Ethan R.
Sauvé
a,
Don M.
Mayder
a,
Saeid
Kamal
a,
Martins S.
Oderinde
*b and
Zachary M.
Hudson
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, The University of British Columbia, 2036 Main Mall, Vancouver, British Columbia, V6T 1Z1, Canada. E-mail: zhudson@chem.ubc.ca; Tel: +1-604-822-2691
bDepartment of Discovery Synthesis, Bristol Myers Squibb Research and Early Development, 3551 Lawrenceville Road, Princeton, New Jersey, 08540, USA. E-mail: martins.oderinde@bms.com; Tel: +1-609-252-5237
First published on 27th January 2022
Energy transfer (EnT) is a fundamental activation process in visible-light-promoted photocycloaddition reactions. This work describes the performance of imidazoacridine-based TADF materials for visible-light mediated triplet–triplet EnT photocatalysis. The TADF material ACR-IMAC has been discovered as an inexpensive, high-performance organic alternative to the commonly used metal-based photosensitizers for visible-light EnT photocatalysis. The efficiency of ACR-IMAC as a photosensitizer is comparable with Ir-based photosensitizers in both intra- and intermolecular [2 + 2] cycloadditions. ACR-IMAC mediated both dearomative and non-dearomative [2 + 2] cycloadditions in good yields, with high regio- and diastereocontrol. Cyclobutane-containing bi- tri- and tetracylic scaffolds were successfully prepared, with broad tolerance toward functional groups relevant to drug discovery campaigns. Fluorescence quenching experiments, time-correlated single-photon counting, and transient absorption spectroscopy were also conducted to provide insight into the reaction and evidence for an EnT mechanism.
Photocatalysts based on heavy transition metals such as Ru or Ir have been studied extensively, due to their high ET, fast rates of intersystem crossing (ISC) and long-lived triplet excited states.1,9,10 However, these catalysts suffer from several drawbacks, including elevated costs, terrestrial scarcity and difficulty in removing the metal from the products. PCs based on more earth-abundant, first-row transition metals have been recently explored, addressing some of these concerns.11–13 Metal-free organic PCs, however, have become increasingly attractive alternatives, with many examples of strongly reducing or oxidizing PCs reported to date.14–20 Several approaches have been taken to increase the rate of ISC in these materials, including functionalization with heavy halogens, or the use of carbonyl-based PCs such as π-extended benzophenones.8
More recently, it has been recognized that materials exhibiting thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) can act as effective photocatalysts, as the design paradigm underlying TADF is intended to facilitate rapid ISC.21–23 TADF compounds are most commonly designed with a twisted donor–acceptor architecture, which increases the spatial separation between the HOMO and LUMO. This minimizes the electronic exchange interaction between singly occupied orbitals when the molecule is excited, reducing the energy gap (ΔEST) between the lowest singlet (S1) and triplet (T1) excited states. If ΔEST is small (<0.2 eV, or 4.6 kcal mol−1), ambient thermal energy can be sufficient to promote reverse intersystem crossing from T1 to S1, resulting in rapid interconversion between the two excited states. This paradigm has been explored extensively in organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs), where TADF materials can be used as emitters for efficient exciton harvesting.24–28 TADF materials have also been used as photocatalysts for cross-coupling,21,29,30 isomerization,21 hydroformylation,31 CO2 reduction,32 and atom-transfer radical polymerization.33 Furthermore, TADF materials that exhibit deep-blue fluorescence must have high triplet energies (ET > 2.7 eV, or 62 kcal mol−1), which can promote reactions that are initiated by an EnT mechanism.
Our group recently reported a series of imidazoacridine-based donor–acceptor materials exhibiting TADF, using structural constraint to provide emitters with narrow emission bands.34 These materials exhibit high triplet energies (ET = 58.2–69.9 kcal mol−1), long-lived triplet excited states, fast ISC, and visible-light absorption, while also behaving as poor oxidants. These properties make them attractive potential sensitizing catalysts for visible-light mediated reactions.
Cyclobutane-fused heterocyclic structures are synthetic targets that can be difficult to access due to the high strain energy and conformational rigidity imposed by the cyclobutane ring.35 Despite this, such scaffolds are found in a large number of pharmaceuticals and polycyclic natural products.36,37 Photochemical [2 + 2] cycloaddition reactions are a versatile method for accessing cyclobutanes, with recent examples reported by Meggers, You and Yoon.35–40 We recently deployed photocatalysis to promote intramolecular [2 + 2] cycloadditions and access cyclobutane-fused bicyclic42 and tetracyclic43 scaffolds from relatively simple, acyclic compounds. Those cycloadditions all rely on the use of metal-containing photocatalysts. Seeking to unlock the advantages of organo-photocatalysis, we sought out deep-blue TADF materials with compatible triplet energies for use as photosensitizers.
Herein, we show that imidazoacridine-based TADF compounds can act as effective high-energy EnT photosensitizers for [2 + 2] cycloadditions, promoting the synthesis of strained bi-, tri-, and tetracyclic cyclobutane-fused scaffolds. In particular, the high efficiency of ACR-IMAC (Fig. 1) as a triplet photosensitizer make it a suitable organic replacement for iridium-based photocatalysts in both intra- and intermolecular [2 + 2] cycloadditions. Near-quantitative yields were obtained in some cases, with high regio- and diastereoselectivity. Functional groups for derivatization and/or elaboration in drug discovery are well-tolerated, providing access to architecturally complex and versatile scaffolds by organo-photocatalysis using visible light. Finally, fluorescence quenching experiments, time-correlated single-photon counting (TCSPC), and transient absorption spectroscopy (TAS) are used to investigate the mechanism of photocatalysis in this system.
Fig. 1 Generalized proposed mechanism for photosensitizer (PS)-promoted [2 + 2] cycloaddition by an energy transfer process (left) and structure of ACR-IMAC (right). |
To date, the photosensitizing ability of imidazoacridine-based TADF compounds has not been explored in photocycloaddition and other organic reactions. We began by evaluating the competence of seven imidazoacridine-based TADF compounds that carry sufficient triplet energies (ET = 58.9–69.9 kcal mol−1)34 to promote the intramolecular [2 + 2] cycloaddition of N-allyl-N,1-dibenzyl-1H-indole-2-carboxamide (3) (ET = 58.7 kcal mol−1) to give the cyclobutane-fused tetracyclic scaffold 4 (Table 1).41PTZ-IMAC (ET = 61.2 kcal mol−1) promoted the photocycloaddition of 3 to form the desired cycloadduct 4 albeit in low 9% conversion upon irradiation with violet LEDs (λ = 400 nm, see Fig. S7† for spectral profile) in MeCN at room temperature for 18 hours (entry 1). The conversion improved up to 22% in the presence of PXZ-IMAC (ET = 58.9 kcal mol−1, entry 2) and TolCZ-IMAC (ET = 58.2 kcal mol−1, entry 3), respectively. Gratifyingly, 100% conversion to the desired cycloadduct 4 was obtained when ACR-IMAC (ET = 63.7 kcal mol−1, entry 4) was used as the photosensitizer. Surprisingly, CZ-IMAC (ET = 64.1 kcal mol−1), and TerCZ-IMAC (ET = 69.9 kcal mol−1), despite their higher ET, were both less effective sensitizers than ACR-IMAC (entries 4–8). The efficiency of CZ-IMAC and TerCZ-IMAC did not improve either by conducting the reaction with DMSO as a co-solvent or irradiating with a lower wavelength light (entries 4–8). It is noteworthy that the efficiency of ACR-IMAC diminished under blue light irradiation (450 nm, entry 9). The discovery of ACR-IMAC as an effective photosensitizer for cycloaddition prompted the design of CZ-Me-IMAC, which has improved solubility in MeCN. While the product conversion of CZ-Me-IMAC more than tripled that of CZ-IMAC (entry 5 versus 11), ACR-IMAC remains significantly higher-yielding. Control experiments showed that the cycloaddition reaction progressed only in the presence of a photosensitizer and light (entries 13 and 14). We also sought to benchmark the impressive performance of ACR-IMAC against TADF materials that have been previously explored as organo-photocatalysts. Although 3DPA2FBN, 4CzIPN and 3CZClIPN all possess sufficiently high triplet state energies (ET = 61.1–62. 7 kcal mol−1), none have been previously explored as a triplet photosensitizer in [2 + 2] cycloaddition reactions.11,42 We found that 3DPA2FBN, 4CzIPN and 3CZClIPN all promoted the cycloaddition of 3 to 4 albeit with lower conversion (entries 15–17). Finally, the use of a metal-based photosensitizer [Ir(dF(Me)ppy)2(dtbbpy)]PF6 (ET = 62.9 kcal mol−1)42 gave quantitative conversion of 3 to 4 (entry 18). These studies demonstrate that ACR-IMAC is an effective photosensitizer for promoting [2 + 2] cycloadditions and it is comparable to metal-based photosensitizers. Given that the TADF materials presented in Table 1 possess similar triplet state lifetimes,34 the high performance of ACR-IMAC may suggest a higher ISC rate compared to the others.11,32
Entry | Photocatalyst | E T (kcal mol−1) | λ ex (nm) | Conv.d |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Reaction conditions: a solution of 2 (0.5 mmol) and photocatalyst (2 mol%) in CH3CN (0.05 M) was irradiated with 34–50 W LEDs at 28 °C under an atmosphere of N2 for 16–18 h. b Measured at 77 K in 2-MeTHF as the onset of the phosphorescence E0–0 band. c T1 and T2 bands appear to overlap in the time-gated phosphorescence spectrum of TerCZ-IMAC; energy of the T2 band is shown. d The % conversion was determined by 1H-NMR spectroscopy from single experiments and a diastereomeric ratio (dr) of >99:1 was observed in all cases. NR = no reaction; Cz = N-carbazolyl. | ||||
1 | PTZ-IMAC | 61.2 | 400 | 9% |
2 | PXZ-IMAC | 58.9 | 400 | 22% |
3 | TolCZ-IMAC | 58.2 | 400 | 21% |
4 | ACR-IMAC | 63.7 | 400 | 99% |
5 | CZ-IMAC | 64.1 | 400 | 15% |
6 | CZ-IMAC | 64.1 | 365 | 23% |
7 | TerCZ-IMAC | 69.9c | 400 | 15% |
8 | TerCZ-IMAC | 69.9c | 365 | 19% |
9 | ACR-IMAC | 63.7 | 450 | 51% |
10 | CZ-Me-IMAC | 63.4 | 450 | 51% |
11 | CZ-Me-IMAC | 63.4 | 400 | 53% |
12 | CZ-Me-IMAC | 63.4 | 365 | 58% |
13 | — | — | 400 | NR |
14 | ACR-IMAC | 63.7 | — | NR |
15 | 3DPA2FBN | 61.1 | 450 | 64% |
16 | 4CzIPN | 61.6 | 450 | 22% |
17 | 3CZClIPN | 62.7 | 450 | 29% |
18 | [Ir(dF(Me)ppy)2(dtbbpy)]PF6 | 62.9 | 450 | 99% |
With the identification of ACR-IMAC as an effective photosensitizer, its general use for [2 + 2] cycloaddition was investigated. Dearomative and non-dearomative intramolecular [2 + 2] cycloadditions were examined in the presence of catalytic amounts of ACR-IMAC (Fig. 2). ACR-IMAC promoted the intramolecular cycloaddition in a high-yielding fashion that was comparable to Ir-based photosensitizers.41,42 Indole, benzothiophene, indene, and chromene derivatives tethered with an olefin all underwent a dearomative [2 + 2] cycloaddition in the presence of ACR-IMAC to give the tetracyclic cyclobutane-fused scaffolds in good yield (up to 99%) and with high diastereocontrol (dr > 99:1). The efficiency of ACR-IMAC was not impacted by the electronic nature of the substrates, as both electron-withdrawing and electron-donating groups are equally well tolerated (Fig. 2A). Similarly, ACR-IMAC was effective at promoting the cycloaddition of N-allylcinnamamines and an N-allylcinnamamide (8) to the corresponding aryl-3-azabicyclo[3.2.0]heptanes (9a and 9b) and aryl-3-azabicyclo[3.2.0]heptanone (9c), respectively, with high diastereoselectivity (Fig. 2B).40
We recently reported an Ir-based photocatalyzed methodology for the synthesis of cyclobutane-fused scaffolds via a dearomatizing, intermolecular [2 + 2] cycloaddition of heterocycles with a range of alkenes.42
The ability to promote this important but challenging intermolecular cycloaddition with an organo-photocatalyst would further broaden its application in drug discovery.
To our delight, ACR-IMAC promoted the dearomative intermolecular [2 + 2] cycloaddition of functionalized indoles and azaindoles with a diverse set of alkenes (Fig. 3). The array of alkenes studied that participated in the cycloaddition reaction included synthetic handles amenable to drug discovery programs, including acrylates (12a and 12k), vinyl alkyl ester (12b), allylic derivatives (12c–12e), vinyl amide (12f), and dimethylphenylvinylsilane (12g–12j). While the cycloadditions of indoles and alkenes proceeded in good yields with high regioselectivity and good diastereocontrol, the [2 + 2] cycloaddition of indole with an alkyne (13) did not progress. Similar to the intramolecular processes, the yields and selectivities obtained with ACR-IMAC are comparable to the Ir-based photosensitizers.41,42
Spectroscopic investigations were carried out to validate the proposed mechanism for the [2 + 2] photocycloaddition (Fig. 1), which was previously only supported with DFT calculations.41,42 We recognized studying triplet-mediated photocatalysis in TADF materials would be particularly challenging since they display both prompt and long-lived fluorescence lifetimes. Unlike metal-based phosphorescent PCs, where 100% of their emission originates from long-lived triplet excited states, the proportion of long-lived emission in a TADF material can, in some cases, be very small (<1%). Indeed, the delayed fluorescence of many TADF materials cannot be observed in solution where long-lived excited states are more easily quenched by molecular motions or collisions. In these situations, careful spectroscopic analysis in the solid state is required to verify that a material does, in fact, display TADF properties.
This is the case for ACR-IMAC, which displays 10% delayed fluorescence in the solid state at 298 K and none observed in solution.34 This delayed fluorescence originates from reverse intersystem crossing from T1 to S1, with the remaining 90% of the emission originating from prompt fluorescence from S1. As a result, a typical fluorescence quenching experiment, in which the emission of the PC is quenched in the presence of substrate, provides limited information about the reaction when ACR-IMAC is used. This complexity can be clearly observed when the TADF photocatalyst is compared directly to [Ir(dF(Me)ppy)2(dtbbpy)]PF6 (Ir-1), a phosphorescent photocatalyst used previously for [2 + 2] cycloadditions (Fig. 4).42
When both photocatalysts are treated with increasing concentrations of N-Boc-indole-2-carboxylic acid methyl ester (10a) under a N2 atmosphere, the phosphorescence of Ir-1 shows clear evidence of quenching (Fig. 4A), while that of ACR-IMAC appears unaffected (Fig. 4A and B). The high oxidation potential of N-acetyl indole (Eox1/2 = 1.2 V vs. Ag/AgCl)43 precludes a SET event and the observed quenching of Ir-1 (Ered1/2 [*IrIII/IrII] = +0.97 V vs. SCE)44 can be attributed to EnT. While this result would suggest that EnT mechanism is not operative if ACR-IMAC were a phosphorescent emitter, more careful investigation is required due to the low proportion of available triplets. We also note the importance of correcting these quenching data for inner filter effects, as the indole substrates used here are weakly absorbing themselves (see ESI†).
While nonradiative decay of the excited state of ACR-IMAC dominates in solution, the behaviour of the long-lived T1 state can also be probed by microsecond transient absorption spectroscopy (μs-TAS).45 Given the similar behaviour in solution of the other IMAC-based PCs presented here, TAS was used to probe their excited state lifetimes using excitation at 355 nm in degassed MeCN (Fig. 5A and S4†). ACR-IMAC (τ = 64 μs), CZ-IMAC (τ = 20 μs), CZ-Me-IMAC (τ = 36 μs), and TerCZ-IMAC (τ = 95 μs) all had excited state lifetimes on the same order of magnitude. Conversely, POX-IMAC (τ = 1.3 ms) and PTZ-IMAC (τ = 1.2 ms) had much longer excited state lifetimes, while the lifetime of TolCZ-IMAC could not be measured due to poor signal-to-noise from its limited solubility. Although these results alone do not provide a clear relationship between transient lifetimes and PC performance, we further explored TAS as a means to characterize the excited state behaviour of ACR-IMAC.
By monitoring the transient absorption profile of the photocatalyst both in the presence and absence of indole substrate, the effect of the substrate on the triplet lifetime of ACR-IMAC could be directly observed. As shown in Fig. 5A and B, transient absorption at 434 nm of a 0.2 mM solution of ACR-IMAC is quenched upon the addition of 10a in increasing concentration ranging from 0 mM (τ = 64 μs) to 50 mM (τ = 452 ns). Furthermore, plotting the inverse of transient lifetimes as a function indole 10a concentration yields a linear relationship, similar to what one may expect from a fluorescence Stern–Volmer quenching experiment (Fig. 5C). As a control TAS experiment, a solution of ACR-IMAC and 1H-indole (ET = 71.9 kcal mol−1, 50 mM)46 was measured; unlike indole 10a, the higher triplet energy 1H-indole substrate is found to not quench the excited state of ACR-IMAC (Fig. S6†). Overall, in conjunction with the high oxidation potential of 10a precluding a SET mechanism, these results collectively support the presence of an EnT mechanism for ACR-IMAC.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d1sc05098b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2022 |