Shouyun
Yu
a,
Hiroshi
Ishida
a,
M. Elisa
Juarez-Garcia
b and
Jeffrey W.
Bode
*b
aRoy and Diana Vagelos Laboratories, Department of Chemistry, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA 19104, USA
bLaboratorium für Organische Chemie, ETH–Zürich, Zürich, 8093, Switzerland. E-mail: bode@org.chem.ethz.ch; Tel: +41 44 633 21 03
First published on 10th September 2010
One for all, all for one! A single chiral auxiliary and synthetic route can be used for a three-step (cycloaddition, auxiliary removal and fragmentation) preparation of enantiopure β3h, β2h and β2,3-amino acids (>99% ee). This approach works for a wide variety of both natural and unnatural side chains, provides access to either enantiomeric form, and can be executed on a preparative scale without recourse to column chromatography.
Oligomers of various β-amino acids stand out as the most studied and sought after class of unnatural foldamers. The three general classes of the constituent β-amino acid monomers, as defined by Seebach,1b are the β3h-amino acids, the β2h-amino acids, and various diastereomers of β2,3-amino acids (Scheme 1). Unlike peptides consisting of natural α-amino acids, which are widely available in enantiomercially pure form at a nominal cost, each enantiopure β-amino acid monomer must be synthesized from a suitable chiral starting material or by asymmetric synthesis.5
Scheme 1 Three-step synthesis of enantiopure βh3, βh2, and β2,3-amino acids by isoxazolidine fragmentation. |
For enantiopure β3h-amino acids, Seebach and co-workers have refined the Arndt–Eistert homologation of α-amino acids with diazomethane. This method is widely employed and is the basis for the commercially available β3h-amino acids,6 but it is not well suited to the preparation of monomers with unnatural side chains or configurations due to the requirement of the enantiopure, Fmoc-protected α-amino acids as the starting material. The plethora of catalytic, enantioselective approaches to β-amino acids are rarely employed in practice due to issues of protecting groups and sub-optimal levels of enantioinduction,5 although several chiral auxiliary based routes are useful.7 To be amenable for the preparation of oligopeptides the monomers must be obtained in >99% ee as their Fmoc-protected β-amino acids.
Other important and desirable classes include β2,3-substituted variants and, especially, β2-amino acids, which are even more challenging to prepare and specialized methods are often needed for each different side chain. The contemporary challenge of reliable routes to diverse enantiopure β2-amino acid derivates has been beautifully outlined by Seebach in a recent review.8 The leading methods utilize several different types of chiral auxiliaries.9 Asymmetric hydrogenation of aminoacrylic acid derivatives10 or enantioselective Mannich-type reactions11 have proven useful in certain cases but with limited versatility. Some β2,3-amino acids are accessible by alkylation of β3h-derivatives12 or by enantioselective Michael addition of nitrogen nucleophiles to acrylate esters.13,14
In this communication we describe a general, unified approach to the preparation of β3h, β2h and both like- and unlike-β2,3-amino acids in enantiomerically pure form (>99% ee). This approach works for a wide variety of side chains from the corresponding aldehydes, provides access to either enantiomeric form, and can be executed on a preparative scale without recourse to column chromatography (Scheme 1). The key starting materials are readily available on scale at a reasonable cost, rendering this protocol an attractive alternative to β3h-amino acids and a viable approach to β2h and some β2,3-amino acids.
Scheme 2 Fragmentation of isoxazolidine lactones to form β-amino acids. |
The cycloadducts were isolated with good to excellent levels of diastereoselectivity as solids that could be readily crystallized to high levels of diastereo- and enantiopurity (Table 1). Single crystal X-ray analysis confirmed the expected relative stereochemistry (see ESI‡), which follows the stereochemical model previously proposed by Vasella.19 The auxiliary could be removed with a variety of mild conditions, such as treatment with perchloric acid in acetonitrile, which allowed acid-sensitive protecting groups to survive. This two-step protocol was applied to several different aldehydes and the results are summarized in Table 1. Alternatively, the initial cycloadducts could be transformed prior to auxiliary removal, making possible the synthesis of precursors to a number of β3h-amino acids containing unnatural side chains (see Table 2 and ESI‡ for examples and procedures).
Entry | Isoxazolidine | dra | Yield (%)b | Yield (%)c |
---|---|---|---|---|
a dr of cycloadducts as determined by 1H NMR. b Isolated overall yield of cycloadducts; Number in parentheses refers to yield of enantiopure major diastereomer after recrystallization. c Isolated yield of isoxazolidines after auxiliary removal. d Overall yield for deprotection of N-Cbz and auxiliary removal. e Prepared from (−)−1. | ||||
1 | 87:8:5:0 | 93(56) | 73 | |
2e | 75:18:7:0 | 93(47) | 83 | |
3 | 86:9:5:0 | 96(59) | 58 | |
4 | 84:8:8:0 | 69(43) | 68 | |
5 | 83:11:6:0 | 95(50) | 47d | |
6 | 86:8:6:0 | 88(55) | 47 | |
7 | not determined | (71) | 71 |
Entry | Isoxazolidines | Amino acids | Solvent | Yield (%)b |
---|---|---|---|---|
a All reactions performed with isoxazolidines or their HCl salts (0.1 M) in the indicated solvent (1 mL) at 60 °C 12–36 h. b Isolated yield of amino acids or their HCl salts. c Prepared from (+)−1. d Prepared from (−)−1. e Overall yield for fragmentation and Fmoc-protection. | ||||
1c | H2O | 100 | ||
2d | H2O | 100 | ||
3c | H2O/tBuOH | 92 | ||
4c | H2O/tBuOH | 93 | ||
5c | H2O/tBuOH | 96 | ||
6c | H2O/tBuOH | 42e | ||
7c | H2O/tBuOH | 70 | ||
8c | H2O/tBuOH | 84 | ||
9d | H2O/tBuOH | 97 | ||
10d | H2O/tBuOH | 99 | ||
11d | H2O/tBuOH | 87 |
Simply warming isoxazolidines 5 in water leads to spontaneous fragmentation to β-amino acids (Scheme 2). The only byproduct of this reaction is cyclohexanone, which does not interfere with the product isolation and excellent yields are usually obtained following precipitation or removal of solvent from the reaction mixture. Every isoxazolidine we have tested to date provides the corresponding enantiopure β3-amino acid in good to quantitative yield (Table 2). It was also possible to prepare Fmoc-protected amino acids by treatment of the crude reaction mixture with FmocCl (entry 6 and ESI‡).
Entry | Amino acids | Acrylate | dra | Yield (%)b | Yield (%)c | Yield (%)d |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a dr of cycloadducts as determined by 1H NMR. b Isolated yield of cycloadducts; number in parentheses refers to yield of enantiopure major diastereomer after recrystallization. c Isolated yield of isoxazolidines. d Isolated yield of amino acids. e The fragmentation of isoxazolidines performed in H2O/tBuOH. f The fragmentation of isoxazolidines performed in H2O. g The cycloaddition was carried out in toluene. | ||||||
1e | R1 = iPr | 77:23 | 85(50) | 92 | 100 | |
R2 = H | ||||||
E-2d | ||||||
2e | R1 = H | 84:16 | 91(62) | 94 | 100 | |
R2 = iPr | ||||||
Z-2d | ||||||
3e | R1 = iBu | 85:15 | 88(61) | 91 | 99 | |
R2 = H | ||||||
E-2f | ||||||
4e | R1 = H | 84:16 | 90(57) | 92 | 100 | |
R2 = iBu | ||||||
Z-2f | ||||||
5e | R1 = Bn | 75:25 | 88(47) | 90 | 99 | |
R2 = H | ||||||
E-2e | ||||||
6e | R1 = H | 82:18 | 91(63) | 79 | 98 | |
R2 = Bn | ||||||
Z-2e | ||||||
7f | R1 = Me | 70:26:4:0 | 42(27) | 98 | 100 | |
R2 = H | ||||||
E-2b | ||||||
8f | R1 = Et | 71:26:3:0 | 75(43) | 99 | 100 | |
R2 = H | ||||||
E-2c | ||||||
9e,g | R1 = H | not determined | 59(39) | 93 | 100 | |
R2 = Et | ||||||
Z-2c |
Encouraged by these results for the synthesis of β3h-amino acids, we sought to extend this procedure to the preparation of more challenging β2h and β2,3-amino acids. The synthesis of the β2h-amino acid required the cycloaddition of a formaldehyde-derived nitrone with β-substituted acrylate 2, which can be prepared from the identical aldehydes used for the preparation of the β3-amino acids. Importantly, either the pure E or Z form of the acrylate can be accessed by known procedures from a phosphonate prepared in two steps from glyoxylic acid, cyclohexanone, and diethylphosphite.20 The cycloadditions were conducted by simply combining the aldehyde, acrylate, and chiral auxiliary in benzene or toluene and refluxing overnight (Table 3). Although the diastereoselectivities were slightly lower than those observed for the synthesis of the β3h-amino acids, we could isolate diastereomerically pure products in moderate to good yields. The E and Z acrylates provided diastereomeric cycloadducts that result in the opposite absolute configuration at the side chain position; thus, the D-gulose chiral auxiliary can be used to prepare both enantiomers of the β2h-amino acids (entries 1–6). When higher aldehydes were employed for the cycloaddition, either like or unlike 2,3-disubstituted isoxazolidines were obtained in good yield and diastereoselectivity (entries 7–9). In either series, removal of the chiral auxiliary was accomplished without difficulty by treatment with perchloric acid. The hydrolysis and fragmentation of these isoxazolidines to the β2h-amino acids proceeded cleanly and in high yield, although care must be taken to avoid epimerization (entries 1–6). Determination of the enantiopurity of the resulting β2h-amino acids derived from the free base isoxazolidines, analyzed as their Fmoc-protected derivatives, revealed that the products were isolated in only 80% ee for β2h-phenylalanine 6u and 90% ee for β2h-valine 6q. We eventually traced the epimerization to the fragmentation step, implicating the discrete intermediacy of II in the reaction (Scheme 2). After careful investigation, we found that epimerization could be almost completely suppressed by performing the reaction under acidic conditions. Addition of 2 equiv. HCl (aq.) or using HCl salts of isoxazolidines as precursors to β2-amino acids is sufficient to prevent epimerization. In our preliminary studies on the synthesis of β2,3-amino acids with this chemistry (entries 7–9), we were pleased that fragmentation of both the like and unlike-isoxazolidines proceeded smoothly to give the expected β2,3-amino acids in excellent yield.
For the purpose of developing and optimizing this chemistry, we have isolated and characterized the two intermediates between the aldehyde starting material and the β-amino acids. The crystallinity of the gulose-derived isoxazolidines makes it possible to prepare enantipure β-amino acids without chromatography or isolation of the intermediates. For example, 1.7 g enantiopure (S)-β3h-phenylalanine 6c (>99% ee) was prepared from acrylate 2a and phenylacetaldehyde. Likewise, 2.2 g (R)-β2h-phenylalanine HCl salt 6u·HCl (99% ee) was prepared from acrylate Z-2e and paraformaldehyde (Scheme 3).
Scheme 3 Preparative scale synthesis of enantiopure (S)-β3h-phenylalanine and (R)-β2h-phenylalanine without chromatography. |
Fig. 1 Overview of the synthesis of β-amino acids and their configuration from gulose-derived auxiliaries. The opposite enantiomers of those shown may be prepared from the L-gulose-derived auxiliary. |
To a solution of this cycloadduct (7.78 g, 14.3 mmol, 1.0 equiv.) in CH3CN (140 mL) was added HClO4 (60%, 3.6 mL, 35.7 mmol, 2.5 equiv.) at RT and stirred 15 h. The reaction was quenched by the addition of aq. NaHCO3, extracted with EtOAc (3×), and the combined organic extracts were washed with brine and dried over Na2SO4. After concentration under reduced pressure, the residue was dissolved in 2:1 (v/v) H2O/tBuOH (150 mL) and stirred 24 h at 60 °C. The resulting mixture was cooled to RT, the solvent was removed and the remaining solid was collected and washed with EtOAc to give (S)-β3h-Phe (6c) (1.72 g, 69% for 2 steps, > 99% ee) as a light pale solid.
To a solution of this cycloadduct (10.14 g, 18.6 mmol, 1.0 equiv.) in CH3CN (140 mL) was added HClO4 (60%, 4.7 mL, 46.6 mmol, 2.5 equiv.) at RT and stirred 15 h. The reaction was quenched by the addition of aq. NaHCO3, extracted with EtOAc (3×), and the combined organic extracts were washed with brine and dried over Na2SO4. After concentration under reduced pressure, the residue was dissolved in 2:1 (v/v) H2O/tBuOH (150 mL) and concentrated aq. HCl (3.1 mL, 37.2 mmol, 2.0 equiv.) was added, then stirred 24 h at 60 °C. The resulting mixture was cooled to RT, the solvent was removed and the remaining solid was collected and washed with EtOAc to give (R)-β2h-Phe hydrochloride (6u·HCl) (2.23 g, 56% for 2 steps, 99% ee) as a light pale solid.
Footnotes |
† Dedicated to Professor Andrea Vasella. |
‡ Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures and characterization for all compounds and preparation of key reagents and auxiliaries. CCDC 763138–763140. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/c0sc00317d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2010 |