Adem Hadjabdelhafid-Parisienabc,
Sebastian Bitschd,
Arturo Macarrón Palaciosd,
Lukas Deweidd,
Harald Kolmar*de and
Joelle N. Pelletier*abcf
aDepartment of Biochemistry, University of Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada
bCenter for Green Chemistry and Catalysis (CGCC), Montreal, QC, Canada
cPROTEO, the Quebec Research Network on Protein Function, Engineering and Applications, Quebec City, QC, Canada
dInstitute for Organic Chemistry and Biochemistry, Technical University of Darmstadt, Darmstadt, Germany. E-mail: Harald.Kolmar@TU-Darmstadt.de
eCentre for Synthetic Biology, Technical University of Darmstadt, Darmstadt, Germany
fDepartment of Chemistry, University of Montreal, Montreal, QC, Canada. E-mail: joelle.pelletier@umontreal.ca
First published on 22nd November 2022
We present an efficient approach for tag-free, site-specific conjugation of a fully glycosylated antibody using microbial transglutaminase (mTG). We created variants of trastuzumab where a single surface-exposed residue of the human crystallizable fragment had been substituted to glutamine, with the objective of enabling site-specific mTG-mediated conjugation with primary amine payloads. MTG reactivity was determined by conjugation to an amino fluorophore, demonstrating effective tag-free conjugation at the newly introduced I253Q site. The conjugation of one payload per antibody heavy chain was confirmed by mass spectrometry. We further demonstrated two-step mTG/click chemistry-based conjugation of I253Q trastuzumab with monomethyl auristatin E. Cytotoxicity and specificity of the resulting antibody–drug conjugate were indistinguishable from trastuzumab conjugated by another method although binding to the neonatal Fc receptor was impaired. The resulting fully glycosylated ADC is unique in that it results from minimal modification of the antibody sequence and offers potential for application to cellular imaging, fluorescence microscopy, western blotting or ELISA.
Various strategies have been developed to enzymatically conjugate antibodies and thus increase batch-to-batch homogeneity by targeting specific residues.8,9 One such enzymatic strategy entails the use of microbial transglutaminase (mTG) from Streptomyces mobaraensis. MTG natively produces an isopeptide bond between protein-borne glutamine and lysine residues. In lieu of a lysine residue, a wide variety of molecules can be used as amino substrates for protein conjugation. Polymers, small organic compounds and proteins have been conjugated using mTG for different applications.10–13 The isopeptide bond formed by this enzyme is stable in circulation and resistant to proteolysis, which represents an advantage for therapeutic applications.
Although mTG is widely used in biotechnology, the mechanism explaining its reactivity toward specific glutamine residues relative to others is not well understood.14 Of particular interest, despite IgG1 human crystallizable fragment (hFc) antibody displaying 8 surface-exposed glutamines,15 none shows reactivity towards mTG in the context of the native, glycosylated antibody (Fig. 1A). Conjugation to the surface-exposed Q295 glutamine residue that is conserved in the Fc of IgGs was previously reported for IgG1 (Fig. 1B).16 However, that process required deglycosylation of the neighbouring N297 residue. This requirement is detrimental for many applications of antibody conjugates since glycosylation is an important contributor to antibody stability and solubility.17
Several strategies have been developed to circumvent the need to deglycosylate the antibody prior to reaction with mTG. These include grafting a short glutamine-containing peptide (Q-tag) recognized by mTG as a substrate (Fig. 1C), the directed evolution of mTG to modify its reactivity, or direct conjugation on lysine residues of the antibody.18–20 However, the incorporation of Q-tags can disrupt the properties of the antibody and result in undesired immunogenic potential in the context of therapeutic applications, whereas use of the antibody as a direct amino substrate of mTG limits conjugation partners to reactive glutamine-containing peptide derivatives.21 Antibody conjugation to amino partners with mTG would circumvent these limitations.
We previously reported the glutamine-walk method to screen for reactive glutamine-containing substrates for mTG conjugation, following the substitution of single amino acids into glutamine in different proteins.11,22 This method was applied to the hFc of IgG1 antibodies. The hFc had been expressed in E. coli SHuffle T7 Express to allow for assembly of dimeric hFc by disulfide bridging. Two highly reactive IgG1 hFc variants, I253Q and Y296Q, were identified as effective mTG substrates for conjugation with amino fluorophores, suggesting that they may enable tag-free conjugation in the context of a complete, glycosylated antibody.22
Here, we demonstrate successful direct conjugation to glycosylated trastuzumab antibody produced in mammalian cells with an amino fluorophore, confirming that specific reactivity of mTG to the newly engineered site was maintained in the context of full-length antibody. We further demonstrate mTG-mediated chemoenzymatic conjugation of a cytotoxic payload onto trastuzumab (Fig. 1D). The resulting antibody–drug conjugate (ADC) was validated for its binding affinity and its cytotoxicity, demonstrating the applicability of this approach to conjugate glycosylated antibodies with minimal sequence alteration.
Conjugation with dansylcadaverine by mTG was performed as previously reported and analyzed by SDS-PAGE to rapidly visualize the reactivity of each trastuzumab variant.22 The I253Q trastuzumab variant displayed the highest labeling efficiency (Fig. 2) (4.9-fold increase relative to WT signal). The Y296Q substitution led to poor mTG labeling of the glycosylated antibody with dansylcadaverine (1.8-fold WT signal). The weak reactivity at this position was not unexpected since this newly inserted glutamine is the immediate neighbor of the IgG1 glycosylation site (N297). Our observation is consistent with the sugar moiety preventing mTG reactivity at Y296Q due to steric hindrance, similarly to the well-established lack of reactivity of the native Q295 residue in the context of glycosylated antibody.16 Glycosylated WT trastuzumab, negative control S254Q (no difference in reactivity compared to WT), and weakly hFc-reactive K340Q (0.4-fold WT signal) and P445Q (0.2-fold WT signal) trastuzumab variants did not lead to observable conjugation of dansylcadaverine by mTG under the conditions tested (Fig. 2). The weakly hFc-reactive M252Q and V282Q trastuzumab variants also resulted in weak reactivity (1.5-fold WT signal) in the context of trastuzumab. This confirms that the general trend of reactivity determined using the hFc was transposable to the full-length, glycosylated antibody.
We observed that activation of mTG by removal of its pro-sequence using trypsin instead of Dispase® was essential for efficient labeling of amino molecules to the I253Q variant of trastuzumab.23 We did not observe this distinction when using trastuzumab that is C-terminally labeled with the LLQG Q-tag (not shown). We speculate that the two extra amino acids (Phe42 and Arg43) remaining at the site of cleavage following Dispase® activation23 may prevent efficient conjugation by mTG at the I253Q site.
Encouraged by these results, we repeated the conjugation procedure to further quantify DoC by mass spectrometry analysis, using freshly prepared mTG and antibodies (Fig. 2). Analysis by LC-MS allowed observation of exhaustive conjugation of the I253Q trastuzumab variant with dansylcadaverine (DoC = 2) (Fig. 2).
MTG conjugation of the I253Q variant of trastuzumab was further investigated for the synthesis of an ADC by a two-step chemoenzymatic approach. Enzymatic conjugation of amino-BCN was followed by protein A purification to remove excess amino-BCN and mTG. Chemical conjugation of the BCN-conjugated antibody with N3-PEG3-vc-PAB-MMAE proceeded via SPAAC reaction. The progress of each reaction was monitored by HIC (Fig. 3). The mTG-conjugation of BCN resulted in the same conjugation efficiency (DoC = 1.7) as obtained above (Fig. 2) and MMAE conjugation was determined to be exhaustive. This demonstrates that the newly introduced glutamine is an addressable site for indirect conjugation of a cytotoxic payload.
To verify that the properties of the ADC resulting from conjugation at the newly introduced Q253 were not disrupted by substitution and subsequent conjugation with amino-BCN-MMAE, the binding affinities of the resulting ADC to HER2 and FcRn receptors were determined. Determination of ADC affinity for HER2 was analyzed by flow cytometry using the HER2-overexpressing SK-BR-3 cells, whereas binding to the FcRn receptor was measured by biolayer interferometry using non-conjugated antibody variants (Fig. 3). HER2 receptor binding affinity was not significantly perturbed either by introduction of the I253Q substitution (KD = 3.3 nM) or by conjugation to BCN-MMAE (KD = 5.0 nM) relative to WT trastuzumab (KD = 5.3 nM) (Fig. 3). This was expected since all modifications were undertaken in the Fc region of the antibody, which is not the primary driver of affinity.
Association and dissociation of antibody variants to FcRn were measured at pH 6.0 and pH 7.4, respectively; those conditions are typically used to elicit the known pH dependence of FcRn binding to WT IgG in the cellular context of the lysosome (association, pH 6) and in circulation (dissociation, pH 7.4).26,27 FcRn binding to trastuzumab, both for WT trastuzumab and the I253Q variant. Specifically, the WT trastuzumab exhibited concentration-dependent, specific binding with an equilibrium dissociation constant of 0.8 μM (ESI Fig. S3†), consistent with previous reports27 whereas the I253Q variant of trastuzumab was identical to the negative control, where no specific binding is observed (Fig. 3C and S3†). Indeed, it has been shown that interaction with FcRn is abolished by the I253Q substitution in IgGs.27 This implies that the mechanism of antibody recycling upon nonspecific intake cannot be achieved, eventually leading to a shorter in vivo half-life. Interestingly, FcRn-mediated antibody recycling can be maintained in a bispecific antibody by introducing FcRn-binding enhancing mutations in one Fc monomer, where the second Fc monomer is non-functional with respect to FcRn binding.28 This suggests a path forward to FcRn-mediated antibody recycling in conjunction with the I253Q substitution. Cytotoxicity and specificity of MMAE-conjugated I253Q trastuzumab are maintained.
The potency and specificity of the MMAE-conjugated I253Q trastuzumab variant were evaluated by cytotoxicity assays. HER2+ SK-BR-3 cells and HER2− HeLa cells were treated with serial dilutions of the conjugated antibody for 72 h to evaluate the cytotoxicity and the specificity of the ADC, respectively. Deglycosylated WT trastuzumab conjugated to MMAE using mTG by the same method served as a positive control (DoC = 1.8) and the unconjugated I253Q trastuzumab as a negative control. Cell proliferation assays on target SK-BR-3 cells (HER2+) showed no significant difference in cytotoxicity of the MMAE-conjugated I253Q variant (IC50 = 160 pM) and the positive control MMAE-conjugated deglycosylated WT trastuzumab (IC50 = 120 pM) (Fig. 4). Neither of the MMAE-conjugated antibodies was cytotoxic toward HeLa cells (HER2−), demonstrating that the HER2 receptor is necessary for efficient uptake of the ADC (Fig. 4). The unconjugated I253Q antibody had no cytotoxic effect on either cell type. These results indicate that the MMAE-conjugated I253Q variant of trastuzumab retained the same potency and specificity as MMAE-conjugated deglycosylated WT trastuzumab.
This conjugation method is appropriate for any application that does not require binding to FcRn, such as cellular imaging, fluorescence microscopy, western blotting or ELISA.30,31 In its current form, disrupted binding to FcRn limits therapeutic applications of the I253Q conjugates since FcRn-mediated half-life extension is crucial for antibody pharmacokinetics. As mentioned above, bispecific antibody design could be envisaged to include the I253Q mutation in one of the two Fc monomers to benefit from its chemoenzymatic modification without largely compromising half-life.32 Although beyond the scope of this work, the half-life of the I253Q-based ADC and the potential to include it in a bispecific antibody design in combination with enhanced FcRn binding should be investigated in subsequent in vivo studies.
In conclusion, our straightforward approach allows mTG-mediated site-specific conjugation of fully glycosylated antibodies with minimal sequence alteration. As the binding affinity for the HER2 receptor is maintained, the resulting conjugate is appropriate for many imaging and binding applications.
ADC | Antibody–drug conjugate |
DoC | Degree of conjugation |
ESI-MS | Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry |
HER2 | Human epidermal growth factor receptor-2 |
hFc | Human crystallizable fragment |
HIC | Hydrophobic interaction chromatography |
FcRn | Neonatal Fc receptor |
LLQG | Trastuzumab C-terminally tagged with the Leu-Leu-Gln-Gly peptide |
MMAE | Monomethyl auristatin E |
mTG | Microbial transglutaminase |
SPAAC | Strain-promoted alkyne–azide cycloaddition |
WT | Wild-type |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d2ra05630e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |