Ge
Meng‡
a,
Kaiyue
Ji‡
a,
Wei
Zhang‡
b,
Yiran
Kang
b,
Yu
Wang
*c,
Ping
Zhang
d,
Yang-Gang
Wang
*b,
Jun
Li
a,
Tingting
Cui
a,
Xiaohui
Sun
a,
Tianwei
Tan
e,
Dingsheng
Wang
*a and
Yadong
Li
a
aDepartment of Chemistry, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China. E-mail: wangdingsheng@mail.tsinghua.edu.cn
bDepartment of Chemistry, Southern University of Science and Technology, Shenzhen, Guangdong 518055, China. E-mail: wangyg@sustech.edu.cn
cShanghai Synchrotron Radiation Facility, Shanghai Advanced Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Shanghai 201204, China. E-mail: wangyu@sinap.ac.cn
dCollege of Civil Engineering & Mechanics, Xiangtan University, Xiangtan 411105, China
eBeijing Key Laboratory of Bioprocess, College of Life Science and Technology, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing 100029, China
First published on 29th January 2021
Single-atom site catalysts (SACs) have been used in multitudinous reactions delivering ultrahigh atom utilization and enhanced performance, but it is challenging for one single atom site to catalyze an intricate tandem reaction needing different reactive sites. Herein, we report a robust SAC with dual reactive sites of isolated Pt single atoms and the Ni3Fe intermetallic support (Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC) for tandem catalyzing the hydrodeoxygenation of 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (5-HMF). It delivers a high catalytic performance with 99.0% 5-HMF conversion in 30 min and a 2, 5-dimethylfuran (DMF) yield of 98.1% in 90 min at a low reaction temperature of 160 °C, as well as good recyclability. These results place Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC among the most active catalysts for the 5-HMF hydrodeoxygenation reaction reported to date. Rational control experiments and first-principles calculations confirm that Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC can readily facilitate the hydrodeoxygenation reaction by a tandem mechanism, where the single Pt site accounts for CO group hydrogenation and the Ni3Fe interface promotes the C–OH bond cleavage. This interfacial tandem catalysis over the Pt single-atom site and Ni3Fe IMC support may develop new opportunities for the rational structural design of SACs applied in other heterogeneous tandem reactions.
Tandem or synergistic catalysis, in which the reactants are simultaneously activated by judiciously designed two or more distinct active sites, has been developed as a powerful strategy to improve the efficiency and selectivity of numerous homogeneous and heterogeneous reactions that cannot be easily catalyzed by a single active species.39–45 Thus, construction of multiple catalytic sites is a significant strategy to overcome the drawback of single reactive sites in SACs for multitudinous tandem reactions, such as dual single-atom site design.46–48 Besides, one of the crucial endeavors should be developing functional support systems to introduce single atom/support tandem catalysis. Taking this concept to the reaction of 5-HMF hydrodeoxygenation to DMF, the rational choice of the single-atom species and the unique support is crucial to realize the tandem catalysis of sequential –CHO hydrogenation and –CH2OH hydrogenolysis reactions. Currently, Ni–Fe bimetallic alloy catalysts have been demonstrated to have high selectivity in this reaction because of the oxyphilic Fe sites favoring the selective C–OH bond cleavage.8,49–51 However, their hydrogenation abilities are still unsatisfactory compared to that of many noble metal catalysts. In contrast, noble Pt-based nanocatalysts have exhibited superior activity in the hydrogenation of CO bonds, but are prone to break the CC bonds or furan ring, resulting in a loss of DMF selectivity.52–54 Recently, the single-atom design of Pt catalysts has been proved to be an effective strategy to tune their selectivity in hydrogenation reactions.55–58 Inspired by the above facts, a unique Ni–Fe nanocrystalline supported Pt SAC can be an ideal model to tandem catalyze the 5-HMF hydrodeoxygenation to DMF, where the hydrogenation of the CO group can mainly be catalyzed by the single-atom Pt site, and the C–OH bond rupture processes can occur on the Ni–Fe interface, and thus both the activity and selectivity would be guaranteed simultaneously.
Herein, to construct the Pt/Ni–Fe dual interface tandem catalyst, we develop a novel approach to accomplish synthesis of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC SACs derived from the PtCl62− adsorbed ultrathin NiFe layered double hydroxide (NiFe-LDH) precursor. The Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC sample exhibited remarkable 5-HMF hydrodeoxygenation activity (99.0% conversion within 30 min) and optimal selectivity (98.1% yield of DMF in 90 min) at a low reaction temperature of 160 °C, which is among the best results for DMF production from 5-HMF as reported in the literature. Moreover, in the sixth cycle, the Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC catalyst still maintained robust reactivity, further indicating its great potential as a candidate for industrial applications. Subsequently, a series of catalytic control experiments and density functional theory (DFT) calculations indicated that the excellent reactivity of the Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC SAC arises from the tandem catalysis over Pt and Ni3Fe interfacial sites, where the single-atom Pt site lowers the hydrogenation energy barrier of the aldehyde group, and the Ni3Fe interface accelerates the C–OH bond rupture process. Therefore, this work illustrates a successful paradigm for the rational design of SACs with multiple catalytic sites towards boosting the tandem hydrodeoxygenation reactions, which also shows potential application in other heterogeneous reactions.
To further verify the electronic and geometrical structure of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMCs, X-ray absorption spectrometric (XAS) studies at the Pt L3-edge, Fe K-edge and Ni K-edge were conducted (Fig. 2). As shown in Fig. 2a, for Pt in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMCs, the white line intensity, which reflect the Pt oxidation state, is lower than that of Pt foil, revealing the electron-richness of Pt atoms in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC compared to metallic Pt0. This phenomenon demonstrates the electron transfer from Ni or Fe to Pt atoms due to the higher electronegativity of Pt (2.20) than Ni (1.91) and Fe (1.83). The electron transfer characteristics were further demonstrated by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) measurements. For comparison, Pt nanoparticles supported on Ni3Fe IMC (noted as Pt NPs/Ni3Fe IMC; Pt content of 2.23 wt%) were also prepared and characterised (Fig. S6–S8†). As shown in Fig. S9,† the Pt 4f peaks of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC show slightly lower binding energies than Pt NPs/Ni3Fe IMC with characteristic peaks of metallic Pt (Pt0), indicating the electronegative feature of Pt atoms in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC. Pt isolated single atoms in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC were identified from the EXAFS spectra and the theoretical fitting results (Fig. 2d, Table S2†), and only the Pt–Ni/Fe shell at ∼2.2 Å was observed without any contribution from Pt–Pt scattering paths (∼2.6 Å) compared with Pt foil. This reveals that the Pt atoms are isolated and no aggregations exist in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC. Specially, the fitting results show that the coordination number (CN) of Pt–Ni/Fe in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC is ∼10.6. The unsaturated coordination of the Pt site testifies the enriched Pt element on the surface, agreeing well with the XPS result (Table S1†) that the Pt content on the surface of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC (5.12 wt%) is much higher than the total content observed from ICP-OES (2.1 wt%) and EDXA (2.2 wt%). The single-atom Pt structure was further demonstrated by wavelet transform (WT) analysis of Pt L3-edge EXAFS as shown in Fig. S10.† Compared to the WT contour plots of Pt foil (Fig. S10a†), the intensity maximum of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC (Fig. S10b†) arises at ∼8.0 Å−1 from the contribution of the Pt–Ni/Fe path and no intensity maximum of the Pt–Pt path (∼10.8 Å−1) is detected. Evidenced by AC-HAADF-STEM, XANES, EXAFS and WT analysis, we can draw a conclusion that Pt atoms are isolated, dispersed in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMCs and stabilized by Pt–Ni/Fe bonds with a feature of electron-richness (Ptδ−).
Fig. 2b shows the normalized Fe K-edge XANES spectra of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC and Fe foil, in which Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC exhibits a similar near-edge absorption energy compared to Fe foil, revealing the metallic state of Fe atoms in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC. Specifically, from the Fe K-edge EXAFS spectra and the curve fitting results (Fig. 2e and Table S3†), it can be found that the Fe atoms in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC are present in an fcc packing form with a CN of 10.7 ± 2.1, rather than the body-centered cubic (bcc) structure as Fe foil. Besides, the intensity enhancement and location shift (from ∼7.9 to ∼8.2 Å−1) in the K-edge WT contour plots of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMCs (Fig. S11†) compared to that of Fe foil also demonstrate the coordination environment difference of Fe atoms in these two samples. These results conform to the XRD and AC-HAADF-STEM analysis that the intermetallic structure of fcc Ni3Fe was formed without the existence of Fe clusters or nanoparticles. For the Ni K-edge, XANES (Fig. 2c), EXAFS oscillations (Fig. 2f and Table S4†) and WT analysis (Fig. S12†) of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMCs are very similar to those of Ni foil, indicating the metallic and fcc structure of Ni in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC. The smaller CN of 10.1 for Ni in Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC than Ni foil can be attributed to the finite size effect. All these results agree well with the XRD, AC-HAADF-STEM and HRTEM analysis as discussed above.
Typically, as depicted in Fig. 3a, the tandem hydrodeoxygenation of 5-HMF to DMF can occur through two reaction pathways.10,15 For one pathway (Path 1), 2,5-di(hydroxymethyl)furan (DHMF) appears as the primary product through the hydrogenation of the formyl group (–CHO) in 5-HMF. For Path 2,5-HMF is firstly converted to methyl furfural (MFF) by the hydrogenolysis of the hydroxyl group. Both of them are then followed by further hydrogenation or hydrogenolysis processes and DMF can be obtained. The hydrodeoxygenation reaction catalyzed by the Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC sample was firstly investigated at a temperature of 160 °C and H2 pressure of 1.0 MPa. As shown in Fig. 3b and Table S5,† Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC exhibited an extraordinary catalytic performance, in which 99.0% conversion of 5-HMF was achieved within 30 min and the DMF yield reached 98.1% after 90 min. As shown in Table S6,† the lower reaction temperature, higher reaction rate and DMF selectivity, and low noble metal consumption of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC make it one of the best catalysts compared to the results reported in the literature. In addition, during the whole reaction process, except for DMF, the intermediates of DHMF, 2-methyl-5-hydroxymethylfuran (MFA) and trace amounts of MFF, no signs of other compounds were observed. These results reveal the superior effectiveness of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC for the fast and highly selective hydrodeoxygenation of the oxygenic group (–CHO, –OH) in 5-HMF, without CC group hydrogenation or furan-ring-opening reactions. Moreover, it is also suggested that the hydrodeoxygenation reaction mainly follows Path 1 on the Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC catalyst. To further evaluate its cycling stability, the reaction was recycled six times (160 °C/2 h), and both the 5-HMF conversion and DMF yield remained at >99% (Fig. 3c). After the sixth cycle, the spent Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC catalyst was fully characterized (Fig. S13–S17†) and the results reveal that the morphology and intermetallic structure were well preserved and the Pt atoms were maintained atomically dispersed, indicating the outstanding structural stability of the Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC catalyst.
Subsequently, to understand the roles of the Pt single-atom site and Ni3Fe interface in the Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC catalyst for the hydrodeoxygenation reaction, a series of control experiments were performed. Accordingly, the reaction was firstly carried out over Pt NPs/Ni3Fe IMC. It is worth noting that, Fig. 3d, after 120 min of reaction, the conversion of 5-HMF attained 90.9%, wherein the corresponding DMF yield was 51.1% and remaining products distributed over MFA (19.9%), DHMF (7.1%) and some by-products (∼12.0%). Such inferior performance on Pt NPs/Ni3Fe IMC demonstrates that the Pt nanoparticle surface suffers from poor reactivity and selectivity sparking an assortment of side reactions (furan ring hydrogenation, ring-opening reactions, etc.), which conforms to previous reports.8,52,59 To further confirm the catalytic behavior of Pt single-atom sites, the Pt1/NiFe-LDHs SAC with the catalytically inactive NiFe-LDHs as the support was also synthesized and tested. The structure of Pt1/NiFe-LDHs was well characterized as shown in Fig. S18–S21† and the Pt content in Pt1/NiFe-LDHs is 1.3 wt% as determined by ICP-OES. As shown in Fig. S22,† Pt1/NiFe-LDHs exhibit obvious activity for 5-HMF hydrogenation to DHMF, with a 5-HMF conversion of 50.8% and DHMF yield of 42.4% after 2 h of reaction. However, this catalyst exhibits extremely weak activity for the hydrogenolysis of –OH groups with only trace DMF and other intermediate products presented. These results demonstrate that, compared to Pt nanoparticles, the single-atom design of Pt catalysts can suppress their catalytic activity for furan ring hydrogenation and ring-opening side reactions to a large extent, with specificity in high –CO hydrogenation ability but low –OH hydrogenolysis capacity. Thus, it can be inferred that the Pt single-atom site in the Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC catalyst can take responsibility for the –CO group hydrogenation in the 5-HMF hydrodeoxygenation reaction. To study the role of the Ni3Fe interface in the hydrodeoxygenation catalysis, the catalytic behavior of the Ni3Fe IMC sample was also studied. As presented in Fig. 3e, after 120 min of reaction, the conversion of 5-HMF reaches only 42.8% and gives a poor DMF yield of 15.7%, indicating the slow kinetics of the hydrodeoxygenation reaction over the pure Ni3Fe IMC surface. More importantly, the MFF intermediate with a high yield of 19.8% was detected, which reveals that C–OH dehydroxylation is preferred over hydrogenation of the –CO group in 5-HMF on the Ni3Fe IMC catalyst (Path 2). Therefore, we can infer that the Ni3Fe interface in the Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC catalyst mainly accounts for the dehydroxylation of –OH groups in the reaction of 5-HMF hydrodeoxygenation. The raw data of GC-MS analysis of Pt NPs/Ni3Fe IMC, Pt1/NiFe-LDHs and Ni3Fe IMC in 120 min reaction duration are provided in Fig. S23–S25.† Summarizing the catalytic results (Table S5†) elucidates that the excellent performance of Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC for the 5-HMF hydrodeoxygenation reaction can arise from tandem catalysis over Pt and Ni3Fe interfacial sites, where the –CO group in 5-HMF was firstly hydrogenated to DHMF on single Pt sites, and then, the C–OH bonds of DHMF ruptured on the Ni3Fe interface to form DMF.
To further understand the tandem catalysis process and the excellent activity of the Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC catalyst, we performed DFT calculations to explore the hydrodeoxygenation mechanisms on different substrates including Pt, Ni3Fe IMC and Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC surfaces. The calculated reaction pathways as well as reaction energetics are shown in Fig. 4, and the corresponding reaction equations are shown in Scheme S1.† For the hydrogenation process, the hydrogen atom is considered to be located at the adjacent site to the carbonyl group. Recent studies have also suggested that on Nickel and Platinum catalysts the furyl ring of the furanic derivatives can strongly interact with the metal d orbitals and the carbonyl group mostly interacts with the pre-adsorbed hydrogen.60–62 Generally, the conversion of 5-HMF to DMF can be divided into two tandem parts: the first is the hydrogenation of 5-HMF to DHMF; and the second is the hydrogenolysis of DHMF to DMF. On a pure Pt catalyst, the rate-limiting steps are found to be the dehydroxylation of DHMF (vi→vii) and MFA (xii→xiii). The calculated barriers (TS-a and TS-b, as marked in green areas) are 1.79 eV and 2.20 eV, respectively, which indicates that the dehydroxylation of DHMF and MFA is kinetically unfavorable over the pure Pt surface. However, the low hydrogenation barriers (TS-1 = 0.52 eV and TS-2 = 0.54 eV) have suggested that the Pt catalyst should exhibit high hydrogenation performance, which agrees well with previous observations.59,63 In contrast, we find that on the Ni3Fe catalyst the rate-limiting step is the first hydrogenation step of 5-HMF (iii→iv) with a high barrier of 1.25 eV (TS-1, as marked in blue area), suggesting the difficult conversion of 5-HMF to DHMF. However, for the selective cleavage of the C–OH bond, the Ni3Fe catalyst shows very low barriers of 0.73 eV and 0.93 eV for TS-a and TS-b, respectively.
Comparing Pt and Ni3Fe catalysts, we can find that the former is effective for the hydrogenation step and the latter is significant for the dehydroxylation step. Without surprise, Pt1/Ni3Fe, which combines Pt and Ni3Fe catalysts, shows significantly improved catalytic performance for the hydrodeoxygenation of 5-HMF. The barrier for the first hydrogenation step on Pt1/Ni3Fe decreases from 1.25 eV to 0.55 eV compared to that of Ni3Fe, and the barrier for the dehydroxylation of MFA decreases from 2.20 eV to 0.64 eV compared to that of Pt. The configurations for the first hydrogenation of 5-HMF and the dehydroxylation of DHMF on each catalyst are also shown in Fig. 5a and b. It is demonstrated that the aldehyde group on Pt1/Ni3Fe directly correlates with the single Pt sites, which accounts for the high activity for the hydrogenation step. For the dehydroxylation of DHMF, the cleavage of C–OH occurs at the Ni3Fe interface and the produced hydroxyl exhibits a strong interaction with the Fe site. This is confirmed by the cleavage energies of the C–OH bond (−0.36 eV on Ni3Fe vs. 0.85 eV on Pt). Our results suggest that the prepared Pt1/Ni3Fe IMC has combined the advantages of Pt and Ni3Fe catalysts and the tandem mechanism results in the high catalytic reactivity for the hydrodeoxygenation of 5-HMF, as schematically shown in Fig. 5c.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental details and supplementary characterization. See DOI: 10.1039/d0sc05983h |
‡ G. M., K. J., and W. Z. contributed equally. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |