristics of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au bioelectrode as a function of OTA using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy technique in PBS containing [Fe(CN)6]3−/4−. Red lines indicate the simulated curves obtained by fitting model of proposed electronic circuit. B) Calibration curve obtained between the RCT (Ω) value versus OTA concentration (ng dl−1). C) Stability studies of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au bioelectrode. |
As shown in the Schematic (Fig. 1E), the free amino groups of BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode have the affinity to bind with the carboxylic group of OTA molecules. Fig. 3B shows the calibration curve obtained between RCT and the OTA concentration. A linear relationship between the RCT value and the OTA concentration is obtained as 0.5–6 ng dL−1. The linear equation obtained is: RCT (Ω) = 115 (Ω) + 36.83 Ω dL−1 ng−1 × OTA concentration (ng/dl). The sensitivity of this BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode obtained is 36.83 (Ω)/ngdL−1 cm2 with a value of the linear regression coefficient (r2) as 0.999. It was found that the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode shows improved characteristics such as response time as 30 s, good reproducibility (>20 times). The detection limit has been estimated as 0.08 ng/dl using 3σb/m criteria, where m is slope of the calibration graph and σ b is standard deviation of the blank signal. The high value of association constant (Ka, 3.96 × 1011 L mol−1) indicates high affinity of AO-IgG towards OTA to prevalent specific interactions.27 It may be noted that the conformational changes of antibodies affect the biological reaction that occurs at the AUT/Au immunoelectrode surface. The increased activity of the AO-IgGs onto AUT/Au electrode due to IgGs with favourable orientation resulting in enhanced interaction between AUT/Au electrode and the active site of AO-IgGs as indicated by the higher Ka value.
The RCT value has been found to change after the initialization of electrode with different concentrations of OTA. Thus, the sensitivity of the immunoelectrode can be determined with relative change in the RCT value.
Relative Sensitivity = 100 [RCT (x) − RCT (0)]/RCT (x) | (Eq. 4) |
Immunosensing Platform | Techniques | Linear Range | Detection Limit | Sensitivity | Shelf-life | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
16-MHDA | QCM | 50–1000 ng/ml | 16.1 ng/ml | — | — | 23 |
NanoCeO2 | DPV | 0.5–6 ng/dL | 0.5 ng/dL | 1.27 μA/ng dL−1cm−2 | 80 days | 27 |
CS-NanoFe3O4 | DPV | 0.5–6 ng/dL | 0.5 ng/dL | 36 μA/ng dL−1 cm−2 | 45 days | 28 |
CS-TiO2 | — | 1–10 ng/mL | 1 ng/mL | — | — | 29 |
Polyaniline-CS | EIS | 1–10 ng/mL | 1 ng/mL | 53 Ω mL/ng | — | 30 |
NanoZnO | EIS | 0.006–0.01 nM/dm3 | 0.006 nM/dm3 | 189 Ω/nM/dm3 cm2 | 45 days | 31 |
4-carboxyphenyl | EIS | 1–20 ng/mL | 0.5 ng/mL | — | 12 days | 32 |
1,6-hexanedithiol | DPV | 0.001–100 ng/mL | 8.2 pg/mL | 1.8 × 10−7 ng/mL | — | 33 |
AUT/Au | EIS | 0.5–6.0 ng/dl | 0.08 ng/dl | 36.83 Ω/ng dl−1cm−2 | 90 days | Present work |
The storage stability of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode has been determined by observing the RCT value at regular intervals of 10 days for about 90 days (Fig. 3C). The BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode is stored at 4 °C when not in use. It has been found that the bioelectrode exhibits a 95% response up to 45 days. After that, the RCT value decreases and reaches 82% of RCT in 90 days.
Attempts have been made to monitor response of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode in instant coffee samples (100% Pure Nescafe). During these experiments, the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode is dipped in the reaction mixture and an equal amount of OTA and instant coffee sample are added and are kept for 30 s. The EIS spectra have been recorded under similar conditions and the RCT value calculated according to software. It has been found that the RCT value of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode as a function of coffee remains the same as in samples containing OTA concentrations. Moreover, the RCT of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode changes when the coffee sample contains OTA and value of the RCT further increases as the OTA concentration increases in the coffee sample (Fig. 4), revealing that the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode shows additive effect.
Fig. 4 The bar chart of RCT values obtained for coffee sample with addition of OTA concentration. |
To estimate the specificity of the developed BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunosensor, the influence of aflatoxin (mycotoxin) was investigated using EIS technique. The specificity of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode was monitored using different concentrations of aflatoxin (1–3 ng/dl). It has been observed that the RCT value changes in terms of relative difference below 5% (Table 2). Therefore, the developed BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode shows high selectivity for OTA detection.
S. No. | OTA concentration (ng/dl) | RCT | OTA + Aflatoxin B1 concentration (ng/dl) | RCT | Relative Difference (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | 3.0 | 233.3 | 3.0 + 1.0 | 242.4 | 1.72 |
2 | 3.0 | 240.2 | 3.0 + 2.0 | 245.5 | 2.2 |
3 | 3.0 | 239.4 | 3.0 + 3.0 | 244.6 | 2.17 |
Anti-OTA antibodies (IgGs, 1 mg/ml) solution was prepared in 50 mM phosphate buffer {(PB), 50 mM, pH 7.4} and a 0.15 M NaN3 was used as a preservative. The OTA (Aspergillus ochraceus) solution was prepared in phosphate buffer (50 mM, pH 7.4) with 10% methanol and stored at −20 °C. A solution of bovine serum albumin (BSA, 2 mg/mL) was prepared in phosphate buffer (50 mM, pH 7.0) and used as blocking agent for non-specific binding sites. AO-IgGs were immobilized onto AUT-SAM by dispensing AO-IgGs (10 μL) by keeping these for about 12 h at room temperature. The resulting AO-IgGs/AUT/Au bioelectrodes were washed with phosphate buffer saline (PBS) (50 mM, pH 7.4, 0.9% NaCl) to remove any unbound antibodies. The prepared AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode was immersed in BSA for 4 h to block non-specific sites for OTA adsorption. The BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode was stored at 4 °C when not in use.
The electrochemical experiments with the AUT/Au electrode were repeated in triplicate. It was found that the results are reproducible within 1% variation, indicating that the AUT/Au electrode was stable and can be used at least 15 times.
The activity of the BSA/AO-IgGs/AUT/Au immunoelectrode was estimated as a function of pH varying from 6.0 to 8.0 at room temperature (25 °C). The high magnitude of current found to be maximum at pH 7.4 (data not shown) indicates that the BSA/IgG/AUT/Au immunoelectrode is more active at pH 7.4 at which IgGs and BSA retain their natural structures and do not denature. Thus all the experiments were conducted at pH 7.4.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2010 |