Jiajun
Zhu
a,
Heyun
Zhao
a and
Wanbiao
Hu
*abcd
aYunnan Key Laboratory of Electromagnetic Materials and Devices, National Center for International Research on Photoelectric and Energy Materials, School of Materials and Energy, Yunnan University, Kunming 650091, P. R. China. E-mail: huwanbiao@ynu.edu.cn
bElectron Microscopy Center, Yunnan University, Kunming 650091, P. R. China
cSouthwest United Graduate School, Kunming 650092, P. R. China
dSchool of Engineering, Yunnan University, Kunming 650091, P. R. China
First published on 30th October 2024
The manipulation of the valley degree of freedom presents opportunities for both research and practical application. In this work, we theoretically demonstrate that the intrinsic valley anomalous Hall effect can exist in monolayer NbIn2As2Se2. Due to time-reversal symmetry breaking, monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 is an out-of-plane magnetization semiconductor with a Curie temperature of 232 K. The ability to induce phase transitions in the material through strain and the U value leads to different electronic states like the valley quantum anomalous Hall effect and the half-valley-metal state. The chiral-spin-valley locking of edge states and the band inversion of the d orbital of Nb at the K/K′ valley offer insights into the mechanisms behind these transitions. These findings not only contribute to the fundamental understanding of topology, spintronics, and valleytronics, but also pave the way for potential practical applications and experimental investigations in this exciting and rapidly evolving field.
Furthermore, the progress in valleytronic materials has led to a new insight into 2D ferromagnetic (FM) systems, known as ferrovalley materials.17–19 FM semiconductors inherently break the time-reversal symmetry, and when coupled with spin–orbit coupling (SOC), they exhibit spontaneous valley polarization phenomena.20 The quantum anomalous valley Hall effect (QAVHE) is easily observed experimentally in ferrovalley materials, making them have great application potential in information storage.21 Achieving spontaneous valley polarization requires out-of-plane magnetism, whereas in-plane magnetic materials are more commonly found in nature.22–24 Therefore, a difficult-to-modulate magnetic axis is necessary for realizing spontaneous valley polarization.25,26 To date, several ferrovalley materials have been theoretically predicted, including VSi2P4, VSiGeN4, NbX2, Fe2SSe, Nb3I8, 2H-VSe2, and GdI2.6,27–30 On the other hand, valleys combined with other physical properties can give rise to new physical phenomena, such as the valley quantum anomalous Hall effect (VQAHE), which emerges from the coupling between valley polarization and topology insulators (TI).31,32 Despite their high value, materials that combine the quantum anomalous Hall effect (QAHE) and the VQAHE are exceedingly rare. Consequently, the design of multi-functional multi-valley materials holds great significance in materials science and condensed matter physics.
Recently, a two-dimensional van der Waals material, MoSi2N4, with seven atomic layers, was experimentally synthesized using the chemical vapor deposition (CVD) method.33 The monolayer MoSi2N4 can be viewed as composed of monolayer 2H-MoS2-like structure MoN2 and bilayer silicene-like structure SiN, exhibiting K valley polarization phenomena similar to 2H-MoS2.34 Spontaneous valley polarization can be achieved by introducing magnetism to break the time-reversal symmetry. Here, we theoretically predict a 2D FM material, NbIn2As2Se2, with a structure similar to MoSi2N4. Based on first-principles, the monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 is a semiconductor with out-of-plane FM at U = 3 eV and has a Curie temperature (TMC) of 232 K. We also confirm that the VQAHE can be observed in this material. The material can achieve phase transition by applying in-plane biaxial strain engineering or adjusting the value of U. These findings indicate that monolayer intrinsic ferrovalley NbIn2As2Se2 holds promise for applications in spintronics and valleytronics.
This work was performed as implemented in the Vienna ab initio simulation package, which was based on density functional theory.35,36 The exchange–correlation interaction between electrons was described by the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof (PBE) type generalized gradient approximation (GGA).37 The energy cutoff of 500 eV and 13 × 13 × 1 k-meshes for Brillouin-zone (BZ) sampling were chosen. The calculation results of the convergence criterion for force and energy were selected as 10−3 eV Å−1 for and 10−6 eV. Due to the strong correlation effect, we use the GGA+U method in the 3d orbital of Nb element.38
To verify the stability of the material, calculations of the phonon dispersions of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 were performed based on density functional perturbation theory (DFPT) by using the PHONOPY code. The molecular dynamics simulation based on the NVT ensemble was conducted to demonstrate the thermal stability by using the Nosé–Hoover method at 300 K. A 5 × 5 × 1 supercell and a 3 × 3 × 1 Monkhorst–Pack grid were employed in phonon dispersions and MD simulations.
The FM Curie temperature was determined through Monte Carlo (MC) simulations using a 30 × 30 × 1 supercell and 108 loops with the Mcsolve code.39 The Fukui method was employed in the Berry curvature calculation using the VASPBERRY code.40,41 We calculated the valley Hall effect through the use of the WANNIER90 and WANNIERTOOLS packages.42,43
Fig. 1(a) shows the side and the top view of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2, which consists of Se–In–As–Nb–As–In–Se seven atom layers in a unit cell. The monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 structure can be viewed as consisting of three parts, in which the upper/lower part is a β-P-like structure InSe layer, the middle part NbAs2 shares the same crystal structure with 2H-MoS2, and the upper/lower middle layers are connected by In–As binding. It possesses a 2D hexagonal lattice which has P6m2 symmetry with space group no. 187. The monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 structure maintains the Mz symmetry about the Nb atom, which can lead to many novel properties, such as hidden physics. We consider the influence of the U value on lattice constant a, optimizing the lattice constants a for different U values, shown in Fig. S1(a) (ESI†). It can be found that the lattice constant a increases with the increase of the U value, from 3.918 Å to 3.950 Å.
To estimate the stability of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2, the formation energy Eform and the cohesive energy Ecoh were calculated through the equations: Eform = (ENbIAS − μNb − 2μIn − 2μAs − 2μSe)/7 and Ecoh = (ENbIAS − ENb − 2EIn − 2EAs − 2ESe)/7, where ENbIAS, μNb/In/As/Se and ENb/In/As/Se are the total energy of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 and the energy of Nb, In, As and Se atoms in a stable bulk phase structure or isolated state. The calculated values of Eform and Ecoh are −0.23 eV and −4.51 eV per atom for monolayer NbIn2As2Se2. The negative value of Eform indicates that monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 can be synthesized from the pure phase Nb, In, As, and Se elements. Our Ecoh is lower than the Ecoh values of some theoretically predicted two-dimensional materials, such as Cu2Ge (−3.17 eV per atom)44 and CeI2 (−3.14 eV per atom),6 indicating that the monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 is stable.
To evaluate the thermodynamic stability of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2, the phonon dispersion calculations and molecular dynamics simulations have been performed. Phonon dispersion can describe the dynamic stability of a material, which needs all phonons across the whole Brillouin zone. Fig. 1(b) clearly displays that there is no virtual frequency in the Brillouin zone at U = 3 eV, confirming the dynamic stability of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2. The MD simulation can evaluate the thermal stability of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2. Fig. 1(c) demonstrates that the structure remains stable for at least 7.5 ps at a temperature of 300 K. The Born–Huang criteria can be used to evaluate the mechanical stability,45 which requires C11C22 > C122 and C66 > 0 for a 2D hexagonal lattice. The value of the elastic constant is about C11 = 109.5 N m−1, C12 = 44.5 N m−1 and C66 = 38.7 N m−1 at U = 3 eV. We checked these values for the Born–Huang criterion and confirmed monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 is mechanically stable.
In order to define the magnetic ground state of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2, we constructed a magnetic configuration by using a 2 × 2 rectangular supercell in Fig. 2(a). The ground state of the system can be represented by the total energy difference (ΔE) between FM/antiferromagnetic (AFM) and nonmagnetic (NM) states and a graph of ΔE–U is plotted in Fig. 2(b), demonstrating that the system is in the FM state at different U values. Spontaneous valley polarization requires an out-of-plane magnetic direction, so it is crucial to understand the magnetic orientation of the system. Here, we plotted the MAE at different U values in Fig. 2(c), which can be calculated as EMAE = E100 − E001 within GGA+SOC+U. The MAE can determine magnetic anisotropy, where a positive value indicates out-of-plane magnetism as the ground state, while a negative value indicates in-plane magnetism as the ground state. In the range of U = 0–3 eV, in-plane magnetism is the ground state. As the U value increases (U ≥ 3), the magnetic direction changes from in-plane to out-of-plane. Therefore, in the following discussion, our calculation results are primarily obtained under the condition of U = 3 eV. The magnetic moment is a crucial parameter in a ferromagnetic system, with the magnetism primarily originating from the Nb atom in our materials. Hence, we employed two methods, namely the electron localization function (ELF) and Bader charge, to analyze the environment surrounding the Nb atom. Fig. S1(b) (ESI†) illustrates the ELF in the (110) plane of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2. The Nb atom has a lower electron density, in contrast to the Se atom which has a higher electron density, indicative of an ionic bond between Nb and Se atoms, implying a transfer of charge from Nb to Se. Through Bader charge analysis, it was verified that Nb atoms transferred 0.6 electrons to each Se atom. Consequently, the calculation results indicate a magnetic moment per Nb of 1μB at U = 3 eV.
T MC is an important parameter in magnetic materials, which can be estimated using the Heisenberg model:
(1) |
EFM = E0 − 6JS2 | (2) |
EAFM = E0 + 2JS2 | (3) |
(4) |
The calculated normalized J is 74.9 meV at U = 3 eV, and the normalized magnetic moment and auto-correlation vs. temperature are plotted in Fig. 2(d). The predicted TMC is 232 K. On the other hand, the transition temperature can be expressed as by using the mean-field approximation (MFA), where J and KB are the nearest-neighboring exchange parameter and Boltzmann constant, respectively. The value of TMFC is 579 K, which is higher than TMC (232 K). Fig. S2 (ESI†) shows the TMC of NbIn2As2Se2 at different values of U and the result that the TMC decreases as the U value increases.
Fig. 3(a) shows the spin polarized band structure of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 without the SOC effect. It can be seen that both the conduction band (CB) and the valence band (VB) near the Fermi level come from the spin-up channel for M↑. When the magnetic direction changes to M↓, as shown in Fig. S4 (ESI†), the CB and VB come from the spin-down channel, which is in contrast to the result when the magnetic direction is M↑. Theoretical calculations reveal that the conduction band minimum (CBM) and valence band maximum (VBM) both reside at the K or K′ point, with a band gap value of 104 meV, indicating that monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 is a FM semiconductor. When the inversion symmetry is broken, the two K valleys will no longer be equal. Under the effect of the SOC, bands at the K and K′ points experience a shift, resulting in spontaneous valley polarization. The calculated band gap value is 29 meV at the K point, which is lower than the band gap of 182 meV at the K′ point, as depicted in Fig. 3(b). As shown in Fig. S3 (ESI†), external magnetic fields can be used to control band gap. When the magnetic direction becomes M(↓), both the VB and CB near the Fermi surface come from the spin-down channel, and the band gap values at K and K′ points are exchanged.
The above results confirm that the monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 is a FM semiconductor with an out-of-plane magnetic orientation. In the presence of SOC, it can spontaneously generate valley polarization. As is well-known, the SOC effects can be written as
Ĥsoc = αz | (5) |
(6) |
Eτ = 〈ϕτ|Ĥsoc|ϕτ〉 | (7) |
Therefore, due to the SOC effect, the dx2−y2 and dxy orbitals near the Fermi level shift, resulting in different energy eigenvalues and leading to spontaneous valley polarization, which can be expressed as
(8) |
The above equation helps us understand that valley polarization arises from the SOC effect causing the degenerate K/K′ valleys to shift, resulting in the two valleys no longer being equivalent.
In 2D materials, the Chern number C can be used to characterize the quantum anomalous Hall effect, which can be expressed as46,47
(9) |
(10) |
In order to understand the relationship between strain and electronic structure, we apply biaxial in-plane strain in the system monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 and plot the band gap at the K or K′ valley as a function of strain ε in Fig. 5(a). Under the influence of strain, it can be observed that the system undergoes a transition from a half-metal to a TI to a half-metal. Notice that the systems transform into a half-valley-material (HVM) state at ε = 0.5%. This state means that one valley is a semiconductor and the other is a metal. When strain ε > 1.4%, the value of band gap at the K or K′ valley increases and few electrons occupy the CB at the K valley, and the systems become half-metal. Akin to tensile strain, as compressive strain increases, the system transitions to a half-metal state at ε = −2%. Until the strain is greater than −2%, few electrons occupy the VB at the K′ valley, and the systems become half-metal. As shown in Fig. S4 (ESI†), the dz2 and dx2−y2 at K and K′ have a competitive relationship via strain engineering. The inversion of the dz2 and dx2−y2 orbitals occurs at the valleys at the K or K′ point after a process of closing and reopening. This process can be explained by the deformation of Nb atoms under strain. Tensile strain reduces the overlap between the dz2 orbital of Nb and the pz orbital of Se, while compressive strain increases the overlap between the dz2 orbital of Nb and the pz orbital of Se, resulting in a decrease in energy during tension and an increase in energy during compression.
We have also considered the influence of the U value on the band gap at the K or K′ valley, plotted in Fig. 5(b). It clearly demonstrates that monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 is in the ferrovalley phase for U = 0.0–2.2 or 3.4–4.0 eV and in the TI phase for U = 2.2–3.4 eV, and the corresponding topological edge states are shown in Fig. S6 (ESI†). On the other hand, the U value can also regulate the band gap value at the K or K′ valley. As the U value increases, the band gap at the K or K′ valley will undergo a process of opening–closing–opening state. Similar to strain engineering, when U = 2.2 or 3.4 eV, the band gap at the K or K′ point closes, and monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 exhibits HVM behavior. We have also observed that the system transitions from the TI state to a ferrovalley state after passing through the HVM state, which is akin to strain effects. The results above demonstrate two methods to manipulate the performance of monolayer NbIn2As2Se2, thereby enhancing its potential applications in spintronic devices.
In summary, monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 is confirmed to be a ferrovalley material with TI via first-principles calculations. We discussed the structural stability in terms of energy, phonon dispersion, molecular dynamics, and mechanical properties. The FM state is the ground state for monolayer NbIn2As2Se2 with a TMC of 232 K at U = 3 eV, and the MAE confirms the out-of-plane magnetization direction, thus inducing spontaneous valley polarization. As the system exhibits the VQAHE, reversing the magnetic direction allows for the observation of chiral spin-valley edge states. Strain engineering and the U value can control the state of the system, such as the half-metal, TI and ferrovalley states. Our work provides theoretical guidance for exploring interactions among the FM, valleys, and TI, and offers candidate materials for valleytronic devices.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4tc03637a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |