Kristina Karalė*ab,
Martin Bollmarkb,
Antanas Karaliusb,
Mónica Lopesbc,
Oswaldo Pérezbd,
Roger Strömbergae and
Ulf Tedebark*b
aDepartment of Biosciences and Nutrition, Karolinska Institutet, Neo, 141 57, Huddinge, Sweden. E-mail: kristina.karale@ri.se
bRISE, Department Chemical Process and Pharmaceutical Development, Forskargatan 18, SE-15136 Södertälje, Sweden. E-mail: ulf.tedebark@ri.se
cSchool of Chemistry, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK
dFaculty of Pharmaceutical Sciences, University of Iceland, Sæmundargata 2, 102, Reykjavík, Iceland
eDepartment of Laboratory Medicine, Karolinska Institutet, ANA Futura, 141 52, Huddinge, Sweden
First published on 29th May 2024
Two novel bicyclo[6.1.0]nonyne (BCN) linker derivatives, which can be directly incorporated into oligonucleotide sequences during standard automated solid-phase synthesis, are reported. Stabilities of BCN-carbinol and two BCN-oligonucleotides are evaluated under acidic conditions. In addition, derivatized BCN linkers (non-acidic and acid treated) are evaluated for strain-promoted alkyne–azide cycloaddition (SPAAC).
On the other hand, strain-promoted alkyne–azide cycloaddition (SPAAC) was employed by several research groups as a copper-free alternative. Commercially available examples of such alkynes are dibenzoazooctyne (DBCO) and non-benzoannulated bicyclo[6.1.0]nonyne (BCN) derivatives. Even though DBCO is widely used, properties, such as high lipophilicity and the tendency to form a mixture of regioisomeric adducts, which is common to all dibenzofused cyclooctynes, limits the attractiveness of this type of click handle. As an alternative to dibenzofused cyclooctynes, BCN was introduced by van Delft et al.21 and an extensive number of studies were performed by the same group to enable BCN for biorthogonal labeling.2,18,21–23 On the other hand, the same authors assessed that BCN is incompatible with standard automated ON synthesis conditions (prolonged/repetitive acid treatment) which limits the versatility of the moiety2 and potentially is excluding BCN moieties from introduction in the 3′ end. It has also been reported that strained alkynes in BCN conjugates are labile to acidic conditions and prone to form inactive vinyl alcohol and ketone species.21
Compared to DBCO, BCN provides lower lipophilicity as well as a plane of symmetry which prevents the formation of regioisomers. While carbamates remain the most common and commercially available BCN derivatives, a few approaches were developed to equip BCN carbinol with other relevant functionalities.22–28 For example, an intriguing alternative to use BCN carboxylic acid as a reactive handle instead of BCN carbinol was quite recently presented by Rady et al.29 The stabilities of BCN amide and BCN carbamate were compared in various media. The results showed that BCN linked with a carbamate is less suitable for biological applications where prolonged incubation is required but BCN linked with an amide could be used instead.29 On the other hand, the less stable carbamate may be desirable in certain circumstances, e.g. prodrug design.30
The possibility to employ BCN derivatives directly in ON manufacturing seemed appealing to us even after having considered the reported limitations of BCN towards acidic treatments. There are commercially available BCN derivatives in phosphoramidite form, however only for terminal introduction, whereas we suggest BCN-phosphoramidite derivatives with a removable protecting group suitable for incorporation in ON sequences in multiple positions or prior to introduction of additional amidites. There are limitations for copper catalyzed click reactions of phosphorothioate ONs (at least in solution) and P(S) is the most common modification. Thus, fully P(S) containing ONs would be the best models for the two reported novel BCN-functionalized linkers (carbamate and amide based).
Stability studies of the BCN carbinol and BCN carboxylic acid derivatives were performed under acidic conditions typically used during oligonucleotide synthesis. In this study we intended to explore a procedure that allows the direct incorporation of multiple linker units into oligonucleotide phosphorothioates during automated solid phase ON synthesis and the further conjugation of the ON without post assembly derivatization. The ability of both linkers to participate in SPAAC reactions is demonstrated via conjugations with an azide derivative.
The synthesis of both linkers A and B started with the preparation of a common intermediate dimethoxytrityl-5N-[(methyl)-benzoyl]-aminopentane-1,3-diol 1 (Fig. 1 and ESI Fig. S1†). BCN carbinol was prepared from readily available starting materials using published procedures.31,32
The synthesis of linker A was started by activation of BCN carbinol (2) with disuccinimidyl carbonate.28 The obtained intermediate was then reacted with 4,4′-dimethoxytritylated compound 1 to give carbamate derivative 3 which was then converted to linker A in amidite form (Scheme 1).
Linker B was prepared using BCN carboxylic acid (6) as an intermediate. BCN carboxylic acid 6 was prepared by combining two reported procedures by Rady et al.29 and by O'Brien et al.32 The obtained carboxylic acid intermediate 4 (alkene,32) was brominated29 to 5 and used crude for the alkyne 6 formation. The purity of obtained crude 6 was satisfactory enough to continue for the next step and intermediate 6 was coupled with scaffold 1 using EDCI/HOBt to obtain the amide derivative 7 which, after purification, was converted to linker B in amidite form (Scheme 2).
When scaling up, we noticed that the yields of BCN carbinol were varying and were usually lower than anticipated with regard to reported yields in literature.32 Despite having the chromatography columns pre-treated with 0.1–1% TEA to neutralize any acidic groups, the yields of isolated BCN carbinol derivatives were rather low. Therefore, one possible reason for this problem could be the silica used for chromatographic purification. To explore this further, BCN carbinol, as the most studied member of BCN analogs, was chosen as a model compound to evaluate the stability of the alkyne functionality. First, BCN carbinol was evaluated by thin layer chromatography (TLC, ESI Fig S14†) to reveal if degradation occurs over time on TLC silica under ambient conditions. To investigate in more detail, the obtained degradation product was isolated. NMR studies revealed that degradation on TLC plate occurred due to both oxidation and hydrolysis (Fig. 2B, 1b). When using oligonucleotide synthesis conditions (under nitrogen, see below), only alkyne hydrolysis (Fig. 2B, 1c) was detected.
Fig. 2 Trend analysis of the stability of BCN carbinol. (A) Kinetic study of BCN carbinol degradation in the presence of solutions of TCA or DCA in DCM or toluene respectively using GC analysis. (B) Degradation products of BCN carbinol, identified by NMR 1b-acid induced hydrolysis and oxidation product (ESI Fig. S19†). 1c-acid induced hydrolysis product.21 |
The results (Fig. 2) showed that the BCN carbinol is more prone to degradation in the presence of TCA in either toluene or DCM corroborating the results reported by Gibson et al.2 Though BCN carbinol was marginally more stable in TCA–toluene solution (13% of BCN carbinol remained unaffected compared to 3.5% of unaffected BCN carbinol in TCA–DCM solution), the investigation revealed that DCA is a more suitable detritylating option for BCN derivatives since after 30 min there was 60% of BCN carbinol remaining in DCA–DCM solution and 79% in DCA–toluene solution (Fig. 2 and ESI Fig. S13†). In addition, the decomposition of BCN carbinol in the presence of TCA appears to follow first order kinetics with a reaction rate constant k = 0.11 s−1 in DCM and k = 0.068 s−1 in toluene. In the presence of DCA decomposition does not follow such a trend – after an initial drop, slow degradation proceeds in both DCA–DCM and DCA–toluene solutions suggesting that the stability can be acceptable for shorter acidic treatments with only low amounts of degradation. These results also indicate introduction of one or a few BCN scaffolds only at the 5′ end during ON synthesis to minimize the acid degradations.
The study was continued by further evaluation of the stability of the BCN moiety incorporated in the ON sequence using 3% DCA solution in toluene, which is a standard condition for dimethoxytrityl removal during solid-phase oligonucleotide synthesis. A column loaded with solid-support bound (A)2-T5 or (B)2-T5 was connected to the oligonucleotide synthesizer. The solid-support bound heptamer derivatives were exposed to five detritylation cycles each. After each acid cycle, 10 mg of solid-supported material was removed for LC-MS analysis.
In both cases (A)2-T5 and (B)2-T5, only minor degradation even after five detritylation cycles could be found (Fig. 3, ESI S19 and S26†). Analyses of both derivatives showed a major product with the masses corresponding to (A)2-T5 and (B)2-T5.
Fig. 3 RP-HPLC profile of (A)2-T5 after one (A) and five (B) detritylation cycles. 7.6 min: (A)2-T5, 7.1 min (A)2-T5 + H2O, 6.6 min: (A)2-T5 + 2H2O. |
BCN carbamate or amide derivatives revealed a similar stability (ESI Fig. S19† (BCN carbamate) and S26 (BCN amide)). In case of the (A)2-T5 synthesis, traces of (A)2-T5 + H2O and (A)2-T5 + 2H2O could be detected (at 7.1 min and 6.6 min respectively) even after one detritylation cycle (Fig. 3A). After five detritylation cycles this peak has increased (Fig. 3B), with the unaffected BCN derivative remaining the major product. A similar picture could be seen for the (B)2-T5 as traces of (B)2-T5 + H2O and (B)2-T5 + 2H2O were identified after the first detritylation cycle following the increase of the peaks after five cycles (ESI Fig. S24†).
Next, diBCN containing heptamers, (A)2-T5 and (B)2-T5 were evaluated for SPAAC. As a model compound, an excess of Fmoc-L-Lys(N3)-OH was added to LC vials containing BCN derivatives (A)2-T5 and (B)2-T5 in aqueous solution of 8.6 mM TEA + 100 mM HFIP (buffer A) and the reaction was followed by LC-MS (ESI Fig. S17 and S22†). As additional proof that the triple bond to a large extent remained intact after five cycles of detritylation treatments, both (A)2-T5 and (B)2-T5 were again reacted with azide-containing Fmoc-L-Lys(N3)-OH (Fig. 4) to give the desired bis-conjugates. The remaining intact BCN derivatives (A)2-T5 and (B)2-T5 underwent nearly quantitative conversion into the expected triazole adduct (ESI Fig. S20 and S27†).
In Fig. 4 the major peak (8.9 min) corresponds to the formation of the desired bis-conjugate. Traces of monoconjugate (not fully reacted starting compound still containing alkyne) is also detected at 8.3 min. The mass of the peak at 8.0 min (ESI Fig. S20D†) corresponds to monoconjugated derivative containing one hydrolyzed BCN fragment (+H2O).
To further determine if the BCN linker can be considered as a functionality at the 3′ end, i.e., survive additional 20–25 acidic cycles, both solid-support bound heptamers ((A)2-T5 and (B)2-T5 previously treated with five acidic cycles) were exposed to an additional 20 detritylation cycles. Although in this case the goal was to not to compare carbamate vs. amide, rather than to find the limitations of triple bond stability, both solid-bound heptamers were subjected to additional acidic treatments to determine the trend of acidic degradation. A sample of solid-bound heptamer (10 mg) was taken after 10 additional cycles (after exposure to 15 acidic cycles in total) and then after 20 additional cycles (exposed to 25 cycles in total). Samples were cleaved from solid support and analysed by LC-MS (Fig. 5 and ESI Fig. S28†).
Fig. 5 Distribution of (A)2-T5 and side products ((A)2-T5 + H2O and (A)2-T5 + 2H2O) after increasing number of standard detritylation treatments in percent of total peak area. Increased number of cycles also indicated additional degradation due to a noisier base line (cf. ESI Fig. S33†). |
25 detritylation cycles of (A)2-T5 resulted in substantial degradation of the triple bond (Fig. 5). Approximately 30% of the starting oligomer derivatized with two BCN linkers remained intact, clearly showing that standard detritylation conditions would lead to poor yields of an intact BCN handle in the 3′ position of an ON. (B)2-T5 proved to be somewhat more stable during 25 detritylation cycles (approximately 50% of starting compound remaining intact, Fig. 6). For an unclear reason, the degradation product when using a BCN amide derivative contains to a higher degree two water molecules whereas the BCN carbamate has to a higher degree one water molecule. Regardless, the use of either BCN derivative in the 3′ position is not considered to be satisfactory enough. Therefore, alternative building blocks containing handles more stable during automated solid-phase oligonucleotide synthesis would be desirable for introduction at the 3′ end.
Fig. 6 Distribution of (B)2-T5 and side products ((B)2-T5 + H2O and (B)2-T5 + 2H2O) after increasing number of standard detritylation treatments in percent of total peak area. Increased number of cycles also indicated additional degradation due to a noisier base line (cf. ESI Fig. S34†). 5* – the solid support bound (B)2-T5 after five standard detritylation treatments and stored at ambient temperature for 4 months. Additional 10 and 20 acidic treatments were performed on aged sample, giving in total 15* and 25* acidic treatments (DCA in toluene). |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d3ra08732h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |